3 ms·
I think the blog post is written quite oddly, in a way that makes it hard to engage with in good faith. The central question is: “Should we tell people that civ
by bee_rider 3y ago
I think the blog post is written quite oddly, in a way that makes it hard to engage with in good faith. The central question is: “Should we tell people that civilization is doomed.” It is on a page called collapsemusings, the audience apparently believes that civilization is doomed already, this doesn’t seem to be a point in contention for the intended audience.
Despite this, it runs through a big list of supposedly civilization-killing effects. These are’t really linked together, it is just problem after problem, joined by phrases along the lines of “if that doesn’t get us, this next thing will.” This makes it very hard to respond to. The author also doesn’t make a concrete link between many of these bad things and the end of civilization. I can show an example, but it is just one in a list.
> Pollution and habitat destruction are mutilating the tree of life. Once the insects are mostly gone and the topsoil is mostly dead, we will no longer have the ability to grow food on a mass scale, and it will be game over for modern civilization. But it gets even worse…
The article linked the “mostly dead” claim is:
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/30/topsoil-farming-agriculture-food-toxic-america https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/30/topsoil-farm...
It includes dire news like:
> Amid growing concerns about topsoil loss, no-till and cover crops are becoming more popular, according to the 2017 US Census of Agriculture. Forty per cent of US cropland is grown on no-till farms, up from 32% in 2012.
> Though still not widely adopted, cover crops are becoming more popular with farmers, too, particularly in the country’s corn belt. Nationwide, farmers planted cover crops on 15m acres, a 50% increase from five years earlier.
Oh wait no, actually the article says this is a problem but solutions are starting to emerge on the market (already, as of 4 years ago). And, would this actually threaten civilization itself? We have a lot of extra food in the Americas, and lots of food waste…
But that’s just one suggestion of many. Maybe one is actually compelling. The list is too long for a mildly interested outsider to research each one in detail. This is a failure on the part of the blog post, assuming the intended audience is people who don’t buy into the premise already—and if not, why list the possible causes in the first place?. Just start with “assume for the sake of argument that civilization is doomed.”
- jonnycomputer 3y agoYes. This. The Dust Bowl of the 1930s (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dust_Bowl) was pretty apocalyptic, and caused by a combination of drought and bad farming practices. It's clear things can go badly. On the other hand, we've adapted and learned since then. I'm enthusiastic about the potential for AI and robotics to make farming more humane and less environmentally destructive while still keeping yields high (e.g. no till, with targeted use of pesticides and fertilizers).