3 ms·
> the applications of QC is limited to specific domains. Breaking crypto alone would make it worth its weight in gold.
by echelon 3y ago
> the applications of QC is limited to specific domains.
Breaking crypto alone would make it worth its weight in gold.
- shwouchk 3y agoDo you forsee any sort of positive impact from destroying the ability to transact online?
- echelon 3y agoIf it's shown to be fundamentally unsound, then we shouldn't be doing it. Society will adapt, as it always does. For some time, I'm sure state actors will derive incredible utility from limited access to the tools.
- shwouchk 3y agoLet’s apply that same argument to global thermonuclear war.
- echelon 3y agoWithout a global government or geopolitically stable world, there's no way to unwind it. All countries have different resources and needs and views, so nobody will disarm. Only MAD. I'd like to double down on my previous statement: if cryptography becomes impossible due to some fundamental property of the universe, then there's nothing to be done. We're where we are today because of a fluke, and that's it. Once the dam bursts, it's over. Maybe that happens, maybe that doesn't. Maybe there's something else we can base our secrets on.
- shwouchk 3y agoNot sure I follow your point re global government, so I’ll return to your double down. If there’s a fundamental property of the universe that disallows public cryptography then it’s a fact of life. What baffles me is someone’s desire to reach that state sooner rather later, given how much current global civilization depends on it. In the same vein, global warming is a fact of life since in a few million years the sun will engulf the earth. Yet I’ve yet to hear a sentiment describing it as a desirable state of affairs, because “the free energy alone would be worth its weight in gold”.
- skywhopper 3y agoSometimes, emergency adaptation does not go particularly well for the individuals involved.
- n4r9 3y agoI can see a positive impact in doing so publicly and in advance of malicious or government actors doing it in secret.
- bawolff 3y agoWe already have options that are quantum resistant (just not as well tested as we would like). There will probably be a short intermediate period where qc can break like 128 bit rsa keys but not 4096 bit. The moment that happens everyone will switch to other algos very quickly. Its not like its all that different from the situation with md5 or the current situation with sha1. The world survived. A few people got hacked... but that was very much the exception and mostly software migrated to new algos. Personally i think quantum simulation is a much more interesting application than factoring.
- tux3 3y ago>everyone will switch to other algos very quickly Yeah. If by everyone we mean open source repos. Big companies outside of the tech top 10 have just finished the meeting phase to plan a transition from RC4 to triple DES It will take decades. And all the smart IoT crap will stay frozen in time, keeping botnets fed and healthy
- bawolff 3y agoAt the very least it wont be that much more of a shit-show than the present.