6 ms·
The unfortunate math behind consulting companies (2011)
- michaelrpeskin 3y agoYes. My company bills me out at roughly 3x what I see. And when I do a side project for someone, I bill the same 3x rate - and even though it's more money in my pocket than my day job, it's more hassle and not clearly a better arrangement (which is why I still work a day job).
- zwaps 3y agoMy consulting company bills me out at a much higher multiple than that in my gross salary
- iancmceachern 3y agoYou should start working for yourself. If you want advice/help on how to start, my contact info is in my bio. I used to be in that boat, now I'm in this boat.
- analog31 3y agoI'm a part time freelance musician, and oddly enough there's a similar situation in the music business. Bandleaders have to pay the musicians a reasonable cut of the proceeds from gigs, or the musicians will split off and form their own band.
- em-bee 3y agowhen i work for myself the number of billable hours is cut in half due to the overhead of finding and negotiating new projects. i am in that boat and i have trouble keeping it afloat. i'd rather take a cut and work with an agency or a partner that finds the projects for me.
- iancmceachern 3y agoI've been working on streamlining these things for myself, given the exact same pain points and limitations, and would be happy to share what I've learned. My contact info is in my bio.
- bsmith 3y agoI'd like to hear more. It would be nice of you to write it in a comment to share with others that are interested instead of requesting DMs :)
- iancmceachern 3y agoI'm not requesting DMs. I'm not comfortable sharing many specific details about my business publicly, in this forum. But I am comfortable sharing them with people who are where I was and want to get where I am. I'm happy to. I'm sure you understand. In service of answering your question anyway. I'm a hardware product design engineer. I can take ownership over an entire complex piece of hardware (medical device, IT product, etc) and architect it, design it mechanically, electrically and do the systems engineering. I'm able to deliver entire complex hardware products that work well (more than well), can be mass manufactured, and meet cost targets. I've designed surgical robotics systems, artificial hearts and other class III implanted devices, stuff in the disney parks, times square and even the Smithsonian. I have a website about myself with more information at www.iancollmceachern.com
- cbsmith 3y agoAnother alternative is to hire someone to manage the overhead and/or work on finding & negotiating new projects.
- em-bee 3y agohow does one get started with this? with an agency they already have a track record and they also have multiple people they can draw on so if they have a project they can manage it with low risk. for an individual partner we need to get to know each other first, and then that person needs to be willing to only get paid when a project is successful, because otherwise i'd face having to pay a full salary from the start before we even have the first project. how does one find such a person?
- wodenokoto 3y agoI agree. In my experience, the company adds a lot of value to me. They help with writing CV (if not flat out write them) they do cold calling, and set up meetings, meaning when I go interview with a potential client, they are almost already on board to have me. They give me access to knowledge of all my colleagues (“have you worked with using tech X to solve problem Y?”), they handle taxes and billing, office and they pay me when there aren’t any clients.
- wslh 3y agoI have a company that includes consulting offerings and while the article points resonate with me and know that real consulting is complex and a craft, the article is too general and more oriented to personal consulting that a business around that. For example, in our case, several consulting work could be seen as presales for other services and/or products while other companies take it as business marketing and sale expenses. If you see consulting in this way, the picture changes dramatically and from the finances/accounting point of view you are converting expenses into income.
- genmud 3y agoYea, but that type of consulting is typically billed as professional services(or similar), not advisory work. If product companies are smart, they might put this role under costs to acquire customer vs services and then have it as a fee for onboarding. I can’t remember the details, but I’ve been told having really profitable services can really complicate VC/fundraising.
- wslh 3y agoSorry, I didn't understand what is the argument bhind your first paragraph: advisory vs. consulting. Regarding your second paragraph, investors looking for the the YC startup definition don't like services companies because they couldn't scale at the pace of product companies but they are specific investors oriented to these companies because they have a more secured cashflow. BTW, some people like Michael Cusumano [1] argued about hybrid companies to better handling economic cycles. [1] https://mitsloan.mit.edu/faculty/directory/michael-a-cusumano https://mitsloan.mit.edu/faculty/directory/michael-a-cusuman...
- PaulAJ 3y agoAlso missing from this are: * The time you spend managing and supervising, including desk-checking the stuff they send out, because it goes out under your name and you are only as good as your last job. * IT costs, and office space if they aren't working from home. * Liability insurance in case they screw up. (Not certain about this: maybe you just trust that your company is a sufficient legal firewall because its only asset is you). I remember back around 1990 hearing that for my big company employer putting a coder in a seat in front of a computer cost roughly twice their salary. That's still true today.
- davedx 3y agoAbout liability insurance: yes, often bigger clients insist on this. It’s not a huge cost though
- greggsy 3y agoIt’s only 1% of my gross income (before tax) as a freelancer. I’ve never seen or heard of it being exercised in my sector (management consulting / cyber), but to be honest it’s a small price for peace of mind in case things do go pear shaped.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIs that liability, or also Errors and Omissions?
- cbsmith 3y agoIIRC, Errors & Omissions insurance is often called "professional liability insurance".
- iancmceachern 3y agoExactly, many businesses require this anyway, like if you lease an office.
- jenadine 3y ago
- dang 3y agoDiscussed at the time: The unfortunate math behind consulting companies - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2189166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2189166 - Feb 2011 (125 comments)
- 01100011 3y agoSome bad takes in that old discussion. "Consulting doesn't scale" "Sure it does, just look at Accenture!" No, Accenture is big because consulting is not very profitable and it's easy for Accenture to accumulate smaller shops for the bodies. Sooner or later, people running smaller shops get bored and sell to companies like Accenture. Big companies can also more easily leverage foreign, low-cost labor and provide a complete solution. It's hard to provide a complete solution, including QA/testing, test writing, documentation, etc if you are a small body shop with 10x engineers that you need to bill out at $400/hr. Accenture will never come close to the profit per employee of a company like Google or Meta due to the poor scaling.
- cbsmith 3y agoI'm always confused by the different properties people imbue with the term "scale". Accenture is an example that consulting does scale by definition, because it's a profitable business that is operating at a much larger scale. It just that when it scales, the profit tends to grow linearly, or even sub linearly. This is in contrast with businesses like Google or Meta where the expectation is that they'll scale exponentially —though you'll notice that once they reach a certain size, they tend to shift back to more linear or sub linear profit growth... That's a niggly detail best left ignored by investors. ;-)
- 01100011 3y agoIt depends on the context. In all of the discussions I've had on this topic, the quality people are concerned with is the performance of a company as an investment. In that sense, consulting does not scale. Sure, you can build a big, mildly profitable, consulting company, but that isn't very interesting to most folks.
- 01100011 3y agoWow, this is a pretty good summary of what I saw during my 15 or so years at "design services" companies. One way around some of these issues is to pay employees by the hour. At the places I worked, there was a large pool of folks who loved that arrangement because of the ability to work in bursts and take more time off in between. The problem then became scaling beyond that pool of labor (many of whom were independent contractors with other commitments). This math is also why, for years, I've recommended people avoid investing in companies like Palantir. Sure, they can be successful companies, but they'll never achieve the sort of hypergrowth that companies like Google or Meta can due to the scaling issues. Overall, I loved my time in the services industry. It had the dynamic quality of being a consultant (except for one 5 year long, mostly continuous project where I was staff augmentation for a large company) but someone else handled the sales and negotiations for me.
- cbsmith 3y agoPalantir has three products: Palantir Gotham, Palantir Apollo, and Palantir Foundry. The professional services are more in support of those sales than anything else. They have achieved periods of hypergrowth that fit the scale of that space. The reasons not to invest in them are far more complicated than that. ;-)
- kossTKR 3y agoTangent but why does so many companies keep hiring consulting companies (a little different) that come in and do nothing but waste everyone's time - is it yet another managerial class excess / nepotism / business theatre or is there some benefit i just don't see? I've seen this countless times both in both Tech and the NGO world - some roadmap is running pretty good, managers then hire a bunch of "cool looking people that come in with a big old white board to make a cool workshop" then follow the process for a short amount of time, giving extremely shitty advice because they haven't been involved in the process at all and are going to leave soon without delivering anything. And the fact that they are often paid a higher wage than the people who have to actually clean up after their crap advice is straight up offensive. And it seems everyone i know have this impression in both softer and harder sectors. I've only met a few "lone wolf" consultants in Tech that were nice, people often with a huge passion and knowledge for something concrete and not "passion for leadership / some bullshit organisational fad".
- intelVISA 3y agoIt's mostly a cover for wealth redistribution as you noted.
- rightbyte 3y agoDo the manager class really have that much "solidarity"?
- bjornsing 3y agoIsn’t it more “I scratch your back, you scratch mine”?
- rightbyte 3y agoSure but the consultant is getting alot a scratched back for not a lot of scratching himself. But maybe I am looking at this wrong. I.e. the buying manager is fine with getting a future favour or some wine and dine since it is not his money he is using anyways? Like money loundering. You expect a bad conversation rate.
- bbor 3y agoWe’ve assumed an 8-hour work day, but any owner of a consulting company will tell you this rarely happens. Oh sure, founders work 60-80-hour weeks, but not employees. Ok a) 8*5=40<60, b) how can anyone read this and not think “jeez this whole owner-employee system sure seems broken”. Imagine how much easier it would be to motivate people if they also had a stake in the profits
- nowbabynow 3y agono all employees are solving for max pay though (whether through salary or profits). for many, maximizing utility is maximizing leisure... ie if you pay more / give folks more profits, they may very well choose to work less.
- antisthenes 3y agoYou can be maximizing your hourly rate AND maximizing leisure at the same time. You're confusing max pay with working more hours, whereas in reality no one actually wants to put in more hours, and in many cases those employees that put in most time is a negative signal showing their inefficiency.
- 01100011 3y agoThis. Many of the folks I worked with liked 35 hour weeks and stayed in consulting because they were avid cyclists/surfers/hikers/etc. The sort of folks that like high pay and poor work/life balance end up at big valley companies in my experience.
- cbsmith 3y agoMeh. Big valley companies isn't the right criteria. There are "lifestyle businesses", and then there are other businesses. People do tend to make a conscious choice between the two.
- cbsmith 3y agoI read it and didn't think that, because the article mentions you can indeed incentivize employees to work longer hours by splitting the excess proceeds with them.
- iancmceachern 3y agoThe only way to do it is to be more efficient than the others. You need to be able to do in 20 hours takes others 40. If you can do the work in 20, with a high level of quality, they won't mind paying the 40 hours they have budgeted. If you say it'll take 40 and then bill them for 60, or bill them for 40 but are a week late, they'll be upset. If you can do that you can be very successful. If you can't, don't try, get good first on someone else's dime.
- 01100011 3y agoThe companies I worked for did it by: - Having better than average engineers. Not "10x", just better than average. - Having a project manager required for nearly all projects. The customer was billed for this and it was worth it. The PM managed a Gantt chart and periodically chatted with the engineers to keep the schedule accurate and the project on track. No daily standups. No agile. - Unless the project was for staff augmentation, the project had a clear set of goals and success criteria was defined up front. Feature creep was strongly discouraged. Is this a business model that will scale to billions of dollars? Most likely not. But it can be a good business that provides you with enjoyable work. Consulting companies are the first to be fired in a downturn, but they're the first to be hired when things get going again because companies are short-staffed and need to react quickly.
- iancmceachern 3y agoWell said, check-out the book "Small giants " companies that choose to be great instead of big. Right in this vein.
- cbsmith 3y agoEfficiency in consulting takes many forms. Yes, there's getting the work done more efficiently, but there's also ensuring you've got a deep pipeline so you have fewer idle hours, billing meticulously for every single expense, having commission/kick-back deals for referrals (ideally you're transparent about this with your clients, but they generally don't mind), and squeezing your employees wages (often structured as paying them a cut of their billables, and a bonus if they go in to overtime)... and that's just the obvious stuff. Consulting businesses are generally seen as "sweatshops" because they are really more a like a logistics business, where your profit comes from the marginal efficiencies.
- SoftTalker 3y agoPage does not display for me in Firefox. Use the PDF link at the top. https://longform.asmartbear.com/consulting-company-accounting/consulting-company-accounting.pdf https://longform.asmartbear.com/consulting-company-accountin...
- nelblu 3y agoWorking fine for me in Firefox (Android)
- zackmorris 3y agoThis is a refreshing article and I wish that I had read it when it was written. I did this math back in 2001 when I was moving furniture to support my side business making shareware games. The warehouse charged $34/hr and paid us $10/hr. For the life of me, I couldn't figure out where the other $24/hr was going, because that's more like $50/hr in today's money. Even though I was doing literally all of the work with the other lumpers, someone else was basically making $100k/yr for standing on my back. Especially considering that the warehouse and trucks had been paid off for decades so fuel was probably the next most expensive overhead! I later realized that the profit went to the office staff and salespeople who landed the moving contracts. And the owner (who was a millionaire) skimmed the rest. That experience shaped me into the antiestablishmenter I am today. Because that pattern repeats across all industries. Loosely the harder someone works, the less they keep of the gross vs the time and effort they put in. And digging into the history of that reveals how the concept of the corporation evolved during colonialism and slavery to extract as much capital as possible from workers and investors. Leaving us with the capitalist system we have today where one guy can extract most of the wealth from thousands of employees as majority shareholder or CEO. We can get into the virtues of capitalism vs socialism and communism, but I feel that those are red herring arguments post-pandemic and with the return of labor unions. What this is really all about is whether workers, owners or society should keep the lion's share of the fruits of their labors. The US currently gives the most to owners. Europe arguably pays a large amount into its societies (its commons). No country has ever given the most to workers, although Central America and Southeast Asia tried it after WWII, so the West blew them up for trying to go "socialist". In my own life, I've found it basically impossible to get ahead working a job and making side projects after trying for almost 25 years. And for every success story, we don't hear about the 9 out of 10 businesses that failed their first year. To a first order approximation, success is simply not attainable now outside of roughly the top 10% of income earners. The US is on the verge of losing its middle class. You can probably see where I'm going with this. If the status quo can no longer provide the essential infrastructure and policies for the people to sustain themselves, then it becomes something to be challenged by the majority. When The Conservative Mind was written in the early 1950s, there was a fear that when the US middle class reached 50% of the population, pure democracy would kick in and voters would pass socialist policies (reparations) to reclaim the profit that had been stripped from them. Which could align them with communists in the East to form a dystopian New World Order. To stop that, wealthy financiers installed Reagan in 1981 to dismantle unions and collapse the middle class back below 50%, which succeeded beyond their wildest dreams by the end of Bush Sr's administration. Clinton frayed the last of the social safety net to close the hatch and lock in the new normal. Post 9/11 has been an experiment in social engineering to see how long people will put up with living under a captured government that only passes legislation popular with a wide majority 10% of the time. The fallout from that is that blue collar workers now blame liberal elites for their problems instead of white collar workers and company owners. Because conservative elites ARE white collar workers and company owners ("job creators"). This misdirected rage is so high that the next election is still very much in contention despite what everyone saw with their own eyes in the capitol deaths last time. The really crazy thing is that the harder the wealthy and powerful close their grip on the rest of us, the more likely a violent revolution becomes. That's been proven time and again throughout history, even today with the two main proxy wars happening, which I won't get into because they're just too sad. To me, the answer to all this is fairly obvious. If it takes such an enormous expenditure of time and effort over many years to maybe kinda sorta squeak by, even when charging $100/hr, then maybe we can justify trying anything else at all. My heart is with solarpunk and shifting the focus from capital to resource production. In literal terms, that looks like energy-positive solar homes and vehicles for everyone on the planet, along with hydroponic and community gardens creating an excess of food to collapse the price towards free. More self-sufficiency for individuals equals less leverage for corporate price gouging and inflation. With the eventual goal of automating all essential labor with AI and robots so that it can be taxed to pay for UBI. Returning leisure time to humanity so that it can explore human endeavors like art, philosophy and creating heaven on Earth as it ventures out into the stars. For what it's worth, the wealthy and powerful can continue making huge profits alongside UBI. The only difference is that we'd have a healthy and happy populace instead of one endlessly struggling to survive. Which is why I think that this is something that red and blue can agree on, with the main barrier being the two entrenched political parties.
- kdwikzncba 3y ago2 sick days per month? What? This makes me doubt the realism of the other assumptions on this essay.
- skipnup 3y agoSounds about right...? End of November 2023 the average German worker hat 20 sick days already. Add 2 for December and 2 for good measure and you're at 2/month.