4 ms·
You keep saying real and true, but it's engineered from the authentic film. Certainly it could be more immersive and give more of a sense of being there, but c
by toast0 3y ago
You keep saying real and true, but it's engineered from the authentic film.
Certainly it could be more immersive and give more of a sense of being there, but colorized b&w film is not real, it's guesses (maybe very good guesses).
- xcv123 3y agoBecause it's not about the film in this case. It's about the reality that was filmed. The AI upscaled interpolated version looks closer to reality.
- Applejinx 3y agoA key point about this, whether here or in AI restoration of classic audio from yesteryear or indeed AI restoration to use in court as forensic audio or video… It ain't. It's made up, synthesized in a sophisticated way to become what is normally present in such a context. As such it is by definition fake and not reality, but a sort of consensus opinion of what usually goes into any given spot. You are not even approaching reality. You're approaching what is typically expected, synthesized to most plausibly fill in the gap. If there is some unusual detail in the original media, the restoration will read it as damage or a glitch, and will wrest it from you and force it into a more predictable form.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xcv123 3y agoThis is not a forensic video. No one is claiming that the colours are actually real. As a documentary this brings us closer to the experience of reality than the black and white jerky movements of the original film. It definitely does approach reality. Grass is green, not grey. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHHt-CBKkS0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHHt-CBKkS0
- WalterBright 3y agob&w film isn't real, the world isn't black and white. I know that colorized film sometimes picks the wrong colors, but really, so what? It's still way better and more watchable than b&w.
- ekianjo 3y ago> b&w film isn't real, the world isn't black and white. What does that mean? Then color pictures are not real either because the world is not limited by 10 bits of color. Makes no sense.
- toast0 3y agoNo film (or other imaging) is real, of course. But film without unnecessary processing is a reflection of reality. IMHO, color processing from color film is necessary. > It's still way better and more watchable than b&w. Well, we can agree to disagree on this; clearly I'm in the minority that wants to watch films as originally captured/presented. But I wouldn't object to someone saying the altered versions are more watchable --- more people are willing to watch them; and better I wouldn't object vigorously too. I'm objecting to it being called real and true. The original images, limited as they are are more real than an intepreted image based on the actual image. Just as actual images are more real than a reenactment, even though a reenactment allows for much nicer image capture that could be more immersive and better.
- Mr_Minderbinder 3y agoThe unaltered black and white footage is "real" in the sense that the information it records, the shades of grey, are actually causally connected to the event it depicts. If I colourise it, the cause or the information is coming from me, the shade of red you see is just my arbitrary choice, it is determined by me and not by the actual light bouncing off the blood of a soldier in 1914. As such the information added by colourisation is less "real" in this sense or entirely "false".