Like orbital-decay says: intuitive matters not at all. Convenience is what matters. I don't use a modal editor, but I do have the control keys on my Windows k

Like orbital-decay says: intuitive matters not at all. Convenience is what matters. I don't use a modal editor, but I do have the control keys on my Windows keyboard mapped to cursor control keys: the control-H, -J, -K, -L keys all correspond to the H, J, K and L keys when vi(m) is in the cursor control mode, leaving them for ordinary alphabetic use when I am not pressing the control key. Similarly for a bunch of other cursor control keys. And control-Q toggles between selecting and not selecting. I've been using this since around Windows 3.11. It is very convenient, and my fingers learned what to do decades ago--they now operate without any intuition whatsoever.