2 ms·
That Symbolics keyboard looks like a minor variation on the PC keyboard in some regards. The Control key is in the same wrong general location; it wants to be
by kazinator 3y ago
That Symbolics keyboard looks like a minor variation on the PC keyboard in some regards.
The Control key is in the same wrong general location; it wants to be where Symbolics has Rubout, and where PC keyboards have Caps Lock.
Another bad design was the DEC VT100 terminal keyboard. It put Ctrl to the left of a Caps Lock key: [Ctrl][Caps Lock][A][S][D][F]. Yikes!
Apple II had this right:
[Ctrl][A][S][D][F]
Commodore 64: Ctrl weirdly high:
[Ctrl][Q][W][E]
[Rs][Sl][A][S][D]
Ctrl next to Q. Rs = "RunStop", Sl = "Shift Lock".
In any case, I need the LeftControl to be somewhere far to the left, just like LeftShift.
Here is why: I only use those! I never use RightShift or RightCtrl.
When I type Ctrl-Q, Ctrl-W, ... Ctrl-Y, Ctrl-A ... Ctrl-G, Ctrl-Z ... Ctrl-B, I'm always using the left pinky, plus another finger of the same hand.
Same with the capitals of those letters: LeftShift with left pinky, plus left hand finger.
Whenever I have to use Alt, which is rare, I use LeftAlt, and it's quite awkward with the left side keys due to its position.
Here is why I use only LeftShift: from time to time ALL CAPS material occurs, like when typing identifiers such as PTHREAD_MUTEX_INITIALIZER. The only way to type these fast without using the Caps Lock key is to hold down shift with one finger and just type with the remaining nine fingers. Changing between left and right Shift in order to always use the opposite Shift key would be slow and prone to typing mistakes. Once you can type arbitrary material blindingly fast with your pinky holding down the LeftShift key, it makes no sense to think about the existence of RightShift.
- drbaba 3y agoI used to do exactly the same. But then I developed RSI in my left forearm, which I blame on overusing it for all modifier keys (including CapsLock as my only Ctrl and only using left shift). Afterwards, I used a Karabiner Elements script to completely block myself from pressing a left-hand modifier and left-hand letter key simultaneously, forcing myself to learn proper two-hand typing of modifiers. My arm feels better now, and I’ve actually finally appreciating having a Caps Lock key precisely due to the struggle you describe - I’m convinced that two-hand chording is healthier than pressing multiple keys simultaneously with one hand, but at the same time typing e.g. TODO out is then unbearable without a real caps lock key.
- kazinator 3y agoYou sound like someone who could benefit from foot pedals for modifier keys.
- drbaba 3y agoI actually like the concept of foot pedals or thumb cluster keyboards, which sound like two of the most ergonomic ways to use modifier keys. The main issue is that due to my work I have to regularly work on a laptop, and anything that deviates too much from a standard keyboard will cause too much friction as I switch back and forth. It would have been easier to go all in on custom hardware if I worked at one desk all day.
- p_l 3y agoThe Symbolics keyboard, and before it space cadet and knight keyboards, take the idea that you're hitting modifier with the opposite hand - no pinky involved. That's why Bucky bits are mirrored on both sides.