3 ms·
> Over time, everyone becomes atheistic. This is a misconception based on recent experience in the west. In the Muslim world, the trend has been the exact oppo
by rayiner 3y ago
> Over time, everyone becomes atheistic.
This is a misconception based on recent experience in the west. In the Muslim world, the trend has been the exact opposite. Neither of my grandmothers (one from a well-to-do urban family, another from a village) wore hijab. In their old age, they covered part of their hair with their sari, as is the south Asian custom: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sheikh_Hasina_Darshana_Jardosh_G20_New_Delhi_2023_(cropped).jpg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sheikh_Hasina_Darshana_.... None of my aunts wore hijab. But several of my cousins do. There’s a video of the President of Egypt laughing at the prospect of a hijab law in 1958: https://youtu.be/brlFxRYCggE?si=jBZ97TCpz3P7LASC https://youtu.be/brlFxRYCggE?si=jBZ97TCpz3P7LASC. Today, 90% of Egyptian women wear a headscarf.
> Not having children is a function of a society's wealth (which is then correlated to education which is the correlated to non-religiosity), not (necessarily) their religiosity.
Affluence allows individual independence, which tends to weaken religiosity. But it’s the religiosity (and social policy—in most societies, the two are closely connected) that then drives reproductive choices. Religious Pakistan has almost double the fertility rate of secular Bangladesh, despite similar GDP per capita. Muslim Americans have more affluence and more education, but also much higher birth rates than both white Americans generally, and non-college educated white Americans in places where that group is secular and not evangelical. West Virginia has a comparable fertility rate to Washington State or Colorado. Oregon has one of the lowest fertility rates, despite being relatively poor and rural. (In red states, you can see a stark contrast between places that are populated by descendants of Germans, or British planters, and those that are populated by Scots-Irish.)
- skissane 3y ago> Religious Pakistan has almost double the fertility rate of secular Bangladesh, despite similar GDP per capita. I agree with your overall conclusion, but nowadays Bangladesh's GDP per capita is significantly higher than Pakistan's, so that part of your argument no longer holds. And, Bangladesh's economy is now growing significantly faster than Pakistan's (in 2022, 7.1% vs 4.7%), so it seems likely that Bangladesh will keep on pulling ahead.