11 ms·
Brilliant, always do the right thing. So catchy and yet so utterly useless at the same time. You sound just like the 'seduction' experts, 'confidence, that's w
by mattmanser 15y ago
Brilliant, always do the right thing. So catchy and yet so utterly useless at the same time.
You sound just like the 'seduction' experts, 'confidence, that's what gets the girl'.
My mum had an episode where she quite literally went mad. We spent a couple of weeks visiting her every day as she was confused, scared and angry.
At some point I turned to my sister and said 'we have to go home, our lives have to go on'.
The irony being that 'home' was 100 miles away from where my mum lives as my sister had met her husband a year earlier visiting me.
Your story is touching and totally fucking stupid at the same time. My to-do list for tomorrow has 'Get loo roll, book a ticket for Splendour festival, vote'.
Your to-do list sucks ass as it doesn't actually meet your real life needs.
And did I do the right thing? I'll never know, I still feel like a shit as she screamed that the nurses were hurting her. Humiliated, ignored. Maybe they did? Lies I hope. I will never, ever know. Alzheimer's? She won't even remember what you did, you're doing it for nothing more than your own conscience.
We are living in a very, very odd time where our parents are turning into our children.
EDIT: The reason I had to write this is that your experience seems to me at odds with points 1, 3 & 5 of the list. And the horrible thing is it's going to get worse for all of us here on HN in the next 40 years. Medicine has put us in a very awkward position, one of being able to maintain the body when the mind went long ago. Or (imo worse) maintaining the body and mind when the reasons to live have gone. My friend's grandma openly talks about wanting to die as all her friends are dead. But does my friend's Mum want her Mum to die? Of course not. This is a very odd time.
- karterk 15y agoYour to-do list sucks ass as it doesn't actually meet your real life needs. Maybe it does to him. He was just sharing his experience, not preaching everyone to do what he does.
- cstross 15y agoit's going to get worse for all of us here on HN in the next 40 years. Medicine has put us in a very awkward position, one of being able to maintain the body when the mind went long ago. Or (imo worse) maintaining the body and mind when the reasons to live have gone. My friend's grandma openly talks about wanting to die as all her friends are dead. But does my friend's Mum want her Mum to die? Of course not. This is a very odd time. Preach it. (Those who downvoted you obviously didn't read far enough.)
- keeptrying 15y agoI want to write a great many things here however I don't know whether your trolling. Hopefully you're just trolling. However, if you are not then when the denial breaks, don't hurt yourself. Forgive yourself and move to fix it.
- robomartin 15y agoHow would you react if someone spoke to you as you just did to the author of this post? I suspect you would not like it very much. Perhaps you should consider tempering your words next time. The last paragraph of your post is worthy of discussion, the rest, as written, is an attack devoid of any class, manners and consideration.
- mattmanser 15y agoThe first 2 paragraphs were assholey, the rest was pure heart. It's controversial. Yes. But needed to be said. I'm glad people read it. In reality I wrote that when I was drunk, I was an asshole. But read it again. It's hard to admit sober. I think edw519 needed challenging, I think he was weak pretending to be strong. But damn, in all seriousness, edw519's choice was a LOT harder than mine. I knew recovery was a few weeks away. He knew his was never. Don't give your disease ridden parents the rest of your life. Mainly because they wouldn't have wanted you to when they were whole. You're supposed to be the next generation. Not caring for an empty shell.
- skore 15y agoI do see value in the core of your argument but, boy, do you ever not know how to sell it. In essence, your main argument is: "Here is how I see it". Well guess what, that's the same argument that the guy you're replying to made, so it might help to be a little more humble about it. Arguing with others is only a tiny bit representing your own viewpoint. It's mainly about then figuring out where the person you're talking to stands on this and finally negotiating a path for the other person between the two points. Your main point seems to be portraying the hurt that you've experienced and how you dealt with it when your mother had her "episode" (does she still have it? It was never resolved to us) while reminding us (rightfully, I think) that having a core priority is all fine and well, but (especially at times of distress) it might not get you through the endless sea of small challenges. A fair point that is not particularly nuanced, but that always makes for a good discussion. What came out of your mouth (fig.) was basically "you're an idiot, I see this differently. Also, while I'm at it, let me curse some more". (Not that I particularly mind expletives, but in your comment, I was tired of them the third time around already.) Not very persuasive.