3 ms·
> How do they get money for arms? Where do the arms come from? Why is the government unable to exert any realistic control within their own borders In the Hout
by alephnerd 3y ago
> How do they get money for arms? Where do the arms come from? Why is the government unable to exert any realistic control within their own borders
In the Houthi's case, they're a clan.
The entire clan pitched in because they were persecuted under Saleh - businessmen, service men, low level govenenent officials, etc.
Familial and Clan traditons are still a thing.
- no_wizard 3y agoMiddle East politics have always felt beyond my understanding. I know we (as in western countries, specifically the US and the UK, but also others) contributed greatly to this mess (and still do to this day, in multiple ways). That said, at some point, you expect things to normalize, because fundamentally people should be conflict adverse, however, it seems this region has an unusually high rate of conflicts that aren't strictly due to massive government failing in succession, since it appears Middle Eastern governments have been in power a long time (thus, can establish a relative order) but seem unable to control their own country within their own borders still. Which i suppose is indeed government failure, just of a different nature than one would typically imagine (IE, losing total control)
- alephnerd 3y agoClan dynamics aren't only a Middle Eastern thing. They happen in every culture or society where family ties matter. For example, Guangdong's rise in electronics assembly thanks to Cantonese business families in Malaysia, Thailand, and Singapore investing in Taiwan and then co-investing in Guangdong. > it appears Middle Eastern governments have been in power a long time Most are stable. Aside from Libya, Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, and Yemen they are humming along. > people should be conflict adverse People are conflict adverse. The issue is a states like Yemen, Syria, and Iraq just straight up imploded and collapsed, so people reverted to family relations. If you ever wondered what the world would look like after the apocalypse, it doesn't look like Fallout or The Last of Us - it looks like Yemen, Syria, Nepal, Myanmar, Afghanistan, Lebanon, etc
- alephnerd 3y ago^ edit to above Cantonese business families (eg. Shiniwatra/Qiu) in Thailand/HK/SG/MY investing in factories in Guangdong Hokkien business families (eg. Tan Kah Kee, like the chem building at UC Berkeley by Evan's Hall) in SG/MY investing in Taiwan and then coinvesting with Taiwanese in Guangdong Teochew business families (eg. Chearavanont/Xie, Li Ka Shing, etc) in TH/SG/MY investing in Guangdong
- twic 3y agoIt's not necessarily driven by anything internal. Lots of parts of the Middle East are globally significant, because of oil and gas production and the Suez canal route. That means that they attract a lot of external meddling. For example, Iran is backing the Houthis with weapons, technology, and money. The United States has done various bits of meddling too, both supportive and not. If you pour the means of conflict into a region, you will tend to get more conflict there.
- throw0101b 3y ago> Familial and Clan traditons are still a thing. I think that most W.E.I.R.D. (Western) people don't realize how much the rest of the world (for better or worse) still runs on kin-based rules. Good book going over the strangeness of the 'Western' world in many respects: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_WEIRDest_People_in_the_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_WEIRDest_People_in_the_Wor... * https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/10/joseph-henrich-weird-people/615496/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/10/joseph-... * https://archive.ph/e7DJX https://archive.ph/e7DJX
- alephnerd 3y agoI'd disagree that a relativist argument like Henrich's would hold in this case. Clans as a societal unit was a thing in the West as well. For example, it was a major reason for the Jacobite Rebellion in Scotland in 1745, the Irish independence movement was organized thanks to the clan system in the 19th and early 20th century, etc. Clans as a societal unit disappeared in Western Europe when the Nuclear Family became the primary unit around the 19th-20th century
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imbnwa 3y agoEvery aristocracy and top 1% strata in the world is a clan system, the Windsors are a clan, its simply seen as primitive when people who aren’t either of those do it