5 ms·
How to install Windows 11 on a device that does not meet Windows 11 requirements
- gridder 3y agoCan someone point me out a common reason why windows 11 (and not 10) is needed? Just curious (the ‘liberty of choice’ ones do not count)
- zamadatix 3y agoThe main reason is Windows 10 leaves free support in less than two years so doing a new install with it basically just leaving the problem for a year down the road. After that there are actually feature changes in Windows 11 (despite the "new windows release" tropes) but they make up a less common reason alltogether.
- icf80 3y agoEasier it is to use https://rufus.ie/en/ https://rufus.ie/en/
- Nostrada 3y agoThis is the answer!
- temp112123 3y agoI'm a ventoy kinda guy- https://ventoy.net/en/index.html https://ventoy.net/en/index.html
- mewse-hn 3y agoYeah I just imaged the win11 installer to a usb stick a few days ago using Rufus and was surprised to discover the checkboxes that bypassed all the crap you have to navigate during a normal install.
- yonatan8070 3y agoIn addition to Rufus, Ventoy (an awesome multiboot USB tool) also supports bypassing the hardware checks and the online account requirement
- NoxiousPluK 3y agoI also enjoyed Ventoy a lot, but recently I had the weird issue that it would fail installing a distro on a somewhat odd industrial system, where Rufus worked fine. It probably did something that the odd UEFI implementation didn't understand.
- yonatan8070 3y agoYou might be able to file an issue on the Ventoy GitHub and get it resolved for all 3 other people with that system
- dzdt 3y agoThe HN headline ("How to Install Windows 11 On A Device That Does Not Meet Windows 11 Requirements") is editorialized and does not reflect the article. The correct headline is "Ways to install Windows 11". The article repeatedly emphasizes that Microsoft does not recommend installing Windows 11 on systems that do not meet their suggested minimum requirements.
- ngcc_hk 3y agoThis actually has that headline : https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/installing-windows-11-on-devices-that-don-t-meet-minimum-system-requirements-0b2dc4a2-5933-4ad4-9c09-ef0a331518f1 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/installing-windo...
- ableal 3y agoThere is a page with the title used: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/installing-windows-11-on-devices-that-don-t-meet-minimum-system-requirements-0b2dc4a2-5933-4ad4-9c09-ef0a331518f1 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/installing-windo... Or close enough: "Installing Windows 11 on devices that don't meet minimum system requirements", it is linked in submitted page, it also contains the caution.
- zamadatix 3y agoMatches the last half well but still a completely different first half meaning. You can't just take any titles on a site, mash them together based on your takeaway, and call that the original title.
- belter 3y agoHN editorializes titles all the time.... :-0 In this case I did it to clarify the relevancy of the article. Would you see a title "Ways to install Windows 11" and then ask what is relevance to the HN audience? The main point is that it's possible, per this official Microsoft document, to bypass the check for TPM 2.0 (at least TPM 1.2 is required) and the CPU family and model. Help avoid the Microsoft induced eWaste. "Windows 11 Upgrade Will Put 240M Computers On The Brink Of Becoming E-Waste" - https://www.benzinga.com/news/23/12/36358322/windows-11-upgrade-will-put-240m-computers-on-the-brink-of-becoming-e-waste-report https://www.benzinga.com/news/23/12/36358322/windows-11-upgr...
- roody15 3y agoInteresting that Microsoft provides how to install on devices that don't meet minimal requirements. Still seems slightly risky as in they may just decided to enforce TPM 2.0 in future updates....
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIf you've dabbed in Windows before and how permissive it is with piracy, you also know that any kind of enforcement on Windows CAN and usually IS bypassed rather quickly an easily. Cracks and patches are on the web only hours after whatever Microsoft does. Especially in places like China, Russia, etc.
- whatever1 3y agoSo wait Microsoft provides a workaround to their own security feature?
- lp0_on_fire 3y agoWhy wouldn't they? Windows is just a vehicle for ads and telemetry now so it makes sense they want to get it installed anywhere it can.
- vezycash 3y ago> So wait Microsoft provides a workaround to their own security feature? It's their way of admitting that they fucked up and they boost windows 11 installation numbers. Windows 11 reminds me of the frustrations users of Windows phone 7, 8, & 10 went through because of pointless hardware restrictions, constant app redesigns, only to scrap the OS.
- awinter-py 3y agomore interested in 'how to not install windows 11 on a device that you've told 50 times not to install windows 11'
- ahonhn 3y agoDon't think it works for Win10 Home, but with Pro use gpedit and go to Local Computer Policy --> Computer Configuration --> Administrative Templates --> Windows Components --> Windows Update for Business, find "Select the target feature update" and set it to 'Windows 10', and '22H2'
- Zambyte 3y agoFree Software operating system and move that ticket to OBE
- paulryanrogers 3y agoOBE?
- Zambyte 3y agoOvercome by events. A common end state for issue ticketing systems for when an issue was not directly solved, but is no longer an issue :-)
- hiatus 3y agoSame. I've had elderly family members unintentionally upgrade despite walking them through declining when they would call confused about the upgrade prompt coming out of nowhere. You could even shut down the "wrong" way and somehow end up upgraded.
- scrlk 3y agoI'm not surprised, the W11 upgrade nag screens are riddled with dark patterns.
- arprocter 3y agoWhen I've done this it seems to work for a while, but when a large Feature/Moment/whateverit'scalledthisweek update comes out it won't pick it up - you'll have to do a full install over what's already there (not the end of the world, as you get the Windows.old folder) I'm wondering if they may change their 'must have TPM' tune as the deadline approaches, because there's already been some bad press regarding e-waste
- johnfonesca 3y agoHow effective is TPM 2.0 compared to the original ? Are there any reports that demonstrate its effectiveness ? If a specific version of TPM becomes required to use future versions of Windows, we will have swappable TPM chips ? Eg update your TPM chip just like you update your GPU :)
- zamadatix 3y agoThe other half of the answer, for boards without a hardware swappable TPM the embedded fTPM in newer stuff may be upgradeable to the newer version, depending what exactly changed requirements wise.
- m-p-3 3y agoSome desktops have a TPM header so yeah, you can replace the TPM chip on those.
- nixgeek 3y agoMost Supermicro mainboards are either an 8-pin or 20-pin header and you can get TPM 1.x and TPM 2.0 options for them.
- refracture 3y agoI've gone down this path.. I have a Skylake Dell Inspiron, it has TPM 2.0 but of course the CPU is not supported. The problem I've found is that the OS in general just isn't very responsive, everything is sluggish as hell in ways that it simply isn't with Window 10, but only when it comes to things like opening explorer, logging in and out, opening programs.. etc.. but programs themselves all seem to run just as well as they did under 10. shrugs, I think I just need to replace this thing finally.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>I have a Skylake Dell Inspiron, it has TPM 2.0 but of course the CPU is not supported. As a Skylake owner too, there's a good and well documented reason for that. Apparently, Skylake is full of so many silicon bugs[1](or just google "Skylake bugs") that Microsoft has had its work cut out patching Windows with workarounds based on Intel's erratas. Maintaining support and testing for older and buggy silicon moving forward, keeps adding to the development cost of Windows, so it's only natural Microsoft would just say "fuck it" and drop further support for that CPU family at one point to save money and support headaches. Apple was also quick to drop Skylake. Yeah, it sucks as a Skylake owner, but Intel holds a large part of the blame as well for pushing out junk without QA. Honesty there should be class action lawsuist for this. FWIW, I have Win11 installed on Skylake and it seems to work just fine, so I assume Microsoft has it blacklisted as unsupported just so that if you ruin your accounting business due to some errors from the silicon bugs showing their heads, you can't hold them accountable as it's on you for working around their restrictions and running Windows 11 on an explicitly unsupported CPU. > I think I just need to replace this thing finally. Install Linux you mean. [1] https://www.zdnet.com/article/ex-intel-engineer-apple-turned-away-from-intel-over-skylake-cpu-bugs/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/ex-intel-engineer-apple-turned...
- ActionHank 3y agoI had a daily driver that ran windows 10. Once a year I would format and reinstall because it would get sluggish. I got a steamdeck and was blown away by how well everything ran on it. The next time I was due to reinstall I switched to linux. It has been snappier than windows ever was and everything works fantastically well.
- horusthegame 3y agoPeople actually want to install Windows 11 when better alternatives like Ubuntu/Kubuntu/Fedora/PopOS!/etc. exist?
- okdood64 3y agoThere's people who like to play PC games or use Excel natively.
- realusername 3y agoYou have to precise recent multiplayer games with anticheats because that's probably the last category of games firmly locked on windows. For old games, you could even argue that wine has a better compatibility story than Windows itself nowadays with the amount of stuff they broke in Win10 and Win11.
- horusthegame 3y agoAgreed, was going to reply to parent's comment but yours is spot on. Wine can run some of my old games great. Steam Proton runs all the newer stuff I've purchased (oops, sorry Gabe I meant to say "licensed"!). I don't do a lot of MP except for stuff that has a native Linux client like TF2 and CS2. Well, I do play a lot of NMS and sometimes play it in MP no issues on Steam Proton though their MP can get a bit funky sometimes. I play 7DTD Windows version, usually SP but it seems like I've played it in MP, maybe I'm recalling incorrectly.
- horusthegame 3y agoSee my comment below on games, as for Excel, I use the online version, works great on Chrome, Firefox and Edge on Kubuntu.
- kataklasm 3y agoUnfortunately, a whole lot (the vast majority) of enterprise engineering software is Windows-only. Be it Patran/Nastran, most of the Autodesk lineup or lots of others.
- elorant 3y agoI sit on the opposite side of the fence. My PC meets the hardware requirements but I've turned off TPM 2.0 to avoid upgrading from Win10.
- kriz9 3y agoThanks for the idea. If it gets rid of these nag screens riddled with dark ui patterns after every update I am willing to try everything.
- samstp 3y agoYou can also use Rufus. It has options to customize Windows 11 and one of them is to disable the hardware module requirement (TPM). https://rufus.ie https://rufus.ie