5 ms·
> It assumes people drive to the work in the morning have charging stations at work That's a pretty reasonable assumption once electric cars are the majority o
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> It assumes people drive to the work in the morning have charging stations at work
That's a pretty reasonable assumption once electric cars are the majority of cars.
> and don't commute very far.
There are popular electric cars with a range on the order of 300 miles. The average commute is 41 miles round trip.
> Also, there's loads of people doing errands during the day, or utility vehicles transporting cargo.
The average person does not drive 300 miles a day in total, and so does not need to charge more than once a day in total. Utility vehicles will have larger batteries and more range, and will strongly prefer to charge during daylight because charging from solar will cost less.
> And lastly, few grid operators are going to accept that their grid storage may drive away on masse during the holidays.
It's storing the energy that the vehicle itself will use. If the vehicle leaves the area then so does its demand for electricity.
> During a cloudy week, you're going to have a shortfall all the time. Solar drops to 10-25% effectiveness with cloud cover
If your grid has 40GW of nuclear and 60GW average of solar (which generates 120GW during daylight) then the 120GW drops to 30GW and you have 70GW of generation, which could be less than the demand before noon. You can also run the peaker plants even though you already had a surplus in those hours so you can put even more into the batteries to have enough later in the day.
> But again, peak demand isn't at midnight it's at 8pm. You can't just hand-wave away the challenge of meeting peak demand when intermittent sources aren't producing.
Suppose you have enough nuclear to meet the demand at midnight, which is enough to meet half of the demand at 8PM. So now you need to satisfy the other half from batteries for four hours, because before 6PM the sun is still up and after 10PM the demand falls off to what you're getting from nuclear. So you don't need enough batteries to satisfy all of the demand for the 12 hours when there is no sunlight, you only need enough to satisfy half of the demand for those four hours.
> And it aligns even worse during the Winter: solar is producing the least amount of energy, cloud cover is at its greatest extent.
But there is more wind in the winter, and at night, when there is more demand for heating.
And one of the ways to decarbonize heating in cities is nuclear with cogeneration. Then you're not using electricity for heat, you're using the waste heat from the reactors, which chops off a large chunk of even the existing nighttime load.
- Manuel_D 3y agoAgain, electric vehicles only work as storage if people can charge their cars at work, drive home, and then tap that storage over night. Many vehicles aren't being used for commuting, they're used for work or running errands. They're going to be used during the day and charged at night. People aren't just going to become nocturnal in order to charge their cars. Someone who drives to work in the morning, goes shopping during the day, and picks kids up in the evening isn't going to be able to do all these chores at night. What happens if someone's car is discharged over night right before a trip to Grandma's and now they don't have enough range? They're going to be pissed and stop letting the grid tap into their car. > If your grid has 40GW of nuclear and 60GW average of solar (which generates 120GW during daylight) then the 120GW drops to 30GW and you have 70GW of generation If you've got 50GW deficit over a week of cloud cover you need 4,200 GWh of storage to offset that. Consider that in many parts of the world, cloud cover can be present for a month or longer. These are absolutely massive storage figures. The latter is about ten times the annual global battery output. And energy demand is much higher than 120 GW. US electricity demand is 500 GW. Global electricity demand is 3,300 GW. > Suppose you have enough nuclear to meet the demand at midnight, which is enough to meet half of the demand at 8PM. It's enough to satisfy 70% of the demand at 8PM. And since nuclear is just as cheap to run at 100% capacity all day long, it's better to scrap the bulk of your renewables because the nuclear plants make them redundant. > But there is more wind in the winter, and at night, when there is more demand for heating. This depends on geography. On the west coast, it's the opposite: wind produces the least energy during winter. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=20112 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=20112
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Again, electric vehicles only work as storage if people can charge their cars at work, drive home, and then tap that storage over night. They're storing the energy that they themselves use. You're not using it for your house, you're charging during sunlight and then driving home or to a restaurant after dark. It allows close to the entire demand for electric vehicles to be served from renewable generation. > They're going to be used during the day and charged at night. A supercharger adds 200 miles of range in 15 minutes. You go into the shop, plug into the charger in the parking lot and when you come back out in 15 minutes you don't have to charge again until tomorrow. > What happens if someone's car is discharged over night right before a trip to Grandma's and now they don't have enough range? They'll plug it in and charge it. Charging your car at night isn't going to be illegal, but it will cost more, so people will prefer not to, and then 95% of the charging will happen during the day. Notice also that "overnight" is not synonymous with "darkness" -- if the sun comes up at 6AM and you leave for work at 8AM, you've had two hours of sunlight to charge your car while it was parked in your garage, and there are computers that can automate this. > If you've got 50GW deficit over a week of cloud cover you need 4,200 GWh of storage to offset that. Or 50GW of peaker plants, or 40GW of peaker plants and 20% of that amount of storage. > And energy demand is much higher than 120 GW. These are just example numbers for a hypothetical grid with 100GW of average demand. > It's enough to satisfy 70% of the demand at 8PM. In California, in October. Not in Texas in July. > And since nuclear is just as cheap to run at 100% capacity all day long, it's better to scrap the bulk of your renewables because the nuclear plants make them redundant. Nuclear is base load. It can make sense to build as much of it as there is base load demand, i.e. the minimum demand during any part of the day. But what do you want to do about the higher demand periods? Build extra nuclear plants that only operate 4 hours a day? Use battery storage with nuclear, even though that's way more expensive than battery storage with renewables? > This depends on geography. On the west coast, it's the opposite: wind produces the least energy during winter. The west coast has mild winters and thus less heating demand.