6 ms·
Rationalism 101: A Historical Overview
- Vektorceraptor 3y agoRationalism is too short-sighted. It only concerns “knowing what” but not “knowing how”. You cannot rationally or deductively explain how to ride a bike or swim. If we take the thought experiment of Mary, who lived all her life in a gray environment and read everything about colors without ever actually seeing them, then we can also say that she may know a lot about colors, but the essentials has not experienced. There is also another distinction in human nature described by Nietzsche - the Appolinian and the Dionysian. Roughly speaking, the Appolinian can be described as the rationalistic, while the Dionysian as the ecstatic. Unfortunately, since Plato, or even Sokrates and before (the transition from Myth to Science) rationalism has predominated. Postmodernism was an attempt to pull the rug out from under rationalism. But it actually had the opposite effect. The consequences of postmodernism are as paradoxical as postmodernism itself. The dismantling of norms has become the norm; the disintegration of identity became a new identity; The decomposition of truth itself became truth; etc.
- bell-cot 3y agoI think of Rationalism as being "Road Runner Philosophy" (after the 1950's cartoon character). If you can "rationalize" running into the mouth of a tunnel - which was painted onto the side of a mountain seconds earlier - then somehow you can. If you are a kid sitting and watching cartoons, it's a great visual gag. If you are a fantasy novelist, trying to make vampires, dragons, and magic feel real to your readers, then Rationalism has some excellent writing strategies to offer. If you are a certain sort of upper-class European royalist, trying to justify Leopold II's policies in the Congo, then Rationalist arguments are probably your best strategy. But if you need to be a capable and high-functioning person in the real, physical world - then Rationalism probably should be on your "Common Fallacies & How To Avoid Them" list.
- Vektorceraptor 3y agoHehe, the road runner metaphor is funny :)
- gregjor 3y agoAs commonly used, as in I’m a rationalist, the self-proclaimed rationalist intends to imply traits and ways of thinking they may or may not actually follow. Rationalist implies rational, intelligent, introspective. Other examples: I am a stoic, I am a Christian. In other words more often a pose or piece of a vague identity than a seriously thought-through philosophy and approach to life. Rationalist is quickly becoming a synonym for pompous. Telling people I’m a musician usually works better in most social contexts to make yourself seem interesting.