2 ms·
I agree. Public schools were invented to socialize children into mainstream Protestant values, and by and large that’s still their purpose today. Insofar as wha
by rayiner 3y ago
I agree. Public schools were invented to socialize children into mainstream Protestant values, and by and large that’s still their purpose today. Insofar as what I wrote is ambiguous, my point is that education and journalism are dominated (at the national level), by a cohort that is defined by a particular set of values they share, not by the fact that they want to use schools to teach their values. Certainly, I’m no supporter of educational neutrality myself.
- tptacek 3y agoWhen the consensus was that schools should teach mainstream Protestant values, you were sanguine about it. But it wasn't principle that located public school values there; it was consensus-seeking. The consensus has shifted. It'll shift again. There's nothing improper about any of that. You'll have to argue against the values schools are teaching on the merits, not based on some claim of impropriety.
- rayiner 3y agoSchools are still teaching mainstream Protestant values. The theology has just evolved. I didn’t claim there was anything improper about it, I’m just describing the dynamic that exists. I will disagree with you about “consensus.” I think people who hold this particular ideology are in the minority. But they are dramatically overrepresented in the education and journalism fields.