12 ms·
The relevant factor is whether it's more expensive than peaker gas plants. Because that's how you get energy when the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shi
by zozbot234 3y ago
The relevant factor is whether it's more expensive than peaker gas plants. Because that's how you get energy when the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shine. And no, battery storage - or any storage other than pumped hydro, which is already in heavy use - is a drop in the bucket; it doesn't even come close to covering serious shortfalls.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoNuclear is not a replacement for peaker plants. They have to run continuously just to reach their already abysmal economics.
- _cenw 3y agoNot being able to scale to zero doesn't mean you can't scale at all. France fulfills essentially all their dynamic demand with nuclear.
- bjornsing 3y agoWhich makes the whole equation very interesting. Here in Sweden the electricity spot price is often zero or even negative when it’s windy. So what’s the point of more “cheap” kWhs at those times? I think we should just stop doing these $/kWh calculations and instead compare various production (and storage) mixes that can actually meet demand.
- anonporridge 3y agoThis is also an important problem that might start showing up with energy overabundance. If we too regularly have these periods of 0 or negative electricity prices, the economics of supporting the infrastructure collapses. Projects go bankrupt and generators get abandoned to fall into disrepair. I suspect that like modern individuals now struggle with unintended consequences of calorie abundance, civilization will also struggle with unintended consequences of electricity abundance.
- greedo 3y agoTrue electricity abundance (like posited by fusion reactors) will enable an incredible amount of new advances and technology.
- oezi 3y agoWe will see electricity over-abundance in the text 5 years for all months around summer. The build-out plans in the world are crazy in the medium term.
- anonporridge 3y agoOf course it will. But the economics still has to balance out. Zero and negative prices would have to be subsidized to maintain economic viability, which just means the actual price is hidden.
- greedo 3y agoIt's not a zero sum world economy...
- anonporridge 3y agoI don't understand how you extracted that from my comment above. We obviously live in an insanely positive sum world. That doesn't mean systems can run sustainably at a loss.
- greedo 3y agoEnergy abundance doesn't mean at a loss. It just means that excess energy that would go to waste can be used very cheaply, for all sorts of stuff that never would have been able to be accomplished before. Take CO2 extraction. It really isn't feasible, partially due to cost. But with free energy, it becomes more feasible (ignoring all the technical hurdles). Recycling becomes more efficient, all sorts of processes that are better for the environment but currently expensive will become possible.
- saiya-jin 3y agoI think with good planning they can significantly lower the peaks, and if you have abundance say in Europe you can sell it to other states.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoBatteries replace peakers. And we are building lots of batteries. Peakers already cannot compete against batteries when they are both paid to charge when there is excess power on the grid, and paid again to discharge, not to mention grid services (frequency response, grid stability, etc). Batteries can already be recycled in recycling supply chains that have been stood up (Redwood Materials, for example). Humorously, batteries are lasting so long in EV applications that the supply chain is ready with very little EOL batteries to process. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/energy-and-resources/articles/global-energy-storage-renewable-energy-storage.html https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/energy-and-resources/a... ("Global energy storage: Digitization and market innovation accelerate battery storage deployment") https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=56880 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=56880 ("The duck curve, however, has created opportunities for energy storage. The large-scale deployment of energy storage systems, such as batteries, allow some solar energy generated during the day to be stored and saved for later, after the sun sets. Storing some midday solar generation flattens the duck’s curve, and dispatching the stored solar generation in the evening shortens the duck’s neck. Battery storage is swiftly being constructed in California; it’s grown from 0.2 gigawatts (GW) in 2018 to 4.9 GW as of April 2023. Operators plan to build another 4.5 GW of battery storage capacity in the state by the end of the year, according to our Preliminary Monthly Electric Generator Inventory.") https://electrek.co/2023/05/31/north-america-battery-factories/ https://electrek.co/2023/05/31/north-america-battery-factori... ("North America is now the growth leader for new battery factories") https://e360.yale.edu/features/in-boost-for-renewables-grid-scale-battery-storage-is-on-the-rise https://e360.yale.edu/features/in-boost-for-renewables-grid-... ("Batteries are beginning to reach a size that enables renewables to replace medium-sized natural gas generators.") https://evmarketsreports.com/300-billion-in-new-lithium-ion-battery-gigafactories/ https://evmarketsreports.com/300-billion-in-new-lithium-ion-... ("According to Benchmark, worldwide manufacturing of lithium ion batteries will more than fivefold by the end of the decade as a result of these expenditures. Last year, the world added 102 gigafactories to the ten-year pipeline, with a total capacity of 3.1 terawatt-hours.") https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-07/end-of-coal-power-in-australia-means-a-boom-for-battery-makers-like-tesla https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-07/end-of-co... | https://archive.today/2owbd https://archive.today/2owbd ("Battery Bonanza Is Being Sparked by Coal’s Exit in Australia") https://lorenz-g.github.io/tesla-megapack-tracker/all-big-batteries.html https://lorenz-g.github.io/tesla-megapack-tracker/all-big-ba... ("Big Battery Tracker)
- Manuel_D 3y agoNuclear power costs about as much to run 24/7 as it does to run intermittently, because the vast majority of its cost is in construction. So building enough nuclear power to satisfy demand when intermittent sources aren't producing makes those intermittent sources totally redundant.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoNot exactly. Suppose you have renewable sources that on average generate 100GW. Well, some weeks they're going to average 90GW -- and that will be quite common -- in which case you'd need 10GW of something else. The long-term average (e.g. over 48 hours) is what matters because you'd always need to smooth out the short-term load with batteries. Some weeks you'll need to make up 20GW, but that will be less often than a 10GW shortfall. Even less often, 30GW. Sometimes, but very rarely, the whole 100GW, or at least say 90GW. This means that the first 10GW of peaker plants will be quite economical because they get used e.g. 15% of the time, but the last 10GW will only get used <1% of the time and not be competitive with nuclear running ~100% of the time. So what you end up with is, say, 60GW of renewables, 40GW of nuclear and 50GW of peaker plants that run the ~5% of the time when you have low renewable generation. Instead of needing 100GW of renewables and 90GW of peaker plants, of which 40GW is almost never used.
- fragmede 3y agoThat's one side of the equation. The other side that's being explored is to vary the demand side. Only use 90 GW when 90 GW is available, and run the aluminum smelters undercapacity when there isn't the solar power to run them at full capacity. It's an interesting balancing equation that someone could make an interesting game out of.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Only use 90 GW when 90 GW is available, and run the aluminum smelters undercapacity when there isn't the solar power to run them at full capacity. That gets you a few percent for the things that work like that, but most of the load on the power grid isn't able to do that. You can't turn off the heat in the winter, which is going to be an even larger proportion of the load in the future than it is now as we transition from fossil fuel heating systems to electric. People demand hot water. Refrigeration is a significant load but you turn it off and your food spoils. Electrifying transportation is also a mixed blessing here. It helps smooth out the day/night load because you can charge them whenever generation exceeds demand, but after a couple days you can't put it off anymore and then you've just got more unsuppressible demand.
- danhor 3y ago> whether it's more expensive than peaker gas plants. While running only a small percentage of the time. Some only operate a few hundred hours a year, let's say 300 hours (around 3.4% of the time). These low operating hours are much more likely to happen as short term storage and renwables get expanded. French nuclear reactors run around 60% of the time and have very little variable costs. Thus new nuclear reactors would have to be only 5% of the cost of gas peakers when run most of the time, as would be economically reasonable, to beat gas peakers.
- zozbot234 3y agoGas peakers are relatively cheap to build but have to pay for their fuel, so running them a small % of the time absolutely makes sense. Nuclear is much more of a baseload source.
- mayama 3y agoPumped hydro storage is approximately cost competitive with new nuclear. It depends on ease of incentives, building permits and finance mechanisms available for building new hydro vs nuclear. Estimated LCOE of new hydro in India for example is Rs9/kwh(~$100/Mwh) which is comparable to new nuclear estimates of $55-90/Mwh. China is also building pumped hydro at good pace. And pumped hydro doesn't have to fight entrenched anti-nuclear lobby while doing it. US and EU storage incentives encourage battery storage schemes over pumped hydro though. They either expect cost of battery storage to become less than pumped hydro shortly, or the lack of construction firms lobbying for pumped hydro is making battery the prominent storage option. https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/renewable/timely-implementation-of-market-reforms-key-to-improve-financial-viability-of-pumped-hydro-storage-icra/99779703 https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/renewable/t...
- Manuel_D 3y agoPumped hydro is geographically limited. You might as well say we should just build more dams to decarbonize the electric grid.
- mayama 3y agoOffriver closed loop pumped hydro just needs two football size fields hundreds of meter apart in elevation. Most continents have plenty of suitable locations for PHS, though they are distributed unevenly. According to the paper, there are 600k feasible locations for PHS world wide, or capacity to store 70% of global energy demand in 2017. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-14555-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-14555-y
- Manuel_D 3y ago> Offriver closed loop pumped hydro just needs two football size fields hundreds of meter apart in elevation A football field sized reservoir isn't going to hold much water unless it's deep. Realistic pumped hydro sites are much larger than 500 square meters. And those two reservoirs can't be too far apart, because excess lateral distance reduces output and increases the energy required to refill it. It also needs to be close to a source of water in order to fill the reservoir and refill any loss due to evaporation. It also needs to be close to a major highway otherwise the costs of construction will be immense because of the long distance that materials and equipment must be shipped. This is particularly problematic because most pumped hydro potential is in mountainous terrain where transportation is expensive. And lastly, this site has to be close to places that have energy demand, otherwise you'll need to build miles and miles of transmission lines. This is also a problem because the places that have pumped hydro potential also have hydroelectric potential, and usually already generate electricity from dams. Norway and Brazil have huge pumped hydro potential, but already generate most electricity from dams. The conditions for a viable pumped hydro sites are much more narrow than "two football field sized reservoir a few hundred meters apart in elevation". The paper you cited just ran an algorithm over a terrain height map. It did not attempt to account for accessibility. Good luck developing the immense pumped hydro potential in Tibet. Pumped hydro would be great if we could teleport concrete, excavators, and turbo machinery into some of the most remote parts of the world. But unfortunately this is not in our capabilities.
- _ea1k 3y agoIn California, battery storage is already far beyond a "drop in the bucket", and we are still in the early stages of large scale deployments. I see a lot of replies that are using nationwide figures, but there is no reason that the CA model couldn't be applied everywhere... if it were cost effective to do so. That last part is the important bit. There's no physical obstacle to doing this.
- anonporridge 3y agoCalifornia can power about half of their homes with batteries for 4 hours. https://www.energy.ca.gov/news/2023-10/california-sees-unprecedented-growth-energy-storage-key-component-states-clean https://www.energy.ca.gov/news/2023-10/california-sees-unpre... That is certainly hugely significant, and does spell an end of peaker plants in the next decade. What it doesn't do is explain what is going to be the backup for long tail events where there's not enough sun or wind for days or weeks at a time.
- hotpotamus 3y ago> What it doesn't do is explain what is going to be the backup for long tail events where there's not enough sun or wind for days or weeks at a time. Oh I have the answer to this one as someone who lived in Texas in February 2021 - you just don't have power; that happens sometimes.
- anonporridge 3y agoThat will always be a possibility when systems fail, like it did during Texas winter storm. If masses of people not having power sometimes is a fundamental part of the system design and not an extreme systemic failure, then that's completely unacceptable.
- hotpotamus 3y agoOk, how often does California (or the US as a whole if we were going to do a nationwide system, or North America, or The Americas, etc....) go for weeks without sun or wind? I would think those could be known via historical data and used to model a system that works except in extreme situations.