4 ms·
Neurodivergence isn't a free pass to commit all the crimes you want. Lots of shooters are neurodivergent. That doesn't mean that society has to let them kill al
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
Neurodivergence isn't a free pass to commit all the crimes you want. Lots of shooters are neurodivergent. That doesn't mean that society has to let them kill all they want.
- drewcoo 3y agoNeurodivergence is definitionally not understanding societal rules. Also known as laws. Neurodivergence is not a "free pass to commit crimes," but an excuse to be locked up by the authorities.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoTo be clear, they aren't being locked up for being neurodivergent. They are being locked up for committing crimes and refusing to stop if released. Sure, not committing crimes is part of "playing the game", but it is a game you must play to go free. If someone can't avoid sufficiently severe crime, that is a completely valid reason to lock someone up. It doesn't matter if they can help it or not
- thomastjeffery 3y agoIf course it isn't. Neurodivergence is a reality. Our justice system can do better than be ignorant of it. Our justice system can do better than to escalate its symptoms. As a participant in democracy, I will accept no lower standard for justice. This person wasn't killing people. He was looking at secrets. There are people who don't understand that murder is wrong, and those people need to be institutionalized for the safety of everyone else. He isn't one of them.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThis person was robbing and blackmailing people. The justice system serves to prevent these actions, and should do so no matter what the mental state of the criminal is. Is your honest solution just to let them continue doing that as an accommodation for their disability?
- thomastjeffery 3y agoYou are reading my comments with the most uncharitable perspective possible. I don't advocate that we legalize blackmail or theft. I also don't advocate that we punish either with a life sentence. My point here is that he wasn't even charged for the theft or the blackmail. He was charged for the hacking. My criticism is directed at the justice system itself. Reading secrets should not carry a life sentence. Ever.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>You are reading my comments with the most uncharitable perspective possible. Im sorry if thats the case and I am trying. unfortunately, I didnt get that from your prior posts and this response as a complete nonquitter. Maybe it stems from a different understanding of the underlying facts. The perp was not sentenced to life in any way, just custody until they stop claiming they will commit more crimes upon release. In general, I agree a life sentence would be unreasonably harsh for hacking or reading secrets in isolation. Charges and conditions of release can be unrelated. You may be placed into custody for hacking, but not release if you say you will commit a more serious crime immediately after.