4 ms·
Somebody needs to take a few anger management lessons. As somebody who makes bucks off the word "agile", I feel like I should respond. I'm not going to take ap
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Somebody needs to take a few anger management lessons.
As somebody who makes bucks off the word "agile", I feel like I should respond. I'm not going to take apart his piece, because I too am sick of the manifesto and believe that the top dogs are just in this as a marketing exercise.
Having said that, Agile was not put together by those guys. That's just what their books say. Agile techniques have been being used for decades. They just didn't have the cool marketing term. You don't have to drink the coolaid to be agile -- any high-performing team is going to be agile, whether they call themselves that or not.
Second, Agile is a philosophy, not a methodology. It doesn't tell you what to do, it tells you what to think about what you're doing. Agile/Lean IS just common sense, but nobody seems to have much common sense anymore. You can apply the agile philosophy to all sorts of methodologies.
Third, Agile is not for mushy-headed enterprise guys. It probably works better for small customer-facing shops. To say agile is a response to CMM or heavy-handed processes is again to buy into the story the book-writers want to tell you. Put down the crack pipe. Agile has always been around, and has been used inside of all kinds of other methodologies.
Finally, Scrum is NOT agile. Scrum is a project management framework that you can use for agile projects. You can use a lot of others, or you can roll your own. The Scum guys are the religious nuts in this circus, if you ask me, and they are the ones causing all of the backlash. The rest of the Agile movement is just about how to best iteratively and incrementally do your job. That's a good conversation to have.
Ironically, a key factor I'm finding in successful agile teams is the ability to be open-minded. If you are an agile disciple or evangelist, or if you are a anti-agilista, usually it gets in the way of team performance. It's the people who want to have an ongoing conversation about how to keep increasing team performance -- without getting hung up over what book it was in or not -- that grow killer teams.