3 ms·
Withholding water, food, medicines for 2.3mil civilians for over 75 days, 1.1 mil children has nothing to do with fighting the enemy. It is only targeting civil
by submeta 3y ago
Withholding water, food, medicines for 2.3mil civilians for over 75 days, 1.1 mil children has nothing to do with fighting the enemy. It is only targeting civilians of whom thousands have died.
And this is not collateral damage. It is intentional as Netanyahu comparing Palestinians to Amalek (google it) means destroying all of them: „killing the women, children, even the unborn.“. Gallant compared them to human animals and then said, he‘ll cut water(!), food, medicines. Herzog says „there are no innocents in Gaza“, saying: all of them are targets. IDF dropping leafelets: leave north or you are considered combatant. Israel has effectively made all hospitals inoperational, shoots old women in churches lately, promting the Pope for a comment, saying „this is terrorism“.
So what are you trying to prove with your whataboutism? Yes, Assad was worse, but Israel is a western all and needs to act civilised, and apparently it is just taking revenge as there seems no clear strategy as to what it tries to achieve by even the withholding water and food! Let alone stopping ambulance, letting people die inside. Or snipers shooting inside hospitals. And what I said was that mainstream German newspapers and media will never report about these details.
So please stop your hasbara. Please stop downplaying Palestinian victims.
- gryzzly 3y agoRepeating lies such as "shots old women in churches" is 1000% antisemitic, now after a bit of exchange you show yourself clearly. How about that hospital? Do you think Israel and Israelis are doing this for fun? Like what your assumption is about "shooting women" or maybe "bombing hospitals" – say it already, what are you trying to say?
- submeta 3y agoDo you read news? Why did the pope condemn the shooting of two Christian women in a church in Gaza? And can you please stop insulting me? Apparently what I am saying is the IDF does not care if civilians are killed. And I am saying they deliberately target civilians, not only in Gaza, but in West Bank as well. Ample evidence. Go read Haaretz or other serious journalism. https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/18/women-mother-daughter-gaza-church-israel-cardinal-vincent-nichols https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/18/women-mother-d...
- pcthrowaway 3y agoAnd repeating lies such as "40 beheaded babies" isn't anti-muslim? I haven't heard about the "shot old women in churches" thing yet, but the IDF literally just shot to death 3 of the hostages Hamas captured, who were waving white flags, because they're so indiscriminate with their violence
- submeta 3y agoSee here for instance https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/18/women-mother-daughter-gaza-church-israel-cardinal-vincent-nichols https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/18/women-mother-d... Or google the Pope calling Israels „indiscriminate bombarding“ of Gaza „a terrorist act“ after IDF snipers shot two Christian women in a church. Snipers. No accident.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gryzzly 3y ago"Withholding water, food, medicines for 2.3mil civilians for over 75 days" – how many trucks of aid entered Gaza? How much of that aid reached Palestinians? Correct, almost none. How much water Israel was providing to Gaza before October 7? Correct, only 13% of its use, and is not obliged to provide. Where did the pipes for the canalisation and water systems go? Correct, it went to build Qassam missiles. Where would any other aid go? Correct, it will go to fight Israel and kill Israelis. Also your statement. "75 days" is simply not true – https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-reopens-second-of-three-water-pipelines-into-gaza/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-reopens-second-of-three... and is the exact example of "demonisation" and antisemitism.
- Qem 3y ago> Where did the pipes for the canalisation and water systems go? Correct, it went to build Qassam missiles. It appears the ones used to build rockets were extracted from abandoned israeli illegal settlements, in combination with IDF unexploded ordnance launched into the Strip. See: https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/56285/did-hamas-dig-up-eu-funded-water-pipes-and-turn-them-into-rockets https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/56285/did-hamas...
- gryzzly 3y agolol, according to qatar owned al-jazeera, that publishes go-pro videos by hamas terrorists (how does it get them?) and qatar literally is the place of hiding of hamas officials - good job, “skeptics”. just stop for a second before posting.
- kaba0 3y agoWithholding != not providing. It is a very muddy topic as is, but let’s not leave out that Gaza is not bordered by Israel alone. What some random politician says (and then some of them gets cut up out of context for propaganda) has not much to do with the actual official foreign policy of a country. Every civilian deaths is deeply tragic, but 0 deaths is absolutely impossible to achieve, and without eradication of hamas, the whole story will repeat again in a year or so, leaving much more innocent people die and suffer on the long run. Palestine requires a similar de-radicalization that Germany has underwent after ww2. Significant controlled investment into the region. But that can only start after there are no more hamas.
- gryzzly 3y agoI can’t answer to your other thread, obviously I read news, but The Guardian is so anti-Israel there is a book about it. Anyway, consider not reading The Guardian and Twitter, and maybe at least change to Wikipedia to have a chance of understanding something and not be hating and demonising.
- submeta 3y agoThen Google it and you’ll find a dozen other sources. Here is one fo you: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/rcna130132 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/rcna130132 You are pathetic.
- WhackyIdeas 3y agoCouldn’t have said it better myself.