5 ms·
> According to the lawmakers, CVS, Kroger, and Rite Aid said that "their pharmacy staff face extreme pressure to immediately respond to law enforcement demands
by bell-cot 3y ago
> According to the lawmakers, CVS, Kroger, and Rite Aid said that "their pharmacy staff face extreme pressure to immediately respond to law enforcement demands and, as such, the companies instruct their staff to process those requests in store."
THIS. Expecting indifferently-paid and often-overworked pharmacist assistants, clerks, etc. to stand up to law enforcement - who can easily be armed, uniformed, belligerent, and right in their faces - is cruel and delusional.
- tomrod 3y agoSimply because some cops can be brigands doesn't really mean that we shouldn't have expectations of people. Bullies are always going to bully. Roll-over-and-take-it is a terrible corporate strategy!
- swells34 3y agoYeah, I have expectations... of the police. In most large cities, this is a guaranteed six figure income, with basically no education requirements. They are literally given an "above the law" status via qualified immunity. If they intimidate someone into doing something illegal, like giving up patient information, they should be culpable. Do not punish the weakest person in the power struggle, they are nearly always the victim.
- fredgrott 3y agoat the same time those firms put the license people at risk of losing their state license by compiling without that warrant..
- sonicanatidae 3y agoThis is the part that would piss me off as a PharmD. They spend a vast sum of time, money and energy to gain a PharmD, then some asshat company puts them in situations where their licenses could be at risk? Of course they do.
- bell-cot 3y agoTheory: The state licensing boards are aware of the problem, and "neglect" to punish pharmacists who are caught in such situations with law enforcement.
- tomrod 3y agoNo, enforcement becomes roulette or leverage over people in these situations. Were I on the board of these companies, I'd be aghast and demand this clear operational issue, which threatens our capacity to provide pharmacy services long term, be remediated.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoI'd just move to an organization that doesn't callously put my license at risk. They sure af aren't going to toss me a lifetime check, when it happens.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoThis is not unlikely, but at the same time, to be put in a position where, in order to do your job, you have to rely on the understanding of "the government" is just shitty.
- codingdave 3y agoThat part stood out to me as well, but because the article said that a subpoena is still required. And it is unclear to me if those pharmacies are at least asking to see it, or if they are telling their staff to handle any and all requests, no questions asked.
- ClarityJones 3y agoI think it's a distinction without a difference. In this context, where this is no pending legal proceeding, a subpoena is just a request with no legal authority. The function of a real subpoena is to punish the recipient for failing to respond (i.e. held in contempt of court), because the request is made on behalf of the court and the court has the authority to compel production. Here, where there's no court case it's not really possible to have a real subpoena. I could equally issue a subpoena in the authority of my own name, and it would have just as much power (none).
- sokoloff 3y agoIt seems like a well-drafted company policy posted and pointed to by the local store staff would be the right way to back up their customers and staff. “Here’s the phone number to corporate who is, by this policy, the only ones equipped and permitted to satisfy your request.” This also makes it so you don’t even send a car out anymore, but can handle the request electronically from the station.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoHere’s how that would play out: You’re the only store manager out of all of the chain to have this policy. The Sherriff calls the Mayor who sends a “concerned” email to your VP of Sales. You standing up for your team not only gets you fired but now you’re on a list against the police. 2023 United States baby. Land of the free.
- gruez 3y ago>Here’s how that would play out: You’re the only store manager out of all of the chain to have this policy. The parent post specifically says that it wold be company policy, so that wouldn't apply. >> It seems like a well-drafted company policy posted and pointed to by the local store staff would be the right way to back up their customers and staff.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThe same power structure exists irrespective of where you jump into the value chain - The police are a legal gang that goes all the way to the President Instead of the Mayor, the Sheriff will go to some State Rep or congressperson and the same results happen. I've seen similar moves play out in the past in real life
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- serial_dev 3y agoCorruption and bending the rules will probably happen even with this system, but it raises the barrier, and if it's inconvenient enough, it will be only done for the most important cases. If every local sheriff can intimidate and bully a local pharmacist to get the information it's very different than if you need a congress person to call in a favor with supposedly one of the few people who have access to the information.
- tokai 3y agoOfc we should expect them to stand up. They are breaking the law full stop. I would not give out information on my users, and would rather go the station. They can't do anything but trying to frighten you. I expect everyone with access to personal data do the same.
- phatskat 3y agoI don’t expect someone in their early 20’s, being paid CVS wages, and dealing with a ton of people all day to necessarily have the best backbone in the face of an armed thug demanding information face to face. Respecting privacy should be a tenant of law enforcement, since that’s like one of our rights or something, but cops and police unions have been operating outside of the law for their entire history in the US. Obligatory ACAB
- swells34 3y agoAre not the police conspiring to break the law then, at the very least? If I intimidated you into breaking the law, while armed, would I not also be culpable? The more I think about this, the more it seems the police should be the only ones culpable in that situation...
- JohnFen 3y agoYes. The police cannot be assumed to be good guys, or even law-abiding.
- autoexec 3y ago> They can't do anything but trying to frighten you. Police can rob you, rape you, or murder you in the street and even if it's caught on camera they can still face zero meaningful consequences for that. We've certainly seen it happen. They can also arrest you for something like "obstruction" or "contempt of cop" and that's something you'd have to spend time and money on fighting later in the courts. Ongoing retaliation is something else to be concerned about. In any case, the can certainly do a lot besides "trying to frighten you"
- Madmallard 3y ago
- rblatz 3y agoI think it’s expected that pharmacists be held to the same or higher standards than we held video store clerks. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act#:~:text=Congress%20passed%20the%20VPPA%20after,to%20%242500%20in%20actual%20damages https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act....
- nativeit 3y agoIt’s too bad law enforcement don’t seem to be held to any standards at all, then maybe folks who are not generally equipped to make legal determinations won’t be accountable for erring just because an unscrupulous officer or prosecutor misleads and/or intimidates them.
- BeetleB 3y agoPharmacists are more overworked than video store clerks. By a huge margin. They're also not treated well by the major pharmacy chains.
- aetch 3y agoToo bad they aren’t paid or treated at a higher standard.
- swells34 3y agoOr perhaps the issue is law enforcement criminally intimidating these pharmacists and clerks. Seems they are the only ones that aren't held to any standard.
- creer 3y agoLawyers have to fight to get that to apply for digital video. So it would take a specific law to make that carry through to pharmacies. And for that matter, I doubt the video store law applies to bookstores. (A judge confirmation process ran in trouble because of video rental records - so a law was written ... which addresses only video rental. For maximum inefficiency or something.)
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Expecting indifferently-paid and often-overworked pharmacist assistants, clerks, etc. to stand up to law enforcement This seems trivial to solve. Subpoenas get forwarded to corporate legal and they handle releasing of records. It seems peculiar this isn't SOP now. Perhaps it's because pharmacists/managers cost less (in $ and accountability) than lawyers.
- WilTimSon 3y agoThis has the expectation that police wouldn't just pressure the clerk to do it themselves. The clerk says they'll forward it to corporate, the policeman tells him not to bother and hints that, you know, he is the one with the power here. How many people would ignore that and still do the bureaucratic procedure? Especially if the cop says it won't get back to legal and they'd be helping out on a case?
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoThe standard corporate policy would be that pharmacists aren't authorized to release records. To do otherwise would risk their jobs and whatever other action follows an unauthorized release of records. With this policy across chains, judges would be skeptical of a cop who tried to bully a local records release. Even a rogue cop could understand this reality.
- tomrod 3y agoRight, so we want to put brigands in prison regardless whether they are at times authorized to use the coercive force of the state.
- caskstrength 3y agoObviously, clerk shouldn't be able to access such data on a whim at all. Same as random "genius" in Apple Store can't access the customer iCloud data.
- ldayley 3y agoIt takes real courage to stand up to a request in those circumstances. A notable example from a few years ago was this nurse [0] who was unlawfully arrested and forcefully dragged away by an officer when she refused to take blood samples from an unconscious patient without a warrant. Imagine how much more difficult it would be to resist this when you're a clerk in a retail store working in public. [0]: https://apnews.com/article/321440980fd54809a5bf8e404cfe4367 https://apnews.com/article/321440980fd54809a5bf8e404cfe4367 (Edited to add context)
- monkaiju 3y agohttps://app.copdb.org/incidents/2ea95420-2070-4c9d-8e72-f1c68fe11359 https://app.copdb.org/incidents/2ea95420-2070-4c9d-8e72-f1c6...
- VBprogrammer 3y agoWhat makes it worse is that the person they were attempting to get the blood from was actually the innocent victim in a crash which resulted from a police chase. The police had no reason to believe the driver was under the influence.
- FireBeyond 3y agoIn fact even worse, I believe, was that the person being chased was LE-affiliated and was under the influence.
- autoexec 3y agoAfter that happened, laws were passed to make it perfectly legal to get blood from unconscious patients without a warrant (https://www.npr.org/2019/06/27/732852170/supreme-court-affirms-police-can-draw-blood-from-unconscious-drivers https://www.npr.org/2019/06/27/732852170/supreme-court-affir...) and to help avoid the problem of doctors and nurses interfering with the demands of the police, departments in several states have started training officers to draw blood from suspects themselves right on the side of the road so there's no need to take most people to a hospital. Jeff Payne, the Utah cop who was fired after his violent arrest of that nurse went viral, later got hired by the Weber County Sheriff’s Office to work in the medical unit of the county jail.
- croisillon 3y agoi used to work at a place where we had (potentially) a lot of personal and movement information about the city inhabitants ; the police would regularly call the call-center and ask for information, the proper answer was "sure, send us a warrant by email" (and we would never see any warrant) but not every worker would react properly
- aredox 3y agoLibrarians do it.
- BeetleB 3y agoLibrarians are not overworked the way pharmacists are. To give you an idea, in a nearby Walgreens, we have pharmacists snapping at customers saying "We got your prescription only two days ago. It's not going to be ready that quickly!"
- 93po 3y agoso glad i can order most of my meds delivered by mail now, pharmacies are awful for everyone
- BeetleB 3y agoIn my experience, going to one of the non-chain pharmacies (the type that don't sell laundry detergents) is always better. Either one tied to a clinic/hospital, or some independent one. With my pharmacy, I can always get it filled within an hour - I notify them before I head out.
- 93po 3y agoMy sample size of one agrees with this. Costco has also been decently good
- annoyingnoob 3y agoIn the time before ubiquitous cell phones, I was a cashier at a gas station. One day a cop came in and asked to use the phone. I directed him to the pay phone. He told me that the pay phone was in use, not realizing that I could see the p[ay phone from where I was standing. He got belligerent and demanded the phone, he made a personal call to his wife. Later he pulled me over and gave me a bogus ticket for not signaling. Real nice people those police, better give them what they want or else.
- phatskat 3y ago> better give them what they want or else A tale as old as the first police union: when the city tried to reign them in, the Portland Police politely threatened to walk off the job and the chief (iirc) casually showed up to negotiations with a dossier on one of the city councilors just laid out on the table next to his gun.
- caskstrength 3y ago> Expecting indifferently-paid and often-overworked pharmacist assistants, clerks, etc. to stand up to law enforcement - who can easily be armed, uniformed, belligerent, and right in their faces - is cruel and delusiona Why do "indifferently-paid and often-overworked pharmacist assistants, clerks, etc." even have access to this? In the US any random pharmacy clerk has access to list of all drugs that customers have ever bought from them and also "medical records" (according to the article)? WTF?
- soared 3y agoPharmacists access drug records as a double check against doctors prescriptions. They look for drug interactions, call out side affects, etc. Their role provides important value so it would be difficult to design a system where they can access the info they need but law enforcement can’t request from (without a change to corporate policy/etc)
- caskstrength 3y agoWhy can't the doctor verify all of this before prescribing? Seems to be some weird US thing.
- lupusreal 3y agoThey're supposed to, but they sometimes make mistakes. Pharmacists are supposed to know about the sort of drugs they're selling so they can catch potentially lethal errors. Doing away with this safety net to.. avoid addressing police overreach directly is a bad idea.
- caskstrength 3y ago> They're supposed to, but they sometimes make mistakes. Pharmacists are supposed to know about the sort of drugs they're selling so they can catch potentially lethal errors. Are there any stats for how many potentially lethal errors they actually catch in practice?
- JohnFen 3y agoIndeed. My wife is an ER charge nurse, and she often complains about the behavior of cops in the emergency room. They have someone on the edge of death and the cops often are in the room yelling at the nurses to get them to do a blood draw and drug screening. Cops need a warrant to get that, and even if they had a warrant in hand, performing the blood draw wouldn't even be considered until the patient is stabilized. But they never have a warrant, and the pressure the cops apply is withering. Most people -- even doctors and nurses -- would eventually cave. Fortunately, as the charge nurse, she's the one who has to approve such a thing, so the cops have to deal with her. And she's hard as a rock. They aren't going to make her wilt.
- swells34 3y agoWell, we've spoiled our police force. We've provided them with ridiculous amounts of power, minimal oversight, and very rare and minor consequences. The behavior you describe is that of a spoiled child, used to getting what it wants immediately by throwing an abusive tantrum, consequences to others and rules be damned. Same reason they execute PIT maneuvers on busy roads, lead high speed chases through the middle of towns, and empty full magazines into densely populated areas, all things that police in other countries are trained not to do, trained to be patient and follow instead. They want it now, and anyone hurt along the way is just a casualty of war, not their problem or responsibility.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The behavior you describe is that of a spoiled child This is exactly how she describes them. "Spoiled brats with guns".
- tiahura 3y agoThe goofy kids at Verizon T-Mobile and ATT manage? Why can’t licensed pharmacy techs?
- bell-cot 3y agoI'm not familiar with that...but are you comparing anonymous workers in a distant and "this call will be recorded..." call center to front-line workers, who may have an armed & angry "law" enforcement officer right in their face? If so, Apples != Oranges
- tiahura 3y agoNo, I mean the kids working at the local corporate store.