3 ms·
Yeah blowing it to bits sounds like the worst thing to do. It's like turning a bullet into a shotgun blast.
by wkat4242 3y ago
Yeah blowing it to bits sounds like the worst thing to do. It's like turning a bullet into a shotgun blast.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoWhich might be fine if the bits are small enough that they would burn up in the atmosphere, but that's making a lot of assumptions.
- hutzlibu 3y agoWell, but the basic assumption is, the more surface of the asteroid is exposed, the more will burn up in the sky. And that is pretty solid physic and should be valid. Also most of the surface on earth is water. And one big impact would create a mega tsunami. And that is magnitudes worse, than many small impacts, where the waves will then even partly cancel each other out. So obviously deflecting is the prefered solution - but breaking up as much as possible will always result in way less damage overall to the planet - but the more impacts you have, the more likely it is, that they will also hit densly populated areas. So this decision will be highly political, as if something goes wrong and for example china gets mainly hit - the final outcome might be worse.
- OscarCunningham 3y agoWaves don't cancel out, they pass through each other.
- hutzlibu 3y agoOrdinary waves travelling through the ocean, mostly yes. But when 2 Tsunamis crash into each other, you can bet, that there is lots of turbulence and energy lost and they wont have the same height afterwards.
- OscarCunningham 3y agoI think you're imagining two towering waves crashing into each other. But in fact tsunamis only pile up like that when they enter shallow water. In the open ocean a tsunami is a wide area (~100km) of slightly raised (~1m) water. If two overlapped it would just be raised twice as high, which wouldn't cause much turbulence.
- hutzlibu 3y agoOk, yes I do, but I think mega Tsunamies do pile up a bit more? And the scenario in my head was many impacts in a close area - and the resulting waves then interacting with each other with turbulence.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoBurning up in the atmosphere is still a concern. In the Cretaceous–Paleogene, aka the day the dinosaurs died, most of the damage was done by matter ejected on suborbital trajectories by the impact falling back into and superheating the atmosphere.
- adolph 3y agoI wonder if Stevenson was thinking about that event when writing Seveneves: In the near future, an unknown agent causes the Moon to shatter. As the pieces begin to collide with one another, astronomer and science popularizer "Doc" Dubois Harris calculates that Moon fragments will begin entering Earth's atmosphere, forming a white sky and blanketing the Earth within two years with what he calls a "Hard Rain" of bolides, causing the atmosphere to heat to incandescence and the oceans to boil away, rendering Earth uninhabitable for thousands of years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seveneves
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sgt101 3y agoI think that the bits hitting the atmosphere might heat the planet up a large amount. This might be bad.
- toast0 3y agoDepends when you do it, I'd think. If it's on final approach, yeah most of the bits still hit the earth, so maybe not great. If you blow up something that you're pretty sure is going to hit the earth a few orbits in the future, the bits are going to have diverse paths and hopefully many will miss or at least arrive farther in time.
- throwaway4aday 3y agoYou'd need a very, very big explosive for any but the smallest grains to have divergent paths. They would form a cloud of debris that would travel on the same orbital path but spread out a bit. Breaking an asteroid up only works if it's fairly small to begin with since anything over about 50 meters that is solid is still going to be dangerous. If you broke a 2km asteroid into a mixture of 50m to 100m chunks of solid rock or metal then you're still going to have a very bad time when all that debris obliterates a state or small country.
- southernplaces7 3y agoIf the asteroid is far enough away, blowing it apart, even partially, would change all trajectories to almost certainly miss the absurdly tiny target that is the earth from a distance of tens or hundreds of millions of miles away. On the other hand, if it happened close enough to Earth that all the little pieces, even if very tiny individually, still fall into the atmosphere, their evaporation friction would roast our world's surface for minutes to hours, terribly, causing global extinctions despite there never having been a single major impact at all. The movie Deep Impact badly fucks that last scenario up near its end when humanity is saved by the main asteroid being completely blown apart just hours away from impact with the Earth. In reality, there'd have been no literal deep impact, but the'yd have all died anyhow, literally baked to death along with every other flammable thing on the earth's surface.