3 ms·
Sibling posters seem to think that $6B isn't unreasonable (and that $6B spent on solar+batteries won't come close to replacing this plant), but I won't address
by kelnos 3y ago
Sibling posters seem to think that $6B isn't unreasonable (and that $6B spent on solar+batteries won't come close to replacing this plant), but I won't address that.
Take a look at today's CA electricity source mix[0]. Regardless of cost, why would you shut down a nuclear plant (prematurely, when there's no renewable capacity right now available to replace it) when we still burn so much natural gas?
Shutting down that nuclear plant now would require that 2.2GW supply to come from somewhere else. And I bet you it would end up coming from fossil-fuel burning. Even if the plan was to spend that $6B on building out solar and batteries, that would take, what... two or three years to come online?
Now, we should be doing both! Keep this nuclear plant online, and accelerate building out solar fields and battery storage. We shouldn't be building more nuclear plants, but things that work today... work today. Shutting this plant down right now would seem like a net negative, carbon-emissions-wise.
[0] https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html
- vlovich123 3y agoI disagree about not building new nuclear. I think we should be installing way more new nuclear capacity. Existing solar installation plans only handle peak growth during the day. However baseload power will increase (eg EVs charging overnight) and batteries are just way too uneconomical and won’t be for the foreseeable future (and they reduce the efficacy of those plants because you have to overbuild peak capacity even more to recharge the batteries during the day). Nuclear remains the cheapest and we should be installing next gen designs like MSR which are even simpler, completely safe (can’t meltdown), and generate even less waste which also means they’re cheaper projects. We get more out of every nuclear dollar we spend than we do for solar and we’ve spent a metric fuckton for solar already (it’s fine- we need solar and wind, but nuclear is well past the time to have been kickstarted into high gear but it’s never too late to start)