4 ms·
An AI that learns about chemical reactions and designs a procedure to make them
- 6stringmerc 3y agoWait, it works cheaper than Post Docs? I am somewhat serious because I am a musician. In Dallas my view is Bench Science is woefully underpaid and over performs at an unsustainable dynamic.
- postpawl 3y ago> I am somewhat serious because I am a musician. ?
- hiddencost 3y agoSaying the post docs might have it worse than musicians.
- tejtm 3y agomusicians/artists are the archetypal poster children for intense training with underpaid work. That a musician is calling out science work as the same, is notable as the musician would have the experience to know.
- ska 3y agoTypical post-docs may be the worst systemic ratio of pay to skills and experience anywhere. Probably related: it's otherwise often a pretty amazing gig. Not universal obviously.
- JonChesterfield 3y agoCopied text from Wikipedia somehow seems different from deriving the nobel prize winning process from a dataset that didn't have the answer in it. And downvotes. The article presents this as a magic box capable of novel work, and some distance down says it found the answers on Wikipedia. Those are different things, whether you're excited about LLMs or not.
- Obscurity4340 3y ago[flagged]
- devmor 3y agoDefinitely different things but I suppose “machine that finds related prior research for me effortlessly” is still quite useful.
- obmelvin 3y agoYes, missing prior work at best can impact your review, and at worst can mean you waste a significant amount of research time
- striking 3y ago> In less than four minutes, Coscientist had designed an accurate procedure for producing the required reactions using chemicals provided by the team. When it sought to carry out its procedure in the physical world with robots, it made a mistake in the code it wrote to control a device that heats and shakes liquid samples. Without prompting from humans, Coscientist spotted the problem, referred back to the technical manual for the device, corrected its code and tried again. What does it matter that it looked up the reactions on Wikipedia? They're building a "coscientist", not an AI-based Nobel prize winning researcher.
- Filligree 3y ago> What does it matter that it looked up the reactions on Wikipedia? They're building a "coscientist", not an AI-based Nobel prize winning researcher. Well, quite. This is attempting to automate the boring, time-consuming and dangerous part of chemical research. We should be applauding.
- gabegomes 3y agoYou got it! That’s part of what we did, but so much more… Coscientist democratizes access to fields that one is not a deep specialist in, allowing for people to merge different ideas with ease. Biologists can do cutting-edge chemistry, chemists can try the latest in materials science, and so on.
- thenerdhead 3y ago“Consider a future device … in which an individual stores all his books, records, and communications, and which is mechanized so that it may be consulted with exceeding speed and flexibility. It is an enlarged intimate supplement to his memory.” By Vannevar Bush
- Obscurity4340 3y agoThe Memex
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoA great idea until Big Brother subpoenas you and decides that pleading the fifth does not apply for electronic devices.
- jahewson 3y agoIt doesn’t apply to paper documents either. Though it does apply to your passcode :)
- mistermann 3y ago"Say, that's a nice 'democratic' governmental organization you have there....would be a real shame if something was to happen to it."
- BowBun 3y agoI would assume a device that records data is already fair game for evidence by legal means. If you want to get technocratic about it, you'd need to start arguing that this kind of tool is an extension of your mind/consciousness of which you are currently entitled privacy to (probably more due to lack of tech than strong ethics). But there's no tech the government does not want to regulate, so your version is probably right.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoI wonder if that memory thing Dumbledore had was open to Ministry subpeonas...
- figassis 3y agoLooking forward to having my own personal Jarvis
- teeray 3y agoYeah science! Yeah Mr. GPT!
- mcphage 3y agoIt seems... unlikely, that a LLM built from scraped webpages, would be able to predict the results of novel chemical reactions. I don't really understand what information in the model's source would lead to new insights into chemistry.
- calebkaiser 3y agoFor anyone interested in the applications of ML to chemistry, PostEra has been doing some pretty cool stuff in medicinal chemistry for the last several years: https://postera.ai/ https://postera.ai/
- mahastore 3y agoThis framework of retrieving information , analyzing it with program code as an output , programming machines to do something , retrieve information about the output of the machines , analyzing it to see if it matches the expectations and if not repeat and rinse until you get the perfect outcome .... seems useful in general for all kind of AI agents. Is this framework open source yet?
- joshuamcginnis 3y agoThis is identical to what I've been building and using my own gpt (via ChatGPT) with API integration to automate full genome base-calling, assembly, annotation and prediction pipelines. Using this approach, me and my team can use it to debug pipeline failures, interpret the results, draw inferences and create context-dependent experiments. There's no leap in the tech beyond GPT facilitating the interaction with APIs, but it is a completely new way of working. This is what I can currently do: User: Show me my genomes ChatGPT: Here's a list of your genomes ... [API call to GET /genomes] User: Annotate genome #nnnn ChatGPT: Kicking off annotation [API call to POST /annotate] User: Show me what genes are related to growth regulation for the genome ChatGPT: The genome appears to have several genes related to growth regulation. Here's a list [API call to GET /genome/X/annotations] ... User: Design an experiment to knock-out this gene using CRISPR in Aspergillus niger, include the guideRNA specific to this gene. ChatGPT: Here you go...
- Nesco 3y agoReally interesting, what would be your real-world use cases?
- joshuamcginnis 3y agoThis is the real-world use-case! We're using to accelerate the discovery and elucidation of novel or unknown gene function in previously unstudied fungal strains.
- Nesco 3y agoI should have meant, have you already found customers? I am also working on a project on genomics, which is very orthogonal to yours, and finding customers in this field the difficult part
- joshuamcginnis 3y agoWe're pursuing grant-funded research at the moment. We have some hunches on some specific fungal genetic functions but they need to be better characterized before we think about commercialization.
- gigel82 3y agoI have a friend that works on Azure Quantum Elements and they said the Copilot integration is pretty impressive. I imagine that's a very specific niche though so likely not interesting if you're not into material science or computational chemistry.
- babyshake 3y agoIs there something along these lines for physics experiments?
- samstave 3y agoSerious question: Given that AI's may (apparently) not own patents, what would be the implication if an AI (presumably) independently comes up with Nobel Laurette level chemistry/[science] - What happens to such body of work WRT the greater humanity? Who owns such (whatever the product is?) If a company has built upon whatever AI GOLLUM service, and then either the GOLLUM comes up with some epic thing, is it all for the corp that owns the GOLLUM? Does the AI provider get some slice? Is this already a solved problem and I dont know what to call it?