2 ms·
If it isn't obvious, GPL is an attack against proprietary computers and against the corporations that have been trying repeatedly over decades to bottle-up and
by guelo 15y ago
If it isn't obvious, GPL is an attack against proprietary computers and against the corporations that have been trying repeatedly over decades to bottle-up and monopolize the computer revolution.
- buu700 15y agoIs it surprising that the GPL represents the antithesis of the startup community? No matter how idealistic any large group of young hackers will want to be, fiduciary duty will always trump everything when you play with business. You can love the GPL as much as Stallman himself, but when you're grasping for any edge you can find over your competition, you'll think twice before shipping her a tarball of your source.
- StavrosK 15y agoThat's entirely off topic. We're discussing GPL versus a more free license. If anything, this is an argument for the GPL.
- buu700 15y agoOff topic? The topic, if I've read correctly, is: I feel it is sad that so few HN hackers seem to appreciate the vision of the GPL Reusing GPL'd code forces developers to in turn release their code; more free licenses don't have this effect.
- StavrosK 15y agoYes, that was the original contrast, versus the MIT license of the OP. Sure, people will opt to not release code when it contains trade secrets or whatnot, but the thread is about MIT vs GPL, basically. Anyway, not to play thread police, it just seemed to me that it was veering off into another direction. I'm cranky in the mornings!
- pbreit 15y agoGPL is an attack on the user who wants to do whatever (s)he wants.
- pygy_ 15y agoThe GPL is extremely permissive WRT users. It allows people to obtain, modify and distribute the code, provided that they keep it GPLed and provide the source with binaries. Contrast this with proprietary software. There are restrictions for developers, namely that you can't link GPLed code to non-GPLed or GPLable code, and that you can't close the source. Liberal licenses are easier on developers, but they don't guarantee that the source will remain open. Software is ubiquitous nowadays, and most appliances use closed source software of unknown quality and probity. There's spyware in every cell phone, for example. More GPL makes a better world, overall.
- enjalot 15y agoI'd rather be part of making things than attacking things. That's why I go BSD or MIT with my code.