6 ms·
I feel it is sad that so few HN hackers seem to appreciate the vision of the GPL. GPL needs more indispensable software like this for it to thrive and protect u
by guelo 15y ago
I feel it is sad that so few HN hackers seem to appreciate the vision of the GPL. GPL needs more indispensable software like this for it to thrive and protect us all from a future of completely locked down computers.
- coderdude 15y agoI'm open to a compelling argument for why the GPL is better than a license that basically says "you can do whatever you want with this." (From the perspective of deterring the locking down of computers by corporations.)
- guelo 15y agoIf it isn't obvious, GPL is an attack against proprietary computers and against the corporations that have been trying repeatedly over decades to bottle-up and monopolize the computer revolution.
- buu700 15y agoIs it surprising that the GPL represents the antithesis of the startup community? No matter how idealistic any large group of young hackers will want to be, fiduciary duty will always trump everything when you play with business. You can love the GPL as much as Stallman himself, but when you're grasping for any edge you can find over your competition, you'll think twice before shipping her a tarball of your source.
- StavrosK 15y agoThat's entirely off topic. We're discussing GPL versus a more free license. If anything, this is an argument for the GPL.
- buu700 15y agoOff topic? The topic, if I've read correctly, is: I feel it is sad that so few HN hackers seem to appreciate the vision of the GPL Reusing GPL'd code forces developers to in turn release their code; more free licenses don't have this effect.
- StavrosK 15y agoYes, that was the original contrast, versus the MIT license of the OP. Sure, people will opt to not release code when it contains trade secrets or whatnot, but the thread is about MIT vs GPL, basically. Anyway, not to play thread police, it just seemed to me that it was veering off into another direction. I'm cranky in the mornings!
- pbreit 15y agoGPL is an attack on the user who wants to do whatever (s)he wants.
- pygy_ 15y agoThe GPL is extremely permissive WRT users. It allows people to obtain, modify and distribute the code, provided that they keep it GPLed and provide the source with binaries. Contrast this with proprietary software. There are restrictions for developers, namely that you can't link GPLed code to non-GPLed or GPLable code, and that you can't close the source. Liberal licenses are easier on developers, but they don't guarantee that the source will remain open. Software is ubiquitous nowadays, and most appliances use closed source software of unknown quality and probity. There's spyware in every cell phone, for example. More GPL makes a better world, overall.
- enjalot 15y agoI'd rather be part of making things than attacking things. That's why I go BSD or MIT with my code.
- jasonkester 15y agoPlease not here though. By all means fire up a new thread and I'm sure you guys will wrap this up in no time. But for the sake of the rest of us here to discuss the topic we're discussing, please don't drop a little religious war into the middle of it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pygy_ 15y agoIt could hardly be more on topic, and until your dismissive post, the discussion was civil. You're the one who conflates licenses and religion, and who refuse to even discuss the topic. The choice of software licenses is far more nuanced than religion. There's a lot of misinformation around the GPL, and it doesn't hurt to talk about it.
- no_gravity 15y agoGPL 3 has a clause forbidding the use of GPL 3 licensed code on locked down computers. Googling for "anti tivo clause" will bring up a lot of discussion about it.
- skeptical 15y agoI for one like GPL's philosophy but to be honest I mostly use MIT on my small projects because I don't care. If credit gets attributed rightfully that's really all I care about. I don't care if the MIT is better from an economical prespective or whatever. I'm not too worried if a company can't just use my software because it's GPLed. Their effen problem, I believe. For me, the MIT license is just small and to the point. Why isn't that a valid reason?
- geon 15y agoFrom a user perspective, GPL offers in theory more freedom, since new products built on codebase X will also be free. It is debatable if this is true in practice. If less software gets built as a result of the license restriction, the GPL takes away freedom. Even closed source software adds some freedom - the freedom of choice. From a developer perspective, there is no question which one is more free. We often do not have the choice to release our software as open source, and when we do, an invasive license like the GPL is still a headache. If I can pick up a library or framework and just use it, that's the one I will pick.
- vasco 15y agoI agree with you, but just to point out what I believe the GPL people think about your point: If you're going to write non-GPL'ed code, they would prefer you wouldn't even write the code, Stallman has said this many times. I think they equate this to something along the lines of just creating more "prisons" and just because you have a bunch of "prisons" to choose where to spend your life, it doesn't make you more free
- melling 15y agoDid he say this? Seems like a really bad analogy to me. If more people are using Meteor, for example, the entire ecosystem will grow. Even if half the devs are writing closed source, they are learning a common tool and that skill lets them contribute to the common knowledge pool (eg. they can answers questions on StackOverFlow). It also creates a bigger market for Meteor developers, thus accelerating adoption.
- vasco 15y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymuqUJ3MsEs&t=3m12s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymuqUJ3MsEs&t=3m12s
- maxerickson 15y agoHe says 'non free' there, not non-GPL'ed. The FSF considers lots of licenses other than the GPL to be 'free software'.
- jwr 15y agoGPL restricts the pool of potential collaborators. Also, GPL has served its purpose: these days 1) almost everyone realizes that it is in everyone's interest to share code and contribute back (maintaining private forks is expensive in the long term), and 2) most software is offered as a service and the value is not just in the software, but also in the infrastructure, maintenance, support, etc, meaning you rarely encounter the problem of restricted liberties because of a software license. Note that you do not need a copyleft license to support sharing.
- sciurus 15y agoIn web development, perhaps. In embedded systems (including the huge world of consumer electronics like cellphones) I suspect that if the linux kernel wasn't copyleft there would be few corporate contributions to its public codebase.
- njharman 15y agoIt enforces the pool of potential collaborators. I value my work, it is not free. Either pay for it or agree to contribute your improvements.
- WiseWeasel 15y agoMost websites are commercial, and they operate in competitive spaces. They will not consider using GPL code if it means their own site code becomes GPL-licensed. GPL works when the people using it must contribute whatever small patches or modifications they have made, not when they have to turn over multi-million-dollar codebases worth much more (commercially) than the GPL tool in question.
- Sanddancer 15y agoThis would be true if it were an area where Open software didn't already dominate. As others, including the developers of Metor, have stated, this software being GPLed was detrimental to the overall user base because there were many people who were not willing to use and contribute to software with a restrictive copyright. The existing culture of web development is already centered around permissive licenses, trying to introduce a new product with more onerous usage conditions now will just lead to it languishing because its usage of the GPL is a weakness.