24 ms·
All our patent are belong to you (2014)
- porphyra 3y agoOpening up the NACS standard is nice too. They have a wall at the Deer Creek office full of patents underneath the next "all our patent are belong to you".
- inamberclad 3y agoNACS standard is the biggest thing. It's got the best infrastructure, so it's good for consumers (lots of places to charge quickly), good for manufacturers (can sell cars with simple charging solutions), and good for Tesla (able to sell electricity at a premium).
- Nullabillity 3y agoThey could also.. just have followed CCS in the first place and you people wouldn't have had this problem to begin with.
- porphyra 3y agoYeah but from a consumer perspective the svelte NACS connector is vastly more pleasant to use than the bulky CCS one.
- maddynator 3y agoIf every company started doing this, their lawyers hair are going to catch fire. This is sooooo amazing and kudos to tesla for leading the way!!
- kgwxd 3y agoIt's a 10 year old post. Facebook was doing a similar PR stunt around the same time. It's already proven to be nowhere near the benevolent gesture it appears to be.
- andsoitis 3y ago> It's a 10 year old post. Facebook was doing a similar PR stunt around the same time. Does Facebook, like Tesla, still host their statement on their website?
- danboarder 3y agoI wonder if SpaceX will also open up their portfolio now that they have also been filing and being granted many patents in recent years(1), as NASA did in 2016(2) and as Tesla did in 2014. I think it would help other space startups innovate further toward the SpaceX mission of making humans interplanetary, much like Tesla opening up their portfolio helped to progress sustainable transport. https://insights.greyb.com/spacex-patent/ https://insights.greyb.com/spacex-patent/ https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-makes-dozens-of-patents-available-in-public-domain-to-benefit-u-s-industry/ https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-makes-dozens-of-paten...
- mensetmanusman 3y agoMost of the real IP is hidden behind ITAR.
- Veserv 3y agohttps://www.tesla.com/legal/additional-resources#patent-pledge https://www.tesla.com/legal/additional-resources#patent-pled... Except the actual terms state that: "A party is "acting in good faith" for so long as such party and its related or affiliated companies have not: asserted, helped others assert or had a financial stake in any assertion of (i) any patent or other intellectual property right against Tesla" [emphasis mine] So Tesla agrees to not pursue you for patent infringement as long as you agree to not pursue Tesla for patent and copyright and trademark infringement and trade secret misappropriation. What a fine and upstanding fair agreement. And, just in case it is not clear it also states: "marketed or sold any knock-off product (e.g., a product created by imitating or copying the design or appearance of a Tesla product or which suggests an association with or endorsement by Tesla) or provided any material assistance to another party doing so." which is a explicit carveout for Tesla's copyright and trademark even though they demand you give up yours. [edit]: Added trade secret misappropriation as a reply mentioned since that is traditionally considered a intellectual property right as well.
- staticautomatic 3y agoShould probably include trade secrets for good measure
- a-dub 3y agoreads to me like "our lawn is for everyone as we want to see the technology succeed, but those who try to crap on it will be asked to leave." what's wrong with that?
- Veserv 3y agoBecause it states, "patent or other intellectual property right" for Tesla, but only "patent right" for everybody else. If you are really "opening" your patents or intellectual property then you would just have a symmetric agreement like patents for both, or intellectual property for both. You would not have a ridiculously asymmetric agreement that legalizes your usage of industrial espionage or counterfeiting. For that matter, the pledge is transitive, but only uniquely privileges Tesla intellectual property rights: "(i) any patent or other intellectual property right against Tesla" "(ii) any patent right against a third party for its use of technologies relating to electric vehicles or related equipment" See how they clearly highlight different rights. The second term is a symmetric patent pledge, everybody equally agrees to not sue each other or others over patents. But the first term says Tesla is more equal than others and you can not sue them for anything even if they steal your trade secrets or literally make counterfeits of your products.
- csours 3y agoEven if you believed Tesla/Elon in 2014, you'd still be parking your business over a trapdoor that could be pulled open at any time in the future. It's like anything a leader ever says: They can mean it sincerely at that point in time, but they can't answer for the future when they've moved on or sold the business or the environment has changed.
- dang 3y agoDiscussed at the time: All Our Patent Are Belong To You - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7884560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7884560 - June 2014 (314 comments)
- Animats 3y agoNow it's all trade secrets instead of patents. Finding out how a Tesla works is all uphill. Not just right to repair. What the cars send to the mothership is a secret. Voice? Video? Everywhere you've been?
- librasteve 3y agoI started my career in the chip business. All large semiconductor shops realised in the late 60s/ early 70s that they could destroy any competition via patent lawsuits - TI has the transistor, IBM the CPU, Intel the microprocessor, multiple fab process inventions, etc , etc. So they generally agreed patent swap agreements (not sure if this was via an organisation, or bilaterals) to avoid just giving all their money to lawyers. Today you write a patent as a defensive weapon (you sue me, I’ll sue you) or as a way for your start up to have residual value when it dies on the vine and your VCs sell the IP to a troll. So, seems that Tesla has enough IP to avoid other car firms from taking them out (probably GM has patent on using 4 wheels) … but no large firm / real competitor will dance unless they follow the chip business “all in” model.
- hacknews20 3y agoHa! Love this post.