3 ms·
In the US, the state is almost never liable for damages if the officers are performing their duties in good faith. This is true even if the officers (mistakenl
by jessriedel 15y ago
In the US, the state is almost never liable for damages if the officers are performing their duties in good faith. This is true even if the officers (mistakenly) execute a completely illegal warrant leading to substantial financial damages to an innocent citizen. Obviously, this sets up terrible incentives for the state (why bother to double check your facts and procedures if there are no repercussions for getting things wrong?), but that's how the law is.
- mcantelon 15y agoThat's pretty much legalized tyranny then.
- sedev 15y agoYes it is: and like a number of such things, it stems from the War On (Non-White People Who Use) Drugs. The incentives regarding property seizure in narcotics cases are even more perverse, and lead to brazen de facto theft.
- vacri 15y agoI think it was back in the 80s that Jello Biafra was arrested on drug charges and had property seized. The sheriff's office was able to legally sell the seized property before his trial. I don't know what happened to that law, hopefully it's been fixed since...
- nknight 15y agoCivil forfeiture is based on a simple preponderance of the evidence, and has not changed.
- jseliger 15y agoBut most people don't realize this, and they don't vote accordingly. So it persists and grows.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoI think that's hyperbole. I understand the whole "damn the man" cynicism thing you got going on but there's two sides to the coin. When you work for law enforcement you get orders and you carry them out. These people are just like anyone else; honest people trying to get by. If anything it should be the ones giving orders who get canned.
- mcantelon 15y ago>When you work for law enforcement you get orders and you carry them out. These people are just like anyone else; honest people trying to get by. If anything it should be the ones giving orders who get canned. You could say the same thing about the cops in Russia who raid businesses that have gotten on the wrong side of the state or its business network. Of course it should be the ones who give the orders who get canned. But noone gets canned. The definition of tyranny is "arbitrary or unrestrained exercise of power". That accurately describes the current situation where authorities can, with no risk to themselves, freely take your property and destroy your livelihood even when you've broken no laws. The fact that the US can even do this to people in other countries should be concerning to anyone who values rule of law.
- msg 15y agoThis is the whole point of the Stanford Prison Experiment. "I merely played my part"
- rooshdi 15y agoDon't forget the Milgram Experiment: http://www.cnr.berkeley.edu/ucce50/ag-labor/7article/article35.htm http://www.cnr.berkeley.edu/ucce50/ag-labor/7article/article... http://youtu.be/W147ybOdgpE http://youtu.be/W147ybOdgpE And the good ole Elevator Experiment: http://youtu.be/aX1gL5Zqkao http://youtu.be/aX1gL5Zqkao
- billpatrianakos 15y agoUgh I knew that either the prison experiment or Nazis would come up. Hyperbole. It's a real fine line and equating some of the things people have retorted with to what's happened with MegaUpload isn't fair. They're not n the same level. Yeah, there's potential for abuse but at the same time I see this as a necessary evil. You trust and hope that they get things right most of the time. That's the social contract we all enter into unless we want anarchy. But all I was saying is try to see things as the other side would. As the guys carrying out orders would. We have a hard time putting ourselves in others' shoes around here. Try it out and maybe what I said will sound just a little more reasonable.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]