3 ms·
The mirrors on this are coated with an element that is specifically good at reflecting IR wavelengths. If it was meant for visible spectrum, it would potentiall
by dylan604 3y ago
The mirrors on this are coated with an element that is specifically good at reflecting IR wavelengths. If it was meant for visible spectrum, it would potentially be coated with a different material.
Complaining about JWST not making visible spectrum light images is like complaining that a hammer doesn't really work driving in a screw. It's not meant to do that, so stop trying to do it, and definitely stop complaining about it since it's just a misunderstanding of its purpose.
- Sporktacular 3y agoChill out Dylan
- hnburnsy 3y agoIt can't do more than one thing?
- dylan604 3y agoBecause of the coating of the mirrors is gold specifically because it is designed to image in IR. "Gold just happens to reflect blue light very poorly but red and infrared light extremely well."[0] This would make visible light images extremely poor if it is not reflecting all wave lengths equally. Think of it like the *nix core belief that you design a thing to do one thing be really fast at it and do it really well while avoiding making something that does a lot of things mediocre and not nearly as fast. We have platforms that are better at imaging visible light. A lot of them. We have nothing with the capabilities of JWST. We have X-ray telescopes. We have microwave telescopes. Trying to ask JWST to be a shittier IR telescope to enable visible light imaging is just a waste of time, effort, and money. [0]https://www.jwst.nasa.gov/content/about/faqs/faq.html?linkId=142822511#gold https://www.jwst.nasa.gov/content/about/faqs/faq.html?linkId...
- lsaferite 3y agoI've read about the JWST and know all about the optical path and why the 400-600nm range is not there. I simply said it was a shame that that range wasn't included so we could get Blue and Green. I hardly view that as complaining and even if it were, why the hell are you getting so bent out of shape over a simple statement? Maybe don't be an ass.
- xwolfi 3y agoYou're the one on the verge of swearing to be fair. He pointed out your misunderstanding of the purpose of a telescope (to see things we need to see, rather than things we can see with eyes adapted to the heavy brightness of Earth) and that your complaint was unfair since you can always just build it yourself if you like to look at yellow featureless balls in the Earth-adapted light spectrum you enjoy. No need to call him an "ass" over it, just apologize politely :)
- dylan604 3y agonow, you've gone from complaining about to whining about it. it's only a shame if you don't understand the entire purpose of the telescope. if you understood the purpose of the telescope, you'd realize why trying to make it do both IR and visible light would be pointless. to catch the faintest light of the furthest galaxies that has been red-shifted we need the most sensitive instrument would could make. ignoring blue and green wavelengths is the only way of doing it. you make every decision to enhance the ability to see the red. it's like saying it's a shame drum&bass doesn't have more guitars. you might have that opinion, but it is absolutely pointless in the purpose of the thing your opinion is about.