6 ms·
Meta's news ban in Canada remains as Online News Act goes into effect
- infamouscow 3y agoThe Canadian government will repeal this law at some point in the future. I suspect after someone realizes they need Meta to disseminate the state-sponsored narrative to manufacture consent.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- IronWolve 3y agoCanadian news sites that compete against the CBC, if they advertise on meta, most of the money gets paid to CBC. Thats not capitalism.
- randomdata 3y agoWas there, uh, something to suggest that it is capitalism? The CBC is openly and explicitly publicly owned. There is not even a shroud of private capital ownership to be found.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoAnd they lost the ability to make news organizations they don't agree with wear distinguishing labels and symbols like YouTube does. Corporate-friendly, populist fascism is on the ascent internationally. Although it is often too stupid to efficiently harm or kill most of us, I don't have faith that it won't try to build a wall to address the causes of climate change.
- donmcronald 3y ago> Under the single deal struck between the government and Google, for example, up to 30% of the funds will go towards broadcasters, with 7% of that going to Canada's public broadcaster, the CBC. > A majority of the money will go to print and online media, with the amount determined by how many full-time employees they have. > The study added that local news outlets in Canada have been hit the hardest. I'm not surprised to see a law that favors entrenched corporate media at the expense of small local media. It's been that way as long as I can remember. I think we'd have been better off with a law that said Facebook needs to serve local news for X% of the (news) content. That would invigorate local media and, I think, be more palatable for Facebook.
- ygjb 3y agoI think there are trade-offs. Small local media is vitally important, but the problem implicit there is that biasing towards small, local media also means diverting funding to small teams that may or may not be high quality. For every Indiegraf, Tyee, or even small town papers like the Flin Flon Reminder, there is a Rebel Media that is just a microcosm of everything wrong with the media.
- lainga 3y agoIs the implied solution for the Federal government to draw up a list of acceptable media orgs? I think you'll get traction, that's very Canadian.
- ygjb 3y agoI don't know the solution, but if there was going to be a committee formed to evaluate acceptable media organizations, I don't think the committee should be staffed by the government - there should be an appointed ombudsman who has responsibility for transparency, and it should be radically open. Beyond that, I would assume that there should be a method of identifying people who have actually studied journalism and it's role in society, for example, with a masters or doctorate in journalism and who have been actively engaged in the industry should be suitable.
- tharmas 3y ago+1 for mentioning the Tyee.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoA straight pro-rata share would have seen even more of the money go to the large corporates.
- phyrex 3y agoMeta doesn’t curate the news sources, it’s what the users share, so you couldn’t enforce that kind of quota
- entuno 3y ago> But it has also been met with resistance by Google and Meta - the only two companies big enough to be encompassed by the law. Surprised to see that Twitter isn't covered by this as well? Surely they meet the requirements of "companies that operate social media platforms or search engine websites in Canada - where news is often shared and disseminated - and that have a total global revenue of more than C$1bn in a calendar year."
- randomdata 3y agoAlso needs to have at least 20 million users in Canada. Twitter reportedly has fewer than 8 million users in Canada.
- SpecialistK 3y agoHonestly.... Good. I'm upset that Google buckled, even at a lower dollar amount than I'm sure the government wanted. This legislation is disgustingly out of touch with the reality of how something as simple as linking works. My fellow Canadians need to feel the impact to remind them of how awful this government is. Luckily, it seems like the writing is already on the walls...
- ygjb 3y ago> My fellow Canadians need to feel the impact to remind them of how awful this government is. That is a pretty general blanket statement. I don't agree with alot of the choices the current government has made, but I also don't believe there is an effective, credible alternative in Canada at the moment. The current front-runner's biggest claim to fame is that he is the last sock-puppet standing from the previous Harper administration, and has not yet released a substantial platform or initiative that should galvanize people besides "Trudeau bad" and "wokeness bad".
- randomdata 3y ago> The current front-runner's biggest claim to fame is that he is the last sock-puppet standing from the previous Harper administration There is no single "front runner". The front runner is entirely dependent on the riding. That may describe the front runner in one particular riding, but there are 337 others where that is probably not the case.
- ygjb 3y agoYep, except when was the last time the prime minister of Canada wasn't the party leader of the party invited to form a government after a federal election? Saying that Pierre Poilievre isn't the CPC front runner when polling indicates that the LPC is down in the polls, and we have an as yet undeclared election coming up is disingenuous. No, Canadians don't elect the Prime Minister, and yes it is most likely that one of Trudeau or Poilievre will form a government after the next election, unless Trudeau steps down before or during the campaign starts.
- Karawebnetwork 3y agoI've written it before, but: one side effect of this whole ordeal that I hate is the fact that fake news sites and conspiracy theory sites that masquerade as "news sites" are not blocked. The result is that platforms are filled with bad content that some people find hard to differentiate from the truth.
- randomdata 3y ago> some people find hard to differentiate from the truth. Oh well. This recent obsession with truth is quite strange to begin with[1]. Enlightened minds do not concern themselves with absolute truths, but rather focus on establishing models that can stand up to experimentation. The model does not even have to follow truths as long as it provides sufficiently accurate results. [1] On second thought, it is not really that strange that we've seen that recent emergence. It is a great social device for nefarious actors to sway opinion in their favour – "I don't need to experiment because what I have before me is the truth!" There is a lot of incentive by those nefarious actors to promote truth seeking as being virtuous.
- Karawebnetwork 3y agoThere are still lies out there. The Earth is not flat, there is no binary solar system hidden amongst the clouds, reptilians aren't destroying the country and birds do exist.
- randomdata 3y agoAll quite easy to validate under experimentation when using a model and not relying on someone to communicate to you what they claim is true. The latter is a model that falls apart very quickly.
- jaarse 3y agoThe current Canadian government can’t seem to screw up the Internet fast enough for Canadians. Between this law, Bill C-11, and Bill S-210 they have gotten off to a pretty good start. But who’s going to save the our precious “Canadian culture” if JT doesn’t come to the rescue?!