4 ms·
You (or your landlord) should probably hire an electrician to get that checked out – especially the higher voltage might be indicative of some scarier failure m
by lxgr 3y ago
You (or your landlord) should probably hire an electrician to get that checked out – especially the higher voltage might be indicative of some scarier failure modes.
A voltage drop of 25% could also mean you have semi-broken wiring somewhere, which can cause fires or shock hazards on faulty appliances.
- nicolaslem 3y agoI did but unfortunately it quickly turned into all parties involved blaming each other (it's your utility, it's your installation...) and it got nowhere. For the past year it's been much more stable than before so I don't worry too much about it.
- smallpipe 3y agoMake sure you have good insurance and multiple loud smoke detectors...
- ajb 3y agoInsurance won't cover if you knew there was a fault and didn't fix it!
- repiret 3y agoDo you have a citation for that?
- ajb 3y agoSure. This is the relevant clause in my current home insurance policy: "You must take steps to maintain the Home in a good state of repair and take all reasonable precautions to avoid loss, damage or injury and to safeguard all property insured from loss or damage." These things are pretty standard - I would be very surprised if there isn't a similar clause in all of them. Which implies that, if you fail to do so, they don't have to pay up. The wording in your policy may be different. What are "reasonable steps" will depend on legal precedent. It may, for example, take into account that you're not an expert, and will probably include some reasonable time to get stuff fixed. But certainly it provides them the opportunity to deny a claim. Obligatory disclaimer: I am not a lawyer or insurance expert, get your own advice if you need it.
- repiret 3y agoIt seems plausible that not addressing the electrical anomaly described by nicolaslem could be called a failure to maintain the home under your policy. For completeness, the relevant section from my policy is "We will not pay for any loss to the property...as a result of...Neglect, meaning neglect of the insured to use all reasonable means to save and preserve the property at and after the time of a loss, or when property is endangered". But in the same context, it says "However, we will pay for any resulting loss from ... defect, weakness, inadequacy, fault, or unsoundness in ... design, specifications, workmanship, repair, construction, renovation, remodeling, grading or compaction; [or] maintenance." It would be shaped by the legal precedent in interpreting these sorts of clauses, and perhaps also the whims of a jury. It still seems unlikely to me that either of our policies would end up excluding the electrical anomaly, and moreover I've yet to ever hear a verifiyable account of someone whose homeowners insurance claim was denied after an electrical problem in their house led to a loss.
- ajb 3y agoI don't know if that exact case can be found, but it's a fairly obvious generalisation of the general principle. that if failure to repair in a timely way a fault or delapidation can result in reasonably forseeable further damage, insurers will be very reluctant to write policies cover the further damage; because it would result in moral hazard in the purchaser of insurance. So I would personally not like to rely on it being covered (apart from the obvious risk to the person of the house burning down). That's not to say that the original electrical fault wouldn't be insured - that depends on other terms. Your policy does seem to be more lenient than mine in that it allows "resulting loss from " ... "inadequacy or unsoundness in" ... "maintenance". I wonder what the scope of that is in reality.
- astura 3y agoNobody can provide you with a citation because the specifics will be the wording that's in your individual policy. But, generally, policies require you to maintain the property.
- amluto 3y agoSee above about a broken neutral. A broken neutral is bad. One could easily load a system or even just have wetter soil so that the voltages are well balanced for a while despite the neutral being open, but that doesn’t make it less bad.
- ajb 3y agoI would not assume that this fault is not dangerous TBH. May well be a good idea to hassle them some more. If you're renting, you don't need to care who is at fault - your landlord needs to sort it. If you own, you may need a 3rd party electrician to settle the argument.
- cesarb 3y agoMy first guess would be something like a broken neutral wire, making the neutral voltage depend on the imbalance of the load between the AC phases. From the little I understand about it, you could have up to the phase to phase voltage between the broken neutral and one of the phases, with the voltage dynamically changing as devices are turned on or off. It's very confusing (since everything expects the neutral to be referenced to the earth, which is constant 0V by definition), and can burn up devices.
- MadnessASAP 3y agoThat definitely reads like somebody removed/forgot the neutral bond. You're understanding is correct, if neutral is allowed to float it's voltage will depend on ratio of the load on the 2 phases. It also creates a variety of hazardous conditions and opportunities to make spicy metal. You can play with it here courtesy of Paul Falstad and Iain Sharp: https://tinyurl.com/yq4lukm6 https://tinyurl.com/yq4lukm6
- dylan604 3y agoDips and spikes are routine in electrical power delivery. In my experience, dips are much more likely to be the culprit of damaging equipment than spikes. People are used to protection from spikes with surge protectors, but the only thing that protects from dips is a UPS. I use a small UPS as part of my entertainment equipment. Not because I want to watch TV during an outage, but to keep from damaging the equipment with the power dips.
- lxgr 3y agoHow would a power dip damage an appliance?
- dylan604 3y agoIf it's turned off or it is on and not being used, probably not much. But more and more equipment no longer has an off mode and is more of an idle stand-by mode, so current is still always being used by part of the system. The point is that in electricity delivery, it is normal to have deviations in the voltage as acceptable. Most power supplies have tolerances that can handle these deviations. A dip is something outside of the deviations that most people don't consider as they are only focused on spikes and only use surge suppression devices. Since the only protection from dips is a more expensive battery solution, most people do not bother outside of computer related usages.
- lxgr 3y agoAh, so e.g. something like a device flipping between “powered” and “not powered” states, which then wears out some part that doesn’t expect that state change to happen so often?
- dylan604 3y agono, not quite. a dip is some lower than the accepted deviations from the expected value. if you have an accepted range of +/-10%, but the dip causes the voltage to drop 15%, that's a dip. some places define an outage as being less than 5% of expected value. so somewhere before outage, you have a severe undervolt situation where the equipment struggles. the longer the dip lasts, the worse things can get. one of the shops that I worked at suffered a catastrophic situation when a nearby construction crew cut one phase of the 3-phase power coming into our facility. the poor transformer died, and took out the some of the more delicate PSUs attached to some very expensive equipment. we were down for weeks recovering from that.