2 ms·
> What's the point of calling something a species if it's a different plant or animal! That's like grouping cats and dogs as the same species called Quadlegs Ad
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
> What's the point of calling something a species if it's a different plant or animal! That's like grouping cats and dogs as the same species called Quadlegs Adorables
There is a lot of essentialism that went into initial efforts at taxonomy and a lot that people believe instinctively that they bring to their own modern understanding of it.
By now it is agreed that the correct use of taxonomy is to classify organisms in groups according to common descent from earlier organisms. This was not true as recently as the 1980s, when my mother's college biology textbook included a "teach the controversy" section explaining that that was one approach to taxonomy, but there were other approaches that also made very good points. [Editorial note: there were other approaches, but of course it isn't true that they made good points. They made points like "it's important for each taxon at a given level to contain the same number of species as the other taxa at that level".]
Anyway, once you lose the essentialism, you discover that there is no way to determine what label ["kingdom" / "class" / "genus"...] should be given to a taxon. [= a group of organisms sharing common descent from an ancestral organism.] So you see that divisions between taxa that are important, but that don't match up to traditional boundaries, are given names like subspecies, subfamily, and infraorder.
You might consider why you think it's absurd to unite the categories of "cats" and "dogs", but you see no problem uniting "dachshunds" [tiny and oblong, aggressive, like entering burrows to hunt] with "newfoundlands" [huge, affectionate, like rescuing humans from water]. Just the size differences are such that a female dachshund is unlikely to be able to breed with a male newfoundland. But also consider that rescuing drowning humans is such an important part of the newfoundland lifestyle that they have webbed feet.