3 ms·
Some have suggested courts are less willing to enforce "click-wrap" agreements against consumers than they are against corporations. The later might be more li
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
Some have suggested courts are less willing to enforce "click-wrap" agreements against consumers than they are against corporations. The later might be more likely to read and thus consent. Did Beeper read the Apple ToS. What do you think.
Perhaps the outcome of challenging Apple's ToS depends on where the case would be filed. For example, 5th Cir would favour Beeper as it follows Vault v Quaid. 1st Cir follows Bowers v Baystate and would favour Apple. 8th Cir has followed Bowers (See Davidson, the Blizzard case).
"[P]rivate parties are free to contractually forego the limited ability to reverse engineer a software product under the exemptions of the Copyright Act[,]" Bowers v. Baystate Techs, Inc., 320 F.3d 1317, 132526 (Fed. Cir. 2003)
But note that in Bowers, Baystate did not actually attempt to plead fair use or copyright misuse. It only focused on preemption. The Bowers case is used to argue against reverse engineering as fair use but Baystate never asserted that defense.
The so-called "tech" companies and their supporters would prefer Bowers to apply everywhere. But it does not apply everywhere.
What is more interesting than the copyright issues, IMHO, is the idea of an antitrust illegality defense to breach of a software license. From 1996,
https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/articles/pdf/v09/09HarvJLTech237.pdf https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/articles/pdf/v09/09HarvJLTech23...
Samuelson and Scotchmer mentioned it again in 2002.
"While antitrust and competition law may regulate antireverse engineering clauses in an appropriate case or context, no such claim has as yet been brought, let alone sustained."
https://www.yalelawjournal.org/pdf/200_ay258cck.pdf https://www.yalelawjournal.org/pdf/200_ay258cck.pdf
- EMIRELADERO 3y agoI'm surprised that the defendants in the Bowers case didn't raise a public policy argument. Wouldn't the reverse-engineering exceptions both to copyright (made by common law precedent through fair use) and the DMCA (section 1201(f)) be strong evidence of such a public policy position? Were it otherwise, any copyright holder could lock their software behind an EULA or similar agreement that prohibits reverse-engineering and foreclose what would otherwise be fully legal research into the non-copyrightable expression/systems/methods in the software code.