3 ms·
That obviously depends on your objectives and world view. In my opinion, it teaches that the NATO should have stayed out of the region in the first place, and
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
That obviously depends on your objectives and world view.
In my opinion, it teaches that the NATO should have stayed out of the region in the first place, and the US specifically should be carefully about upsetting regional power balances.
>Devil's advocates tend to glance over the fact that these red lines were respected at the time and Ukraine nor Georgia were offered any closer integration with the EU and NATO
This is not very accurate IMO.
There were significant NATO policy decisions immediately preceding the 2014 invasion with respect to Ukraine. Further decisions were taken immediately proceeding the 2022 build up and subsequent invasion.
The first was in 2008 when NATO decided Ukraine could start the NATO membership process.
This came to a head at the start of 2014 when Euromaidan revolution lead to a change of government.
Feb 2014, Russisa takes Crimea
In 2016, Ukraine was granted a NATO Comprehensive Assistance Package (CAP), comprising the advisory mission at the NATO Representation to Ukraine as well as 16 capacity-building programs and Trust Funds.
In 2018, Ukraine was officially given NATO aspiring member status.
2021 NATO reaffirmed that Ukraine will become a member.
2021 Russa Masses on the Ukrainian boarder and makes the same threat of invasion it has made for 10 years if it doesn't get US assurance that Ukraine will not be allowed to join NATO. US still refuses
2022 Russia invades.
This whole war was telegraphed a decade ago and nobody involved was willing to compromise.
I think personally that it would have been better if the parties involved could come to a solution based in self-determination and demilitarization.
- brnt 3y agoWhat the Kremlin says and what is actually means and does are so fundamentally divorced that it would be endearing that you think you can take them at their word if it wasn't so painful because even the slightest bit of study on the subject would tell you how dangerously foolish that is. The Kremlin has telepraphed exactly one thing, since forever: they'll try to get away with blatant bluff, force, oppression and otherwise until the day Muscovy is no more. The only rational thing would be to bite the bullet now, while it is at its smallest in years, and take the Kremlin out. Just end it, and forcibly put something sane in its place. The good news is that this snake doesn't have much more than a head, and that disintegration is a given.
- ultimafan 3y ago>What the Kremlin says and what is actually means and does are so fundamentally divorced that it would be endearing that you think you can take them at their word if it wasn't so painful because even the slightest bit of study on the subject would tell you how dangerously foolish that is. >The Kremlin has telepraphed exactly one thing, since forever: they'll try to get away with blatant bluff, force, oppression and otherwise until the day Muscovy is no more. I think we tend to scrutinize our enemies harder than ourselves sometimes in that regard. I don't know what country you're from and thus won't try to guess, but here in the US looking at what our politicians have said or say over the years they're guilty of a similar disconnect. What's important is that there have been two decades of noise in Russia over what's happening now and we disregarded it, diplomatically snubbed them, stoked the flames, and followed up by not taking the steps to take full responsibility for Ukraine's safety when the dam finally burst. When the situation was reversed, and Russians were meddling in our own backyard with Cuba, we were able to reach a diplomatic solution instead of escalating- we (understandably) blew a gasket over a foreign superpower encroaching on our local home sphere of influence, reached out, and they backed down with concessions that made both sides relatively happy to leave that conflict at that. Now that something similar is happening on their side of the world, we were more than happy to goad them until they invaded. Russia's actions in Ukraine are disgusting but it's understandable what the parent comment meant when he said this was telegraphed many years in advance.
- brnt 3y agoThe situations are so uncomparable, the kind of claims, aims, methods and history so different, that I'll just ask you to examine those facts a bit further. Im not American, perhaps you guessed. What (some/many) Americans dont get is that its not about 20th century geopolitics. It's about a consistent pattern playing out for the past 500 years, more depending on how you count. You can check out Timothy Snyder's lecture for a taste of that history. It's about Russia never backing off ever. That's the only role the US plays: providing a credible threat greater than Russia can muster. This Russia hasn't changed in that way of dealing, because it is core to its conception (collaborators with the Golden Horde). I never will. Cuba was far less of a thing for them then it was for the US. They didn't back off at all, that is a misunderstanding of their goals and means.
- mopsi 3y ago> The first was in 2008 when NATO decided Ukraine could start the NATO membership process. NATO membership of Ukraine and Georgia was, is, and in foreseeable future remains a pipe dream. Any hope of NATO entry was dashed when Russia invaded in 2014, because NATO members did not and do not want to get involved in an on-going conflict. It's always been the opposite: weakness has encouraged Russia to act bolder and bolder. We are now at watershed moment where the previous policy of appeasement has been discredited beyond repair and western experts have finally begun to universally recognize this simple truth. > This whole war was telegraphed a decade ago and nobody involved was willing to compromise. There is nothing to compromise over. Russia wants to subjugate us, we want to live in freedom. We have as much common ground with Russians as Britons or the French had with Germans when Hitler "telegraphed" his intentions. > I think personally that it would have been better if the parties involved could come to a solution based in self-determination and demilitarization. This strategy is how most neighbors of Russia from Finland down to Romania got invaded by Russia the last time around and lost a sizable portion of their population to Russian crimes of genocide. Even Sweden, which had been neutral since Napoleonic times, decided to ditch neutrality and sign a mutual defense pact with other European nations, because the threat of Russian aggression is too large to face alone.