3 ms·
> By all accounts it is essentially a subway with smaller cars that is more point to point, which would seem to be more efficient. … Why would that be more eff
by rsynnott 3y ago
> By all accounts it is essentially a subway with smaller cars that is more point to point, which would seem to be more efficient.
… Why would that be more efficient? Generally, when you’re trying to eke the last drops of efficiency out of a train system, what you do is use _longer and longer_ trains (this can get slightly silly at the extremes; some train services will actually require passengers to move to a specific set of carriages to get off at certain stations, because the stations can’t accommodate the whole train).
Based on their own claims, the system has a peak capacity of 4500/hour. Not per direction (the capacities of train systems are usually quoted per direction); _in total_. 40,000 people per hour is a reasonable capacity for a modern single line fully segregated metro system. 4500/hour would be pretty anemic for a modern _tram_ system. 4500 per hour is a busy single bus route (one 80 person bus a little over every two minutes, two directions); it’s just not really in the conversation as far as metro train lines go.
Now, there’s a place for low-capacity transport systems, though I’m not sure why this particular one couldn’t be implemented by just using a bus lane. But something like this simply isn’t competitive with a metro rail line.
- verdverm 3y agoIt can be unit wise less efficient while overall more efficient. It's on demand, meaning the system only moves a car when it is needed. It doesn't have to move larger cars on a schedule to ensure availability. Another thing to consider is the context. Does Vegas need to invest in a large scale subway system? Do they have the demand for that? One of the big benefits they saw in Boring is that they could do it piecemeal and I don't think they are paying anything for the system, so the risk for them is quite low. Is there a company that would build and operate a subway system for a city at their own expense?