3 ms·
Can you clarify what is destructive? Is there a reason the originals need to be kept, like for some kind of chemical analysis? Or should descendants be allowe
by crazygringo 3y ago
Can you clarify what is destructive?
Is there a reason the originals need to be kept, like for some kind of chemical analysis?
Or should descendants be allowed to claim them, and the rest auctioned off?
Especially for something as generally mundane as wills, it's not obvious to me why high-resolution scans don't suffice for all future historical, legal, and archival purposes.
- hardlianotion 3y agoFrom the site explaining what is to be done: "Currently about 110 million physical documents are stored costing taxpayers £4.5 million per year. The consultation is seeking views on keeping hard copies for about 25 years, in recognition of their sentimental value to families, while saving them digitally longer term." https://www.gov.uk/government/news/easier-access-to-historic-wills-under-new-government-plans https://www.gov.uk/government/news/easier-access-to-historic... I was wrong to call the _process_ destructive, but I disagree with the proposed disposal policy.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoEven in a restricted context (the apparent documented information), hard copies have advantages over digital copies under two considerations. First, they survive technological obsolescence. Consider how even reading a floppy disk is a huge pain in the ass for most people today. Now stretch the time frame. (Some might say that all you need to do is copy the contents to a new medium when upgrading. Sure, you can do that, but it has a migration cost, and perhaps some risk. It's not a freebie. Compare that to keeping around hard copies.) Second, they have historically been less ephemeral. Sure, we have durable, write-once media out there that manufacturers claim will last thousands of years (we'll see in...thousands of years), but that's rare. For important stuff, you should a) keep the hard copy, b) make a digital copy, and c) create backups. You have the option of migrating or reinjesting the original source material, at least.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoHard copies have significant risks themselves - They're vulnerable to misfiling, to mishandling, and perhaps most importantly, destruction - By natural disaster or human hands. A well organized archive can have much more redundancy, including georedundancy, for the same price. Further, it can have massively redundant metadata - Imagine if we had a reasonable checksum of every document in the archives of everyone who was interested - And then in the event the main archive was lost or offline, we could have a verified reconstruction from the archives of people who had copies of the metadata and partial copies of the data. https://www.archives.gov/personnel-records-center/fire-1973 https://www.archives.gov/personnel-records-center/fire-1973
- crazygringo 3y agoI think I would challenge both of these points: > First, they survive technological obsolescence. Consider how even reading a floppy disk is a huge pain in the ass for most people today. Most paper hasn't survived technological obsolescence, because it hasn't survived at all. Nobody's keeping anything on floppies, everything's migrated as you say: > but it has a migration cost, and perhaps some risk. It's not a freebie. Nobody saying it's a freebie, but it's a heckuva lot cheaper than running massive physical warehouses and libraries and museums with security guards and fire suppression systems and everything. And no, there's virtually no risk when you're always keeping distributed backup copies. We use checksums and things to prevent data corruption. > Second, they have historically been less ephemeral. Again, no -- hard copies have historically been far more ephemeral. Remember what happened to the Library of Alexandria? Hard copies are susceptible to fire, war, economic disintegration, and so forth. Digital copies can both have plenty of geographically distributed official backups made and maintained, and also be open to personal backups as well if desired. Keeping hard copies around seems like far more expense for zero benefit -- at least for things that don't have sentimental/museum value.
- eviks 3y ago> Sure, you can do that, but it has a migration cost, and perhaps some risk. It's not a freebie. Compare that to keeping around hard copies.) There is a bigger risk with hard copies since they are unique, and storing them is more expensive, so in neither of those points the simple fact that there is a risk and a cost means much, no option is a freebie
- Teever 3y agoThere's a ton of historical and anthropological reasons to keep the physical copies of artifacts like this. I dream of a day when genetic sequencing is so affordable and trivial, that we can analyze records like this for DNA from people and other organisms that came to be deposited on these pieces of paper. Imagine the possibilities of sequencing the geneomes of all the people who left genetic material on these wills and what that could tell us about society and people who lived in it.
- crazygringo 3y agoIs that scientifically plausible? I'm ignorant here -- does simple handling of paper leave a genome's worth of DNA? Is it probable that even a single skin cell was deposited, for example, and that its DNA would remain intact enough? My impression was that in handling papers, we leave skin oils behind but generally not any cells. I'm happy to be wrong about this, though.
- Teever 3y agoThink of how many people lick their digits before thumbing paper, or have small cuts that leave blood on paper when they touch it, or who sneeze on paper. There's DNA on everything, and the ancient DNA on papers stored in an archive will one day be very valuable.