3 ms·
Just like everything else I remember at the time most of HN were singing songs and praise about the Tesla infotainment interface and everything touch screen. Pe
by ksec 3y ago
Just like everything else I remember at the time most of HN were singing songs and praise about the Tesla infotainment interface and everything touch screen. People who preferred buttons were the minorities. "You already have to look at buttons for playing songs or X why not make everything touch screen."
Now the tide has finally turned. Sigh.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoWhy sigh?
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoWhy downvote a simple question?
- jansan 3y agoComments without content and humor is a sure fire way on HN to get downvoted.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoOh the drama. I'll downvote them, as payback haha.
- ksec 3y agoI had a rant about a the whole thing, but I deleted it before posting but somehow left the sign there.
- mqus 3y agoI think in VWs case there was the additional circumstance that their touch screen was just abysmal.
- bdcravens 3y agoI haven't driven a Tesla, but perhaps the interface is more intuitive? I feel like on VW and others with terrible interfaces, it was more of an afterthought, kinda like a web app that spent $200k on the API and then had a budget of $10k for the front end that needed to go live in a couple of weeks.
- TheKnack 3y agoThe Tesla interface reminds me of the iOS settings page. A huge list of options and you have to drill down multiple levels to find the setting you want to change. Definitely not easy to use while driving, IMO. There have been lots of complaints because there are no physical controls for things such as windshield wiper speed on some Tesla models. They just put out a software update in response to complaints about that, but people don't seem to like the "fix". https://www.reddit.com/r/TeslaModelY/comments/1305970/finally_physical_wiper_controls/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TeslaModelY/comments/1305970/finall... I test drove a Model S but ended up buying a RAV4 Prime plug-in hybrid instead. The controls are much better on the RAV4. There are physical buttons for almost everything.
- agloe_dreams 3y ago> A huge list of options and you have to drill down multiple levels to find the setting you want to change. I'm confused by your concept that there are multiple levels -There isn't. There is the car page with 10 tabs, all with only top-level information and the default tab has steering wheel and mirror controls, both are set-it-and-forget-it with driver profiles. The wipers suck, for sure. I honestly think they could fix that in a software update or at least make more intuitive controls. Currently the wipe speed menu pops up if you hit the wipe button. That said, zero of the settings in the car menu should ever be used while driving. The auto-headlights work well enough and it has a traditional stalk for that anyways.
- metabagel 3y ago> I'm confused by your concept that there are multiple levels -There isn't. There is the car page with 10 tabs Ten tabs? This sounds complicated.
- vincnetas 3y agoThese are not necessary the same people ;)
- ricardobeat 3y agoThere is a sea of distance between the UI on a Tesla, and the UI on the Volkswagen. The lack of buttons in a Tesla is mildly annoying but everything is still pretty usable. On the VW the software is so bad it makes you want to scream in despair, and the buttons they do have are the worst of both worlds: unclear, unresponsive, no feedback, and invisible in the dark.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThere's a big difference between classic Tesla Model S, which had lots of physical buttons for the traditional things that cars used physical buttons for; but also had the big touchscreen... And the Model 3, etc... which, well... sorry, I won't drive one. Yes, I know you can program buttons on the stalks and crap, but I'm the kind of person who has used emacs for 30 years with the stock keybindings, so...
- agloe_dreams 3y agoHad a 20' Jetta and then a 22' Taos, a Volvo Xc40 and now a Tesla Model 3. Comparing VW MIB with Tesla's OS is like comparing a knockoff android TV streaming stick plugged into a 720p tv with an iPad Pro. Just miles of difference in UX, design, and performance. After having it for three months, so far my take is that the VW does exactly one thing better - Wiper controls. Notably, the Tesla Auto Wiper is pure trash and the VW one works well so you don't need to play with it. You are constantly in the Tesla menu because auto-wipers just don't work correctly.
- metabagel 3y ago> Just like everything else I remember at the time most of HN were singing songs and praise about the Tesla infotainment interface and everything touch screen. People who preferred buttons were the minorities. My recollection is different. I recall there was always a significant sentiment against eliminating buttons and knobs in favor of a centralized touch screen.
- ksec 3y agoThat happened much later. The sentiment of eliminating buttons and knobs came post 2016 / 2017. And it started to grow since.