3 ms·
If you only run the desalination plant when energy is cheap, plant cost per liter of water goes up. May or may not be a win. Probably a win for small, isolated
by Animats 3y ago
If you only run the desalination plant when energy is cheap, plant cost per liter of water goes up. May or may not be a win. Probably a win for small, isolated plants, say for powering and watering a small island. Large grid-connected plants, don't know.
- thelastgallon 3y agoWater probably isn't grid connected like electricity. Nor does the supply need to perfectly match the demand every second. There is quite a bit of water storage in the system. There might be pumps, in addition to just gravity assisted transportation of water. When energy is cheap, we can do both desalinate + transport.
- cperciva 3y agoYou're missing the point. If you need 24 m^3/day of fresh water, you can have a desalination plant producing 1 m^3/hour and a water tank to match supply to demand. But if you only want to run the plant for 3 hours/day when electricity is cheap, you now need a plant which can produce 8 m^3/hour. There's a tradeoff -- spending more building the desalination plant makes it possible to run at a lower duty cycle so you can spend less on the electricity.
- laurencerowe 3y agoBut mainland desalination plants are connected to the electricity grid. The problem with only running them part of the time is that the fixed capital and other operational costs of the plant are now split over a smaller amount of water produced so that water is more expensive than if you ran the plant all the time paying more for electricity at other times of the day.
- morepork 3y agoThere is certainly a trade off there, does the cheaper electricity compensate for the fact that you need to add say 20% extra capacity and the accompanying costs to your desalination plants as they will now be idle during low renewable production/times of high electricity costs.
- Animats 3y agoIf it's solar powered, more like 60% extra capacity to compensate for that annoying daily power down.
- dragontamer 3y agoAll water infrastructure in mainland America is stored in large reservoirs / lakes and/or water-towers for future use. If it takes 1GW-hr to make I dunno, a billion gallons of water or whatever, then it might be cheaper to store a billion-gallons of water + build a 2nd desal plant rather than trying to build a 1GW-hr Li-ion battery. That's the real question that's being discussed here. What's cheaper? Additional Desal plants + water storage? Or Giant-batteries? Presumably, pumped-hydro is off the table (which is true in some geographies). Pumped-hydro is an effective form of GW-hr sized energy storage but is somewhat frustrating at how limited the geography can be for it in practice.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI don't think the geography at the Ludington pumped hydro storage plant is particularly uncommon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludington_Pumped_Storage_Power...
- credit_guy 3y agoAt least in the US it is not a win. The Carlsbad desalination plant [1] cost $1 billion to build, and it produces 190000 tons of desalinated water per day, or 5.7 million tons per month. Assuming a 6% financing cost, and 30 years amortization, you pay $6 million per month, or about $1 per ton of fresh water. That's a cost you incur whether you desalinate the water or not. If you decide to run the plant at 50%, then that's $2 per ton. It takes 3.6 kWh to desalinate a ton of water. The cost of electricity in California is about $0.12/kWh for industrial users, so that's about $0.44 per ton of desalinated water. Let's say you switch from the current electricity providers to solar generation that is absolutely free. Then you save $0.44 for each ton, but incur an additional capital cost of $1. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claude_%22Bud%22_Lewis_Carlsbad_Desalination_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claude_%22Bud%22_Lewis_Carlsba...
- Animats 3y agoOK, that's useful. Not a win at current plant and power costs.