4 ms·
Alternatively, someone at Apple thought "we should add one of those pulse ox thingies like they've used in the doctor's office for the last 50 years into our ne
by kstrauser 3y ago
Alternatively, someone at Apple thought "we should add one of those pulse ox thingies like they've used in the doctor's office for the last 50 years into our next watch", saw that Masimo was a player in the space, met with them, and then decided they'd rather do it themselves.
This is not something Masimo invented themselves. The class of devices existed for decades before Masimo even existed. I'm not saying that Apple's in the right here -- I have no inside information giving me more perspective than anyone else reading this -- but it's far from clear that they did anything wrong.
- tadfisher 3y ago> met with them, and then decided they'd rather do it themselves ..., headhunted Masimo engineers, and hired them to reimplement a pulse-ox device. > Masimo and Apple began their relationship in 2013, when Apple discussed potentially integrating Masimo’s sensing technology into future Apple products. Internally, Apple executives debated the idea of buying Masimo and making its chief executive a vice president, according to documents made public at a later trial. But Apple ultimately decided against it because “acquisitions of this size aren’t our style,” an email reads. > Instead of buying Masimo, Apple ended up hiring Masimo engineers and began working on the technology itself, Masimo later said. https://www.wsj.com/tech/apple-to-halt-watch-sales-as-it-prepares-to-comply-with-u-s-import-ban-432a018c https://www.wsj.com/tech/apple-to-halt-watch-sales-as-it-pre...
- rvnx 3y agoBasically what 100% of the AI companies are doing right now.
- kstrauser 3y agoFrom an employee's point of view, I'm 100% OK with that. If Apple wants to throw money at an engineer to do the same thing they were already doing, but for Apple, then by all means do so. I don't think it's at all unethical to hire away employees. If it were, that'd lead to bad outcomes for those people (i.e. artificially suppressed wages).
- microtherion 3y ago… which is in fact something Apple was doing in the past. It's somewhat ironic when a company that gets in trouble for their anti-poaching shenanigans now gets accused of poaching. To me, it's clear that hiring competitors' employees is not morally wrong, and for the most part it's not legally wrong either, PROVIDED those employees do not take along their prior employers' confidential information.
- kstrauser 3y agoAgreed, and agreed, with the proviso that “confidential information” doesn’t cover the general knowledge of how something is done. For example, designing motors for Ford shouldn’t mean a lifetime ban on making motors for anyone else.
- mort96 3y agoPersonally, I'm against anti-poaching when Apple does it and I'm against anti-poaching when other people do it.
- skinkestek 3y agoI am not saying this is right. But I think it is something poetic about a company that sues and wins over Samsung for a "design patent" and uses the fact that Samsungs lawyers cannot see the difference as proof... when that company gets hit by a ridiculous "intellectual property" lawsuit. Said as an Apple user who has brought in a number of new Apple users, meaning I am not against Apple only against ridiculous "intellectual property" laws.
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt's hard to look at pre-iPhone and post-iPhone smartphones and not see a pretty clear dividing line with significant shift in looks and functionality. I'm leery of design patents, but it's hard to say there wasn't some invention going on there. We've had easy fingertip pulse oximetry since 1977, and Masimo was founded in 1989. It's unclear to me what in their patent is novel.
- skinkestek 3y agoThe big change with iPhone was the lack of physical keyboard, wasn't it? The form factor square with rounded edges in itself has been used for calculators and pocket PCs long long long before iPhone hasn't it?
- etchalon 3y agoThe big change with the iPhone was the entire concept of how a smart phone looked and worked.
- evilduck 3y agoNah, Windows Mobile, Palm devices and even the Newton had virtual keyboards long before the iPhone came around. They were resistive screens with shitty operating systems that required a stylus to do anything but the lack of a physical keyboard is not the difference. Smartphone design language changed dramatically after they all started copying the iPhone.