4 ms·
Is it just me or does this feel like another "we must stuff AI into everything, just because"? Inertial navigation has been around for most of a century, i.e. b
by userbinator 3y ago
Is it just me or does this feel like another "we must stuff AI into everything, just because"? Inertial navigation has been around for most of a century, i.e. before GPS even existed, and is basically self-contained.
- daniel-s 3y agoLearning that is difficult. It is a skill that needs to be worked on by learning maths, then control, dynamics. Instead, learn to use an AI framework and you can solve the problem with orders of magnitude more computing. Not advocating one way or another, just that that's probably the thinking. Also, it's in vogue.
- anonylizard 3y agoIts far easier to stuff 8 H100s in a submarine than to add another headcount. Every person in a submarine consumes valuable space/food/oxygen. Cooling and electricity on the other hand are easy to solve, when you have a nuclear reactor and a dead cold ocean right outside. So if possible, AI will be used to perform these duties.
- hef19898 3y agoAnd there will always be low tech, self contained back up systems in place. And I was not aware that current military subs had problems with navigation that require AI to solve, or issues with life support.
- jprete 3y agoInertial navigation is a sealed box and doesn't require more headcount than the H100s.
- nine_k 3y agoIn the outer space, yes; you can compute orbits for millennia to come. In the ocean, with its currents, it's way less easy.
- progbits 3y agoI don't think you understand, inertial navigation is not computing (as in predicting) anything. It is a bunch of sensors to measure where you are. Using AI to predict where you might be based on crappy cheap sensor data and ocean simulations is never going to be precise enough. AI can't pull signal out of noise and uncertainty.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Using AI to predict where you might be based on crappy cheap sensor data and ocean simulations is never going to be precise enough. AI can't pull signal out of noise and uncertainty. Yeah, but people with monies see this as "AI can help replace expensive milspec hardware with cheap COTS garbage plus some software magic pixie dust, for approximately the same effect [during peace time, in harbor]".
- hhh 3y agoGPU clusters already exist on them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pluto_modadic 3y agoit's interesting to study a balance neural network by evolving a few and going "so how would this AI withstand choppy seas" if it checks up with the map of how our brains learn to keep us upright, then we learn other side effects of how brains grow and learn if it doesn't... then it's even more interesting because there's another confounding variable.
- Maxion 3y agoAI is a contemporary marketing term. Statistical methods that go under that umbrella term has been used for a few hundred years. AI has now become hip, so anyone using any methods that could conceivably be put under that marketing term is now being done.
- niederman 3y agoAI is definitely a big buzzword right now, but in this particular case inertial navigation has a pretty big limitation: cost. Cheaper sensors with better software would be a legitimately compelling alternative to traditional solutions.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI reckon inertial navigation is dead.