Our ancestor commenter Qwertious wants a maximally immutable comment history and you advocate a maximally mutable comment history. Who's right? There's a wide

Our ancestor commenter Qwertious wants a maximally immutable comment history and you advocate a maximally mutable comment history. Who's right? There's a wide range of acceptable answers. Don't participate in a forum if you don't like their policy. Measured by overall forum quality HN has a decent enough approach.