4 ms·
I would think that in safety critical systems design (flight control systems for instance) there is a deep, well understood field of study over when, and why to
by ggm 3y ago
I would think that in safety critical systems design (flight control systems for instance) there is a deep, well understood field of study over when, and why to retain mechanical inputs over digital (soft) inputs.
Which makes me wonder how far VW and others went, justifying their decisions to walk away from them.
Maybe I misunderstand how strongly advice exists to retain them? I mean, they didn't go with side-stick steering, fly-by-wire, a number of things. It almost certainly is cost driven, but I would love to understand where their compliance and safety "epidemiologists" were in this.
- karmelapple 3y agoShort answer: there sure is a deep and well understood field of human factors that knows this in aviation. But there’s also a lot of customers who think it’s cooler/neater/better to have touchscreens.
- syndicatedjelly 3y agoBlaming that decision on customers is not fair. Car companies gave their marketing teams too much say in design. The current state of affairs with car UXs is the result of not listening to engineers.
- squigz 3y agoAnd it's been established for literally decades, which is why it's been so amusing to me to watch the rise and very quick fall of this type of input. If I recall correctly, there was some instance in the space industry of using some (Javascript-powered) touchscreens in the cockpit. Possibly from SpaceX? I'm sure that's a great idea too.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoOh please tell me how a climate knob is a safety-critical flight-control element.
- ggm 3y agoThe point is not that a climate knob is safety-critical: The point is that the UX in this space is well informed. Why digitise things, which only serve as a distraction from the core function? It's pointless innovation.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoAre you actually questioning why cheaper EVs are better? Besides - a350 and 777x started adding touchscreens AND they are designing FSD equivalent system too! Finally, if climate slider instead of knob distracts you, then perhaps you aren't fit to drive to begin with?