11 ms·
'Tranq tourism': TikTokers travel to film drug users
- artagnon 3y agoGod, this is so dehumanizing. When I think about the places such a thing can possibly happen, I think of North America and third world countries.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoI read the title as Philippines at first but Philadelphia makes sadly even more sense. I haven’t really seen a drug/homeless problem as bad as major North American cities anywhere else
- HKH2 3y agoIt's almost as if escapism can't be cured by condoning it.
- next_xibalba 3y agoIt is far more dehumanizing to be so hopelessly addicted to drugs that you’ve lost all ability to support yourself and are shooting up in public. The filming of it is a secondary and far more minor indignity.
- Xelynega 3y agoDo you think drug addiction is a choice rather than a situation? How do you feel about the same thing being done to homeless encampments where you don't have the easy excuse of "those people deserve it"?
- 4death4 3y agoWe (as a society) consider addicts personally responsible for their actions. For instance, if an alcoholic drives drunk and kills someone, we don't say "oh they're an alcoholic and therefore not responsible for what happened." Whether or not you want to call it a choice is up to you.
- anonzzzies 3y agoBut we, as a society, are hypocrites. There are people (anecdotally I think a lot or even a majority), who, when asked, would say that alcohol is not a drug. Simply using the law (alcohol is legal), they will say it cannot be a drug as drugs are illegal or subscribed. This is, of course, non sense. The other point is that many dui’s and accidents do not happen to alcoholics but rather casual users of alcohol, like students having a drink, no idea what their limits are and getting into a car. That’s different from actual alcoholics who down half a liter of vodka just to get out of bed. I believe they should be treated differently; the latter is ill, the former is a criminal. Addiction is a disease but society is not kind to the sufferers. It will change though; before the 90s, most mental illness was just ‘don’t whine, walk it off’. Doctors in 80s would send people with anxiety or depression home with a clean bill of health and just ‘work hard, it’ll pass’. If they were women and the doctors men, it would be considered as female hysterics. This all changed quite a bit over the past decades, at least in the west. Addiction will get there and in some countries that is going faster than others. Any actual Addicts (alcohol or crack or TikTok) operating heavy machinery is a bad idea; functional addicts are just not easy to recognise. An ex colleague of mine is a functional alcohol who drinks exactly 2.5 liters of vodka per day ; he doesn’t drive, he is smart, he functions fully. Not many people know he is an addict. I would say it’s easier to recognise addicts to social media far faster than him because you can see their phone, and when I see them driving while scrolling on their phone, I hope they get a dui and their license taken and then therapy; I am not sure how it’s not as dangerous as driving drunk and yet I see people swerving sitting on their phone daily while swerving without phone is very rare (at least here).
- 4death4 3y agoI don’t think you can automatically classify addiction as disease. It can be a disease, but it can also be a compulsion that a “sufferer” chooses to partake in. There is an implicit assumption in your argument that all drug addicts would choose to stop if they weren’t addicted. In my experience, that isn’t true. Many drug users like to use drugs and would not stop using given the choice. For a more benign example: I “suffer” from dermatophagia. It’s a compulsion that would be very hard for me to stop. But I like doing it. I wouldn’t stop even if I could. This is similar to how addiction is a compulsion, but that doesn’t make the behavior something done unwillingly.
- huytersd 3y agoThis is what happens when you don’t institutionalize these people in psychiatric hospitals. They need to come back, just with more process and transparency this time.
- janalsncm 3y agoAgreed. For people who need serious help and don’t have resources, there’s nowhere for them to go. Dumping them on the street is an abject moral failure in this country.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoThis is entirely correct for some subset of the homeless population. Some people are far gone enough through untreated mental illness or drug addiction to where they can no longer be reasonably classified as being sound of mind, they're no longer able to take care of themselves even at a basic level. These people need professional help even if they don't nominally consent. To let them slowly languish and degrade further mentally and physically on the street is not compassionate, it is grotesque. Obviously, that's not all homeless people, but it's maybe the most visible segment of the population.
- Xelynega 3y agoAgreed, anybody flying across the country to try and film societal issues for 'clout' needs some readjustment.
- huytersd 3y agoAh the ol’ switcheroo. Yay.
- haswell 3y agoIn the photography community, taking street photos of people without their permission is a source of controversy. Some people on the extremes feel it’s never acceptable, but most photographers agree that being respectful is the key, as well as always deleting photos if someone asks. One of my personal stances is that I’ll never photograph someone who is in a compromised position, e.g. a drunk person stumbling out of a bar, or a homeless person sleeping on the street. This seems like the bare minimum in terms of respect and human decency. It’s pretty disheartening to see these kinds of TikTok trends just blow through these kinds of ethical concerns and norms. I’ve already worried at times that poorly behaving street photographers are going to make it harder for most photographers to continue their work. I don’t even know what to say about trends like this one. It’s one of the many reasons that I’m convinced humans are not capable of using certain forms of social media in a healthy way. Our brains are not equipped for it.
- robotnikman 3y agopeople will keep stooping to lower and lower levels for views, likes, etc. If it gets them money in the end there will be people who will try to grab it.
- hotstickyballs 3y agoWhat’s wrong about that if it brings more visibility to a social problem?
- tenebrisalietum 3y agoVisibility can help solve a problem, but once you are at a certain level of visibility and your problem is not solved, more visibility isn't going to solve it.
- HKH2 3y agoMaybe you need a higher level of visibility? Put it where the privileged have to see it?
- mschuster91 3y agoIt's high time for government to act and regulate social media platforms more - and not just TikTok, but also YouTube and Instagram, where similar content isn't moderated either unless it generates public outrage. The list of "internet challenges" [1] alone should be enough to warrant serious crackdowns across the board, and that's just dangerous challenges and doesn't include other noxious effects of social media like hordes of Instagram followers ruining flower fields [2][3] and tourist destinations [4]. And hell, not just the platforms should be held accountable. Track down and arrest every single one of those utterly vile people exploiting the suffering of fellow human beings. Just because they're doing it "on the internet" shouldn't mean immunity from the law. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_challenges https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_challenges [2] https://mashable.com/article/instagram-ruining-california-super-bloom https://mashable.com/article/instagram-ruining-california-su... [3] https://matadornetwork.com/read/instagrammers-destroying-siberian-flower-field/ https://matadornetwork.com/read/instagrammers-destroying-sib... [4] https://qz.com/quartzy/1580867/all-the-tourist-destinations-ruined-by-instagram-this-year https://qz.com/quartzy/1580867/all-the-tourist-destinations-...
- mgraczyk 3y agoWhich law does this violate?
- mschuster91 3y agoI know it's not the US, but here in Europe you'd run afoul of GDPR - filming or photographing people is an activity regulated by it. In Germany, there's an explicit criminal code protecting "helpless" persons from filming (§201a Abs. 1 Nr. 2 StGB [1]). In the US, there are numerous states who require consent for recordings, so that may be another avenue. [1] https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__201a.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/stgb/__201a.html
- dfgfek 3y agoNot obvious to me, since the person in the article took money for it. There clearly is an economic transaction thus consent is implied.
- singularity2001 3y agoThe optimistic side of me wants to think that exposure will ultimately lead to improvement
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- silenced_trope 3y agoSame. I'm surprised that the "alarm" is over the tourism and filming of it. Not over us allowing people to self-destruct, which is what we do when we enable this behavior, which IS what we're doing right now. In San Francisco where I live we do this too. Plenty of "connected" charities making money and growing by serving the needs (addictions) of the drugged street population. We need to be more alarmed at that, not at the exposing of it.
- janalsncm 3y ago> I'm surprised that the "alarm" is over the tourism and filming of it. I’m not that surprised. It’s a stance which doesn’t require doing anything to solve the underlying issue, but lets people take a moral stance which feels somewhat humanitarian.
- pseudalopex 3y ago> I'm surprised that the "alarm" is over the tourism and filming of it. I'm surprised you assumed a headline captured a situation fully.
- kelnos 3y ago> I'm surprised that the "alarm" is over the tourism and filming of it. It is possible to be alarmed about more than one aspect of a situation, but decide to only focus on one part of it when telling a story. People being homeless and doing drugs isn't news to me (sadly), so focusing on that in this piece would not have given me any new information. However, I had no idea that people were exploiting drugged-out homeless people for TikTok views; that was new information to me.
- 3y ago
- xrd 3y agoIt seems common to tiktok, Instagram, and any other platform where the majority of the people are craving followers that this kind of behavior will be rampant. Once you commit to these platforms there will always be someone pushing the boundaries of decency and those will be elevated by the platform itself. The only game is not to play. There is also some irony in the fact that a Chinese company is profiting from the drug trade and social problems caused in part by that same country. The drug trade by now is a decentralized and multi-hop production process of course and the USA certainly can't claim innocence either. But, it is fascinating.
- mgraczyk 3y agoIt's interesting to me that the line between "this is important journalism" and "this is bad and we should stop it" seems to be arbitrary aesthetics around distribution medium and production style. If this is bad, would it also be bad for NYT to film the same things and publish a piece about how bad the situation is, with ads?
- mpalmer 3y agoIf the only distinction you see between this and NYT content is medium and production style, I'm more curious to know how you personally define important journalism.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mgraczyk 3y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/07/health/fentanyl-xylazine-drug.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/07/health/fentanyl-xylazine-... There are some important differences related to consent and background info, but the high level criticism in TFA that "people are profiting by sharing imagery of fucked up drug users" is equally true of mainstream publications It's important journalism to the extent that it disseminates information or raises awareness of important conditions or facts
- mpalmer 3y agoIt's a messy gray area to be sure. Both parties want more reach and more revenue, so let's set those incentives aside. To me it seems that the worst accusation you can level at a news org like NYT is reaching for sensationalism and lurid "entertainment" to get clicks. But they are a (subjectively) trusted/credible news institution. There is an underlying mission and set of shared journalistic values behind what they do, not to mention an editorial process. Through these things there is at least a nod towards accountability. TikTok creators are not credible or trusted in the same sense, and they are under no obligation to a larger mission or set of norms, self-imposed or otherwise. They just want followers. With content like this, it seems they're doing the inverse of the NYT - they're reaching for credibility by creating content with the appearance of journalism. --- And to your point about consent, I'm sure there are people who did not or could not consent to their image being published. AFAIK there are no structures governing TikTok "journalism" that would prevent this sort of harm. For me, this is enough to totally disqualify this sort of thing as journalism.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- mpalmer 3y agoIt's disturbing to think of Tony Gilroy's film Nightcrawler as prophetic, but as I read this article, it was the first thing that came to mind.
- BaculumMeumEst 3y agoMaybe the TikTokers filming public spaces aren’t the problem in this picture.
- fngjdflmdflg 3y agoExactly. If these tick-tockers became drug addicts instead they would be celebrated by the people who raise "alarm" filming American cities.
- Loocid 3y agoNo one is celebrating drug addicts.
- AlexandrB 3y agoA lot of people celebrate Elon Musk.
- iAMkenough 3y agoSnoop Dogg is celebrated for his heavy marijuana use.
- Xelynega 3y agoThese tiktokers are drug addicts. It just so happens that drug is dopamine they produce by exploiting people on social media instead of injecting chemicals.
- kelnos 3y agoOr maybe there's more than one problem, and TikTokers exploiting homeless drug addicts is still one of them.
- Erratic6576 3y agoThe problem is not the problem. The problem is their filming the problem
- pengaru 3y agoGood. The more visibility the US's failure to house and assist those in need the better. Shame this nation into oblivion until it changes its ways. People use drugs across all social classes. Those living on the streets just use them where it's visible for lack of alternatives. At least we have strong laws protecting filming/photographing any public activity where there's no reasonable expectation of privacy, so we can shine light on these societal failures until resources are allocated appropriately. What's happening in this country's city streets should be embarrassing to all citizens. Through this particular lens the US looks like a failed state, such a dereliction of duties for a first-world nation.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoThis is basically my position. Yeah it feels kinda gross that people are blatantly doing this kind of recording for views, but the far larger crime is that the situation exists in the first place. The US is a monumentally rich country where people are left to basically rot on the streets if they're currently unable to care for themselves. There's some support institutions of course, and I applaud those that work there, but so much more needs to be done.
- HKH2 3y agoHow do you dig yourself out of being a low-trust society?
- Der_Einzige 3y agoUnfortunately the answer is (limited) authoritarianism. See Singapore as the quintessential example of this. I think they may in fact be the highest trust society on earth as a result of it. Folks would take seats at hawker stands by leaving their 4000 USD macbooks and keys/wallet as markers. No one even bats an eye.
- HKH2 3y agoWhy can't America strictly enforce laws like in Singapore?
- JCharante 3y ago> to Influencer Market Hub research. Profit depends on the reach of a video, so in some cases, it can be far higher, but the platform pays approximately $20 for every 1,000 views. There's no way videos on YT featuring drugs are getting $20 CPM so it makes no sense to include that, and in no way $20 CPM the norm. The sensibilities of the journalist is undermined by such malicious carelessness.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- carlosjobim 3y agoThis issue has already been settled in the Bible, thousands of years ago, in the story about Noah.
- brutusborn 3y agoCan you please explain? I can’t see the connection.
- carlosjobim 3y agoNoah was humiliated or even abused by his sons when he was blacked out drunk in his tent, and subsequently cursed the family line of the guilty part. The story is a clear warning against abusing people who are incapacitated. How many people haven't been humiliated by "friends" when blacked out drunk, or when unconscious from other drugs? Or even worse, the countless of people who have been abused when in such condition. Would it be fun to do the same thing to somebody being incapacitated due to a medical condition?
- djohnston 3y ago> In 2022, the typical compensation for YouTube content creators in the United States was roughly $4,600 monthly, according to Influencer Market Hub research. Profit depends on the reach of a video, so in some cases, it can be far higher, but the platform pays approximately $20 for every 1,000 views. Seems implausible. Is it true?
- LordShredda 3y agoA lot of twitch streamers have a VOD channel (video on demand, or just stream archives) on youtube to tap their lucrative payouts. It's relatively easy to do, just after a stream ends edit out the quiet bits and add some background music, easy 20 min video.
- nsvd 3y agoI'm sure the median income across all YouTube channels is not $4,600, so I guess this comes down to how they define "typical".
- nullc 3y agoThis article is worthless without links-- you're supposed to take the authors word for it that what they're writing about is reprehensible but you're carefully sheltered from seeing it yourself. It's reasonable to wonder if this is because the author is overplaying their hand. I attempted to google and immediately found a footage matching their description, but not from tiktokers but from television news.
- FireBeyond 3y agoI'm somewhat okay with this - it doesn't mean the barrier of proof should be zero, but in that many of these "influencers" are openly chasing follower and view counts (dare I say some are addicted to it?) then I'm okay with not enabling that. You don't need to link to CSAM sites to talk about issues like that. Similar to not needing to link to the worst of rotten.com or whatever just to make observations on it. > I attempted to google and immediately found a footage matching their description, but not from tiktokers but from television news. My perception has been that tiktok isn't particularly well indexed by Google.
- nullc 3y agoYuck example, but it's a point. We aren't talking about something as extreme here, however. Given that hyperbole in journalism is common, I think we ought to hope for enough information to validate where it wouldn't be reprehensible or unlawful to provide it. I was guilty of hyperbole myself with the worthless comment, thanks for the reality check. :) (and fortunately you could see the article and judge that I'd overstated it!)
- Racing0461 3y agoOnly the homeless industrial complex is allowed to exploit homeless/drug users.
- mckn1ght 3y agoThe last two paragraphs: > Jeff, a content creator in Kensington who runs a channel called Jeff’s High on Life, believes there is an ethical way to do this sort of filming if you pour the resources back into the community. This is what I wanted to day after reading some comments talking about “raising awareness”. Put your money where your mouth is and show us the receipts of all the money made off the videos being donated. > He makes about $1,000 a month, which he spends on wound care and supplies like clothes, but says he’s heard of cases in which content creators set up GoFundMe pages for the addicts who never see that money. Disgusting, and sadly not surprising.
- keithalewis 3y agoAdvertising is the root of many evil things.
- Zambyte 3y agoAdvertising is a direct consequence of premature optimization and shared mutable state
- keithalewis 3y agoNo. It is how companies with money increase the gap in wealth distribution. They pay pennies to encourage "influencers" to behave poorly in order to maximize their revenue
- Zambyte 3y ago... I was making a "root of all evil" joke
- keithalewis 3y agoI wasn't making a joke.
- pvaldes 3y agoAddicts using other addicts to keep their lifestyle, with a third part benefiting economically of it. Another day at the magical realm of Drugsterworld. People descending to such hell rings, and paying for misery so they have something new to feed to their insatiable "fans", should seek help. Your fans on tiktok aren't really your friends, people. The only legit reason to do this is to help, not to entertain or to brag. And the government should take this people from the streets and provide real help to their citizens. Having one missile more or less will not make a difference.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Exendroinient23 3y agoAny attention to this phenomenon is a good thing.Exposure always helps.