6 ms·
Can we please stop using the silly Apple marketing gimmick "retina display" yet? It's a high-DPI display. Lots of devices have it. Lets not attempt to pretend
by josteink 15y ago
Can we please stop using the silly Apple marketing gimmick "retina display" yet?
It's a high-DPI display. Lots of devices have it. Lets not attempt to pretend there's anything Apple-specific about that.
- alinajaf 15y agoDon't get me started. Anytime anyone asks me if I'm a Mac or a PC, my response is "Mac's aren't PC's? What have they started making mainframes now?"
- rb2k_ 15y agoAs soon as we stop saying Jeep, Walkman, Zipper, Kleenex, Laundromat, Xerox and all the other proprietary eponyms
- huxley 15y ago... and Google. If people really hated Apple marketing, they probably should be ecstatic at the idea of one of their trademarks becoming genericized.
- jwoah12 15y agoWell to be fair, it's been several years since I've heard anyone call an SUV a Jeep (other than a Jeep), a tissue a Kleenex, or a copy machine a Xerox. But Zipper was a brand name?? What the hell is the generic product name for a zipper?
- skrebbel 15y agoIn fact, they should sue all programmers who ever made a zip() function for trademark violations! (in fact, even more confusingly, most zip() functions don't interleave elements, like zippers do, but return a sequence of paired tuples - this, naturally, gives Zippers a bad name who wants their pants to pairwise join)
- huxley 15y agoDoesn't seem to have a consistent one, clasp fastener or separable fastener are earlier generic terms. BTW Zipper wasn't trademarked by the creator or manufacturer but by BF Goodrich when used on their zipped-up boots. Two which surprised me were Ping Pong and Adrenaline.
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoUm, in Britain, we call them "zips". It's generic and not trademarked.
- rb2k_ 15y agoIt might just be my German origin, but I wouldn't call an SUV a Jeep either. We do however call all of the off road-capable bulky cars with the roll-over protection thingy ("Überrollbügel" in German, can't think of the English equivalent) Jeep.
- melling 15y agoWho's else is making high-DPI displays? I have really seen companies running with this. It would be nice to see Samsung, for example, start promoting 300 dpi screens so they go mass market.
- maggit 15y agoSamsung builds the Galaxy Nexus, which has a 316 ppi display. Now, we still have a way to go before high ppi displays are ubiquitous, but there you have one example at least :)
- altrego99 15y agoThe Galaxy Nexus uses pentile subpixel rendering, which is a system with slightly controversial ways of determining the PPI.
- romland 15y agoHTC One X comes to mind (first and only one I looked up), 310-320 DPI (depending on the source; first few hits on Google)
- empoman 15y agoSony's Xperia S have 338 PPI which is even more dense than Apples "retina display". So there are other companies using high dpi displays. Galaxy Nexus is at 316 PPI if I remember it correctly. HTC has a phone, Vigor, that has 342 PPI. So apple is certainly not the only company out there who likes pixels :)
- kennu 15y agoI've understood that technically the main idea of "retina" is that the physical display pixels no longer map one-to-one with the logical user interface (CSS) pixels. Instead, the retina display appears as a virtual low-resolution screen that is able to utilize higher-resolution images (which would otherwise be scaled down). So in this sense, I would claim there is a clear technical difference between just higher-resolution screens (more pixels) and retina displays (same pixels but "better looking"). To me this virtualization of pixels seems like a good idea, since the majority of web pages assume pixels have certain DPI range. Operating systems like OSX treat pixels as floats anyway, so if you need subpixel accuracy, it's still possible.
- ned 15y agoNo, the distinction of device pixels vs. CSS pixels predates the first "Retina" iPhone. The distinction existed in all browsers supporting full page zoom, including the Safari on the first iPhone, and in Opera for years before that. "Retina" is just a marketing term for "pixels so small your eye can't distinguish them at a normal distance anymore".
- goblin89 15y agoThe distinction is also in CSS specs[0] since version 2.1: “The reference pixel is the visual angle of one pixel on a device with a pixel density of 96dpi and a distance from the reader of an arm's length. <…> 1px thus corresponds to about 0.26 mm (1/96 inch).” [0] http://www.w3.org/TR/CSS21/syndata.html#length-units http://www.w3.org/TR/CSS21/syndata.html#length-units See also http://inamidst.com/stuff/notes/csspx http://inamidst.com/stuff/notes/csspx (been featured on HN some time ago)
- drcube 15y agoWhy are their visual angles measured in millimeters?
- mgunes 15y agoIt's called resolution independence, and has been built into various toolkits and operating systems well before the first "Retina" device. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resolution_independence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resolution_independence
- rimantas 15y agoThere is nothing silly no gimmicky about it. It is just a catchy name for some technology. There are a lot of similar marketing terms in tech. Lots more people will understand what you are talking about when you say "retina display" instead of "high-DPI display". What's high-DPI? What's high-DPI when talking about pentile displays? Not to mention that "retina" is easier to pronounce. Apple loves simpler names for a reason.
- ajross 15y agoNo, it's a gimmick designed expressly to confuse the consumer. Other manufacturers of comparable products, for trademark reasons, can't use the term "retina". So only Apple has "retina". Intel played a similar trick about 8 years ago with "Centrino". The advertising (for what was essentially just a 802.11b chipset with some added processor/chipset requirements) was so successful that many novice users got fooled into thnking that "Centrino" was wifi, and that all those other manufacturers were just cheap knockoffs of an Intel technology. It did great harm to the market.
- twoodfin 15y ago> many novice users got fooled into thinking that "Centrino" was wifi, and that all those other manufacturers were just cheap knockoffs of an Intel technology. It did great harm to the market. Really? Both the claim that many users were "fooled" by the Centrino branding and that this hurt the market for Wi-Fi devices seem highly implausible to me. I don't think I heard anyone use the term "Centrino" outside of Intel PR and reporting thereupon, whereas Wi-Fi had made it into the vernacular at least a decade ago. The only other trademark for the 802.11 series of standards that got any traction at all was Apple's AirPort, and even their OS calls it Wi-Fi now.
- ajross 15y agoYes, really. I had to explain to numerous relatives the distinction between "Centrino" and "Wifi". How old are you? Were you engaged with people who were actively buying laptops at the time? Were you engaged on the subject outside the tech community? The Centrino television ads were pervasive, everyone knew what they were about, and no one at the time had ever heard of a laptop that could get on the internet without a wire. (edit: your remark about AirPort makes this clearer on reflection: you were a mac user at the time, and familiar with Apple products much more than PCs. Outside the mac world, as you might expect, literally no one had heard of an "AirPort". So you were insulated from Intel's nonsense, essentially.) It's the same thing here. We have "retina.js" being pushed around as a solution for what is clearly a manufacturer-independent problem. Yet on it's face it appears to be Apple-only software. You don't think that constitutes harm to the market?
- hej 15y agoDPI i just incorrect. Use PPI if you really insist on that name. That said, there is nothing gimmicky about the retina name. It's a device where distance to the display, resolution and screen size are such that someone with normal vision cannot distinguish between pixels. High-PPI does not in any way pack the same information. It’s ambiguous and unclear. The only thing that’s bad about retina is that Apple uses it like a trademark. I would love it if any company could call their HD TVs retina displays (because they are), but that’s not possible. Luckily everyone else is busy taking away that name from Apple (for example by naming their software like that).
- huggyface 15y agoIt's a device where distance to the display, resolution and screen size are such that someone with normal vision cannot distinguish between pixels. It is a post-development sales pitch used to pitch as a differentiation the fact that Apple's naive scaling required them to grossly overshoot the mark. Competitive products already had excellent displays before Apple decided that they had no choice but catch up. I would love it if any company could call their HD TVs retina displays Why would you love it? "Retina" display is a misnomer -- unless the device is a fixed distance from my eyes, and it is specifically geared for my eyes specifically, it is horse shit to call it a retina display. It is ignorant marketbabble that lowers us all.
- hej 15y agoOh come on. Apple’s iPhone and iPad barely hits the mark there. They are overshooting nothing. It’s a petty good approximate term that to my mind works perfectly well. Sure, things change depending on view distance but I guess nerds have to survive a term that’s not always exact. The horror! That was an uninformed rant on your part. What are you suggesting as an alternative? High-PPI certainly does not work.
- huggyface 15y agoApple’s iPhone and iPad barely hits the mark there. Do you actually believe that the magical "retina" mark just coincidentally happened to be 2x Apple's original resolutions? How convenient! It’s a petty good approximate term It's a marketing term that the stupid embrace. Is a 64Kbps mp3 "eardrum audio" in a standard room with a fan? Is 128Kbps eardrum audio on a crummy mp3 player? That was an uninformed rant on your part What was uninformed about it? Desperately curious to hear what.
- zootsuiter 15y agoEven though the term "retina display" may be a gimmick, I think the creator of retina.js specifically designed it with Apple devices, and Apple's developer documentation, in mind (case in point: usage of the @2x modifier).
- Hervetar 15y agoPlease cut the drama and the whining and get over it.