2 ms·
Grammarians have been puzzling over this text for many years. It would help if someone could find another phrase in the Bill of Rights that refers to, or even
by CamperBob2 3y ago
Grammarians have been puzzling over this text for many years.
It would help if someone could find another phrase in the Bill of Rights that refers to, or even alludes to, the primacy of the rights of the state (whether "Congress" or a collective state-sanctioned "militia") over those of the citizenry.
There don't seem to be any such phrases, which lends a lot of credence to those who argue that the preface to the Second Amendment is just that -- prefatory, with no functional or prescriptive aspect whatsoever. The Bill of Rights is simply the wrong place to look for rules that grant, rather than restrict, governmental authority.