3 ms·
> Hamas’ leadership wants its villa bills paid. Which will continue. > Those payments come in exchange for influence over Gaza. Those payments come in exchan
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> Hamas’ leadership wants its villa bills paid.
Which will continue.
> Those payments come in exchange for influence over Gaza.
Those payments come in exchange for remaining a thorn in Israel's side. They don't need to be managing Gaza's water authority to remain one. They're much more effective as an insurgency than a government.
> The Republicans were messaging to a primary base who reward loyalty over productivity.
The same is true for Hamas, quite clearly.
> Hamas wasn’t messaging to anyone with this attack. They lost control of their proxies.
This is a weird assertion; all signs point to extensive planning by Hamas of this attack.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Which will continue If they lose control over Gaza? No. > payments come in exchange for remaining a thorn in Israel's side…they're much more effective as an insurgency The guys in Doha aren’t insurgents. They’re bureaucrats. The insurgent leadership is being killed. > same is true for Hamas, quite clearly How? There is no loyalty test. Again, Hamas lost control of its proxies. You’re conflating separate situations that are fundamentally different because on the surface you like the opportunity to call the GOP terrorists. Which, ironically, undermines your broader argument. > all signs point to extensive planning by Hamas Extensive planning. Not necessarily by Hamas. Again, this was a tremendously stupid move. There were smarter plays, and hints Hamas was trying for them, but they screwed the pooch and are seeing heavy destruction and the likely loss of their fighters, local infrastructure and operational control in Gaza.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> If they lose control over Gaza? No. Hamas has been out of control in Gaza before, it's hardly the first time. Insurgents don't need control over the area to be a serious pain for the occupying force. > The guys in Doha aren’t insurgents. They’re bureaucrats. The insurgent leadership is being killed. Their bureaucracy is largely focused on recruiting and funding the insurgent wing. Taking out insurgent leadership is like offing Bin Laden; someone else always volunteers. > Again, Hamas lost control of its proxies. You keep asserting this without any evidence. What proxies? What's the evidence Hamas doesn't want them doing what they're currently doing? Hamas is the proxy, for Iran, as are Hezbollah. Iran is likely quite happy with their performance, given the brewing international condemnation of Israel's response. > they screwed the pooch and are seeing heavy destruction and the likely loss of their fighters They don't care. There's always more cannon fodder, especially after a war generates a new generation of refugees, orphans, and grieving relatives. We saw the same in Afghanistan; every civilian you kill means a family swearing vengeance.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Insurgents don't need control over the area to be a serious pain for the occupying force Fair enough, I should have said influence versus control. It looks like Hamas won't have influence in Gaza after this war. That doesn't mean there won't be insurgents. As you point out, there absolutely will be. In part because of this war. But I doubt they'll show loyalty to Hamas--their surviving leadership will be too far away. > Taking out insurgent leadership is like offing Bin Laden; someone else always volunteers Al Qaeda's income fell off a cliff following the American response to 9/11. (Not after 9/11 per se.) > What proxies? What's the evidence Hamas doesn't want them doing what they're currently doing? Islamic Jihad, for one. Proxies can have proxies. Look, if Hamas intended what happened they are incompetent and evil. That strengthens the argument for their liquidation; it says they cannot be reasoned with. I don't think the last decade of Hamas' rule shows them incapable at achieving their ends. (Islamic Jihad, on the other hand, seem like nutters.) Add to that the operational incoherence of the October 7 attack, and that Hamas lost its hostages, its sole source of leverage, and it's not difficult to conclude things went off piste. > Iran is likely quite happy with their performance, given the brewing international condemnation of Israel's response Yes and no. They're happy because it shows their strength, brings them to the negotiating table and makes their oil more valuable. (It also curtails Arab-Israeli normalisation.) The international response has shown that Israel can do what it wants. The Arab states softly condemned. Hezbollah and the Palestinian Authority chose self preservation. America sent through arms. The one PR battle the Palestinians need to win, sympathy in America, has gone backwards. > We saw the same in Afghanistan The Taliban took back ground control. Their fighting forces were preserved. That does not look like it will be the case in Gaza; Jerusalem is being far more brutal than we were in Afghanistan. It might be that's the only way to win. (If you're correct, that Hamas intended to kill thousands of Israelis and tens of thousands of its own, then this is a good thing.)
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Al Qaeda's income fell off a cliff following the American response to 9/11. (Not after 9/11 per se.) Hoist the "Mission Accomplished" banner! What happened next? (Hint: It rhymes with "schistlamic plate".) > Look, if Hamas intended what happened they are incompetent and evil. That strengthens the argument for their liquidation; it says they cannot be reasoned with. I agree! I just don't think the Israeli approach is going to do the trick, and is likely actively harmful to that goal. > Islamic Jihad, for one. Proxies can have proxies. PIJ is a rival to Hamas. They've fought from time to time, and coordinate attacks at other times. US intelligence describes it as a "tense relationship": https://www.dni.gov/nctc/ftos/pij_fto.html https://www.dni.gov/nctc/ftos/pij_fto.html > The Taliban took back ground control. As will Hamas or their successors as soon as Israel withdraws from Gaza. Barring a Holocaust-scale elimination campaign against the population, there'll be a powerful set of insurgent groups in Gaza for the forseeable future.