3 ms·
Yeah pretty interesting. Personally I never liked systemd because I just didn't see the need for it and I don't like changes forced on me. I'm not a team playe
by wkat4242 3y ago
Yeah pretty interesting.
Personally I never liked systemd because I just didn't see the need for it and I don't like changes forced on me. I'm not a team player and I hate being told to 'just go with the flow'. The whole idea of FOSS for me is to be in control of my computer. Alnd I just don't like the character of Poettering and yes that matters. For a much more extreme example look at ReiserFS. It was totally shitcanned after it turned out its creator was an actual murderer.
Of course Poettering is nothing close to that and his biggest fault is being a little socially abrasive and opinionated. I'm just more sensitive to this than others. But I just really hate optionated software.
This probably makes me a "systemd hater" that the article speaks off. I understand as my concerns are indeed a bit petty. But they're mine anyhow.
In the end I moved to BSD. I'm very happy with it now. They don't have the push to constantly changing stuff around for the sake of things like systemd and net-tools.
- gosub100 3y ago> They don't have the push to constantly changing stuff around for the sake of things like systemd and net-tools. I assume you forgot a word here and intended to write "changing stuff around for the sake of changing things"? I just want to set the record straight: systemd solves the startup-dependency problem. Yes the old default init scripts worked fine for your system (that probably had very few services installed other than vanilla defaults), but it was insufficient for handling the exploding cascade of dependencies when service1 depends on the network, service2 depends on the graphical subsystem, service3 (the wifi daemon) can restart the network, etc. People tried in vain, hacked nasty rc.init scripts for years, until Poettering took matters into his own hands. I will stop there because I dont know the whole history behind it, but I just take issue with the attitude that systemd in particular is just kids messing around with the latest-new-thing. Some of that does exist in the Linux sphere, even worse, with some maintainers putting inappropriate images and political messages in their apps[1]. But systemd - as with wayland - solves a problem that had been brewing a long time.I suppose you could almost think of it as a fix for developers instead of end users? I'm not compelling you to use it, just disputing your final point. [1]. https://www.reddit.com/r/browsers/comments/18izmt4/clarifying_thorium_browser_controversy/ https://www.reddit.com/r/browsers/comments/18izmt4/clarifyin...
- wkat4242 3y agoI don't really agree, because it works totally fine on BSD. I do think the Linux init system was a bit less advanced than BSD's though. PS: I don't like Wayland either for that matter :) At all. My ideal would be an X12 with the X-Windows foundations but modified for modern realities.
- dreamcompiler 3y ago> systemd solves the startup-dependency problem And that's perfectly fine. My problem with systemd is that it didn't stop there; it became this giant monolithic thing that Linux hangs off the edge of. That's Poettering's sin.
- 9dev 3y agoI’ll never understand what that guy did that got all of you in such a frenzy. Because Stallman or Torvalds are such socially apt and charismatic people, or what? Yet all those systemd opponents out there don’t seem to have a particular problem with them. Poettering might have opinions on what Linux should be that don’t overlap with yours, but systemd solves actual problems and works better than any init script shenanigans that came before. If you don’t agree with this premise, I call your proficiency with Linux into question (don’t take this in spite, please, it’s in no way meant personally).
- LeFantome 3y agoWell, both Linus and RMS have attracted their share of controversy. In the case of Linus, while you may not always agree with him, there seems to be broader support for his engineering choices. He has multiple projects that have dominated their spaces on their own merits. Whatever you think of Stallman, there is no denying his historical contribution. For myself, I am more bothered by RMS. Although I know Chimera has shunned GNU for technical reasons, I would personally prefer a world where all GNU software has been replaced by alternatives. In my view, we would be better off to be free of RMS and the politics he has created around around “GNU / Linux”. The GPL itself is an important option in Open Source and, while it is not my favourite, I wish it and the projects that adopt it much success. However, the GNU Project itself is becoming an impediment ( my views only of course ). Luckily, the GNU project represents quite a small list of software projects despite the way people talk about it. Replacing GCC, Glibc, and Coreutils would be enough. Of these, the most damaging and the hardest to replace is probably Glibc. Anyway, my intent is not to trigger people with such opinions in this thread. I do not want them to reflect badly on Chimera. My only reason for chiming in is to illustrate that Poettering is not unique in collecting detractors. Finally, systemd did solve real problems at the time. There are other solutions now though so let’s not render them inoperable. Also, not everything systemd wants to be now is better than the alternatives or even what came before. Not liking systemd does not mean wanting to go back to init scripts. Btw, the system I use most daily uses systemd. I also use it in a project at work although, there, we have a strange bug “rarely” at shutdown that systemd is implicated in and I wish it ( and is ecosystem ) were easier to understand. So again, I find the Chimera approach attractive.