3 ms·
Hissp
- loganrios 3y agoI’ve been keeping loose tabs on this and Hy[1] for a while, but I’ve had some trouble figuring out the major differences between them and the use-cases for either. Would love to see an in-depth comparison in the form of a blog post sometime (though maybe the answer here is to do the research and write one up myself). 1: https://hylang.org https://hylang.org
- epgui 3y agoCame here with the same question!
- nerdponx 3y agoFrom the perspective of language design, Hissp strives to be more directly homoiconic, representing s-expressions as Python tuples. Hy is more of an abstract sexpr-to-Python compiler, with s-expressions represented as custom data types, rather than Python primitives. From the perspective of usability, Hissp is very minimalistic overall. Whereas Hy is both much more Python-like in its user experience and provides much more of a batteries-included experience like you'd find in Common Lisp or Clojure (and in fact its standard library takes a lot of inspiration from both). I consider Hissp as more of an interesting experiment in language design than a practical programming language. Whereas I think Hy is very practical and I've been very happy to use it for various scripts over the years. That's not to say Hissp is a bad project by any means. It's impressive, and I admire its dedication to its own principled consistency. I just don't find it very practical. The downside of Hy is that they've gone through several radical design changes over the years, but that finally seems to be stabilizing.
- Kodiologist 3y agoAs the Hy maintainer, I'd say that assessment is pretty accurate, at least on the Hy side.
- gilch 3y agoAs the Hissp author/maintainer, I'd be interested in hearing about your take on Hissp's practicality (or lack thereof) in more detail.
- gilch 3y agoThat is the right answer. While some comparisons have been written already, they're somewhat out of date. Hissp could use a new writeup. Let me know if I can answer any questions about Hissp, and when your blog post is ready :) You can reach me at the Hissp community chat channel on Gitter's Matrix: https://gitter.im/hissp-lang/community https://gitter.im/hissp-lang/community -- share your Hissp experience or get support.