3 ms·
> Basically way more than half of the people are democrats and they are denied proportional representation because if they had it either USA would become one pa
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Basically way more than half of the people are democrats and they are denied proportional representation because if they had it either USA would become one party system with a perpetually disgruntled minority opposition that would need to be controlled or it would have to have an actual multipolar democracy but that would interfere with making money the usual way too much.
If you had e.g. approval voting then you would have a multi-party system even using the existing districts etc. If you had districts all of equal size (and didn't have the Senate) but still used first past the post, you would still have a two party system and they would still each hold about half the seats, but the positions of the parties would change to reflect the change in the electoral map.
Democrats like to think this would benefit them, but it's not as simple as "left gets more representation" at all. It would change what Democrats are (and what Republicans are).
For example, the current system causes rural areas to be over-represented, but rural areas have lower incomes, and changing that would increase the representation of higher income people. A large proportion of US federal spending exists to transfer wealth from under-represented populations to over-represented populations as political arbitrage of the difference in representation, so changing it could plausibly cause government programs to be cut as you increase the representation of the people currently paying for them at the expense of the current recipients.
Not all of that is necessarily bad but it's definitely not simple or anything that cleanly aligns with traditional notions of right vs. left.
Obvious example: Ideologically, agricultural subsidies are textbook socialism but are currently held in place by Republicans and might be the first thing on the chopping block.