3 ms·
"If I give you my public key, say I post it on my web site, how can you be sure that it's really my key? Maybe my site has been hacked and I don't even know it.
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
"If I give you my public key, say I post it on my web site, how can you be sure that it's really my key? Maybe my site has been hacked and I don't even know it. Or maybe someone tampers with the site content between the time it leaves my server and arrives at your browser (though TLS is supposed to address that).
We could get on a phone call and I you could read the key back to me. The problem with this approach is that keys are long. A 4096-bit RSA key, for example, encoded in hexadecimal, is 1024 characters long."
If trust the "phone" and phone numbers but not the "internet" and IP numbers, then why not just use modems to transfer the public key.
Is the assumption that it would be impossible for both the person's website and his phone to be simultaneously compromised.
- pants2 3y agoMy favorite solution to this is probably ENS (Ethereum Name Service) - you can link your public key to a domain name, essentially, and it's extremely verifiable and widely adopted.
- uxp8u61q 3y agoWhat does this bring to the table over having txt records at e.g., _key.example.com? Why add a bunch of intermediaries?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoDNSCurve was putting public keys into NS records before Ethereum existed. The subdomain for the nameserver contains the public key. See https://dnscurve.org/integration.html https://dnscurve.org/integration.html For example, example.com. IN NS uz5bcx1nh80x1r17q653jf3guywz7cmyh5jv0qjz0unm56lq7rpj8l.example.com.
- archero 3y agoWhen I read that I thought about the ability to replicate someone’s voice using AI. How would you know it’s me on the other end reading you my key over the phone? Then again, you would need a substantial amount of audio from me to accurately train a model of my voice.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agohttps://www.vice.com/en/article/3k7mgn/baidu-deep-voice-software-can-clone-anyones-voice-with-just-37-seconds-of-audio https://www.vice.com/en/article/3k7mgn/baidu-deep-voice-soft...
- notatoad 3y agotrusting a phone call means a whole lot more than trusting your phone's hardware. calling somebody lets you recognize their voice, mannerisms, personal knowledge, etc. spoofing that is many degrees more advanced than getting some spyware onto a phone that can intercept keys.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoIf it's someone the person has never talked to before how would the person recognise voice, mannerisms, personal knowledge, etc. Why might someone trust a phone number more than trusting an IP address. Is the network qualititatvely different. Is it easier to "steal/take over a domain name or a server" than to "steal/take over a phone number or a phone". What if someone can do both.