2 ms·
Instead of hiding behind your downvotes, you could come and argue logically, on the planetary impact of 300 or 400 less SUVs on downtown London or Paris...
by belter 3y ago
Instead of hiding behind your downvotes, you could come and argue logically, on the planetary impact of 300 or 400 less SUVs on downtown London or Paris...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you could come and argue logically, on the planetary impact of 300 or 400 less SUVs on downtown London or Paris New Yorker here. They’re loud and take up more space and navigate our tight corners awkwardly when driven by nonprofessional drivers. I broadly believe in abolishing street side parking, and making in-city parking more expensive. I drive a car in the suburbs, and feel that when I take a rideshare downtown it should be expensive. > hiding behind your downvotes Don't do this [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- belter 3y agoI am arguing on the pollution argument. - SUVs constitute only a fraction of the total vehicles on the road. Even if pollution taxes successfully deter some SUV drivers, the overall impact on city-wide emissions is marginal - Imposing higher taxes on SUVs in downtown areas will shift the problem rather than solve it. Drivers will choose to drive around these areas, increasing emissions by driving longer distances. - Less SUVs means more space for smaller cars. At the end 3 cars will make the same pollution as an older SUV. The modern ones are frequently hybrid. Another focus on symbolic actions rather than tackling the larger issues of urban pollution...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> SUVs constitute only a fraction of the total vehicles on the road They also constitute a disproportionate fraction of the damage [1]. > Imposing higher taxes on SUVs in downtown areas will shift the problem rather than solve it It also deters their purchase. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37297647/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37297647/
- eesmith 3y ago> Another focus on symbolic actions rather than tackling the larger issues of urban pollution... Paris is doing far more than this to tackle urban pollution. Even at the end of this article: "Under Hidalgo, Paris has for years raised pressure on drivers by increasing parking costs and gradually banning diesel vehicles, while expanding the bicycle lane network in the congested capital. The city has reduced the number of on-street parking spaces in order to make drivers use underground parking." That doesn't even mention the new low-emissions zones. ("The restricted traffic zone in Paris covers the entire city center and is operational from Monday to Friday, between 8 am and 8 pm. During these hours, access to the heart of the city is limited to vehicles with specific permissions. This means that, during peak urban activity, the ZCR helps alleviate traffic congestion and reduce pollution levels, ultimately contributing to a healthier and more pedestrian-friendly urban environment in one of Europe's most iconic cities." - https://parkimeter.com/en/blog/paris-limited-traffic-zone-france-city-center https://parkimeter.com/en/blog/paris-limited-traffic-zone-fr... ) At what point is it no longer symbolic? > Drivers will choose to drive around these areas, increasing emissions by driving longer distances. If they can drive around these areas then why would they care about the increased parking costs in those areas? Either they are going to park there or they are not. And, many of those drivers have other transportation options; it isn't like "once a driver always a driver."