6 ms·
Tree plantations are not the environmental solution they’re purported to be
- nubinetwork 3y agoPaywall
- nouryqt 3y agohttps://archive.is/2JIMw https://archive.is/2JIMw
- ooterness 3y agohttps://archive.is/2JIMw https://archive.is/2JIMw
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI really, really loathe it when scientists advocate for something (in this case planting tons of trees) and then get faux shocked when people use that information to their economic benefit ("I didn't mean plant trees and still burn fossil fuels!") A good analogy to me is the "anti-fat" nutrition crowd in the 90s (remember "the food pyramid" anyone??) I was reading an article about this whole debacle a while back, and remember one scientist lamenting "The advice on its own was good advice, but we never imagined the rise of Snack Wells." If anyone doesn't know, Snack Wells were a cookie brand in the 90s that were fat-free but loaded with sugar. They had the effect of getting you just as fat (they had a ton of calories), with probably a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, but with no fat they left you feeling hungry and they tasted a bit like cardboard. But the scientist's defense was utter baloney. Of course if you convince the populace that fat is evil and you can avoid weight gain just by avoiding dietary fat that food companies will respond accordingly. The same thing applies here. It's ridiculous for a scientist to think that his report about how planting lots of trees can counteract fossil fuel emissions wouldn't be latched on to by fossil fuel companies to say they "offset" their new emissions by planting more trees.
- WalterBright 3y agoFossil fuel companies don't have emissions, their customers do. When I drive my car, it's me emitting CO2, not the gas company. But I know it's expedient to shift the blame to the oil companies.
- buttercraft 3y agoSoooo... scientists should not release their results? Scientists should make policy? Or what?
- twiceaday 3y agoSome science gets done to gather metrics. Those metrics get oversimplified into broad public advice. Following this advice to the letter circumvents both the public messaging intent and the related science. "Do what we meant not what we said." I would put most of the blame on the science communicators / policy advisers. But it also doesn't help that there is a large mismatch between how definitive nutritional science is vs how hungry for science-based nutritional advice the public seems to be.
- tsimionescu 3y agoMuch of this nutritional "science" has been made into public advice by large swaths of the medical establishment, by people's own doctors, by public health authorities. We're not talking about advice people took from reading Reader's Digest or some health magazine.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoScientists should stop trying to make policy off the back of their studies, which are too narrow to provide a full picture of something like food and environmental issues.
- bluGill 3y agoThe problem as as the public I need to have/create useful policy. Studies are a lot better than my "gut feeling". Sometimes my "gut" is right, but sometimes I conclude heavy objects fall faster than light objects. Thus I want scientists to study things and help figure out what policy will make the world better.
- specialist 3y agoTLDR: Protect and restore forest ecosystems. Just planting a bunch of trees doesn't accomplish that. I became a volunteer forest steward this year. I'm currently clearing invasives, to be replanted with locals. Bioremediation and creating new forests is fascinating. My "boss" has a whole playbook. Dozens of species carefully chosen for the site, planted just so, managed over time. Even factoring in soil conditions and "transplanting" soil from healthy areas. In 30 years, we'll have a small new forest. Long after I pass on. Wish I had studied biology and such when I was younger.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 11235813213455 3y agoMonocultures are just bad for the environment, it needs a lot of diversity and native species instead, basically just letting things grow is the solution along with consumming less, much less, spending less money (as money spent is roughly a unit of pollution)
- bertil 3y agoI wish people didn’t confuse forests and tree farms.
- lyjackal 3y agoIn already destroyed eco systems, “Just letting things grow” tends to lead to unhealthy monoculture of invasive species. Where I live, it’s mostly a bunch of buckthorn, autumn olive, and honeysuckle. Maybe they’ll eventually heal themselves, but that’s on a much larger timescale than humans. Seems like a good idea for our own well being to contribute to healing those ecosystems faster.
- bytearray 3y agoThe only real solution is fewer humans.
- jack_riminton 3y agoYou first
- wodenokoto 3y agoSaudi spend a lot of effort promoting their Green program at COP28. They are aiming at 10 billion trees, if I remember correctly. That place is a desert for a reason other than "nobody got around to planting trees". I really wonder what they need to do in order to start and maintain such a large forest. Will it ever become self sustainable?
- bertil 3y agoI don’t know about the specific local conditions there, but there have been more violent floods in Yemen and the UEA. Sudden precipitation is —oddly— somewhat common in Arabia and usually trickle through ergs, river beds empty most of the year, and sometimes captured by water walls, feeding oasis. The last few years have seen more violent incidents, overflowing ergs leading to floods, changes in temperature in the Indian Ocean, and more water in the monsoon-like pattern, I’m not sure. It might make sense to adapt to the changing climate than the one they’ve known until now. If tree-supported water basins can handle more water than ergs, that might be relevant terraforming. It’s the same in “Northern” Europe: Paris, Berlin, London, Amsterdam. Those cities had hot summers and needed fountains, but not so hot that they needed adaptations like shading all plazas with trees, having every building extend with parapets to shade the inside, etc. Paris has Venetian blinds (meant to let the air through but keep the sun out in summer), but they are not common in London, for instance. All those cities are now thinking of having gree water-culvert to complement storm drains. Changing what we think of as normal might be necessary.
- peteradio 3y agoAren't there a lot of desert areas that were created by overgrazing goats i.e. not natural?
- throwaway5752 3y agoThat is an oversimplification of an existing theory, it is not proven: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/what-really-turned-sahara-desert-green-oasis-wasteland-180962668/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/what-really-tu.... Note: "It’s important to note that the green Sahara always would’ve turned back into a desert even without humans doing anything—that’s just how Earth’s orbit works, says geologist Jessica Tierney, an associate professor of geoscience at the University of Arizona. Moreover, according to Tierney, we don’t necessarily need humans to explain the abruptness of the transition from green to desert."
- darth_avocado 3y agoTree plantation was supposed to be a supplement to protecting existing forests, not a replacement. Anyway, monoculture is bad. Restorative initiatives are way more effective. On that note, I like Mossy Earth (https://www.mossy.earth/ https://www.mossy.earth/). They have a YouTube channel and a non profit that works on restorative initiatives. I’m not affiliated to them in any way, I just find their projects very interesting.
- oatmeal1 3y agoThe only solutions people with power are interested in are the ones that don't upset the status quo. Of course, those are the least effective solutions.
- votepaunchy 3y agoA politician or party elected to “fight” climate change has no incentive to reduce emissions, just as pharmaceutical and health care companies have no incentive to improve health. The only incentive is for ineffective projects or changes so radical that other parties can be blamed for obstruction.