3 ms·
The economy and the economic plight of the bottom x% of society are not the same thing. Nor is every single case of homelessness necessarily related to the eco
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
The economy and the economic plight of the bottom x% of society are not the same thing.
Nor is every single case of homelessness necessarily related to the economy.
- willcipriano 3y ago> The economy and the economic plight of the bottom x% of society are not the same thing. It used to be the job of the left to argue the opposite. In my best sarcastic Tucker Carlson voice: "you judge a society by its worst off"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eropple 3y agoIf you want to solve a problem, you have to describe it accurately first. "The economy is very strong" and "the bottom X% of society are having a bad time of it" are both statements that can be true at the same time. Further, if the first isn't true, the solution set for the second is differently constrained. And as near as I can tell the bottommost segment of the American populace is, in material and numerical terms, generally seeing a more positive rate-of-change than pre-COVID; lower-end wages are increasing faster than they have in most of my lifetime and are significantly outpacing the inflation that got everybody hairshirting last year. The thing that the doomer set doesn't love to acknowledge is that so much of that dooming is sourced from precarious tech workers or members of/aspirational members of the media, who are getting hammered (in other words, the economic recovery seems K-shaped) and are in turn using their outsized megaphones to convince everybody else that it's a universal problem.
- willcipriano 3y ago> "The economy is very strong" and "the bottom X% of society are having a bad time of it" are both statements that can be true at the same time Not to a liberal (or even Adam Smith). The purpose of a economy is it benefits the people, that's why the people allow "the economy" to exist in the first place, if the common people aren't benefiting the economy isn't doing it's job and therefore cannot be "strong". It's only strong if you think the economy exists to serve mainly the professional managerial class as well as the elites and perhaps the claims of strength reveal the true thoughts of the speaker.
- pandaman 3y agoCommon people != people who excluded themselves from the economy. Yet, even the OP who started this thread, while excluding him or herself from the economy still benefits from it, owning a vehicle, getting welfare payments and even receiving medical attention. Compare this to somebody who'd decided not to work in a poor country. You won't see posts on HN from a homeless in Mali, for example, because such a person, at best, would have been preoccupied with survival and would not have time or means for a critique of modern society on an internet forum.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoPerhaps. But when so many aren't doing so well and they are force-fed "the economy is great", and *this is key* those disenfranchised vote...well, I hope you see where this is going. The Federal gov (read: both parties) can't keep using aggregated numbers to hide the details and the hurting. Ppl aren't that naive any more. The world has changed. The gov's reporting of the economy has not. The more that disconnect widens, the worse the potential for sociopolitical fallout. We've been seeing that and yet how has Uncle Sam adjusted? Please don't shoot the messenger.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIndeed yet the data says these are mostly first-time homeless. So more likely to be related to rents and healthcare rising much faster than wages.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoAnd rents have to do with supply of housing relative to demand, which are local issues that can be holding the national economy back. So one way to frame it would be the national economy is doing well despite significant problems in housing supply/demand.
- surge 3y agoOne of the dichotomies I've noticed is the talking points about affordable housing juxtaposed with saying the concern with "illegal immigration" by the opposite side of the political spectrum is overblown. My thing is, even if its not the main issue causing issues with demand, I don't see how you can bring in nearly 3 million "undocumented migrants in a year" who are all going to compete for the lowest tier of the housing market, and outcompete single parents, etc on what they can afford in rent (since many have several adults rooming together and sharing rent). If you only have so many affordable apartments/houses etc to go around in a town/neighborhood/borough, etc, an influx of a few thousand, especially in high population areas is going to drive rents up and create constraints on the market. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/migrant-border-crossings-fiscal-year-2022-topped-276-million-breaking-rcna53517 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/migrant-border-... It's certainly not helping. I don't see how you can not link these two issues, if you bring in migrants, documented or not (or not migrating through legal methods), they need housing, and its going to be the undocumented ones competing for housing in the sector with our most vulnerable citizens. There seems to be some level of cognitive dissonance politically, at least in the media, when it comes to these two issues. Maybe those on the ground notice it or have tried to call it out. But if I can see it from my middle class suburbia, I don't see how this is getting missed, if not outright ignored. All that to say, while certainly a local issue, this is a national issue I feel is at play here that local governments (short of stunts like bussing ppl to Martha's Vineyard or NYC), have no control over.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoSerious question: If not the economy, then what?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI do not understand your question. If you are suggesting the common vernacular of “the (national) economy” should refer to the plight of the bottom x%, then I guess that is one opinion to have.
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> Serious question: If not the economy, then what? That's a very good question, however you ask it. A problem when you go looking for the root cause of things, if you can bear to ask "why?" more than five times, is that you can go around in circles or start seeing things that aren't there. That's definitely going to happen if you go looking for the end of rainbow like "The Economy" [0]. Other nebulous categories like "mental health" or "immigration" don't add much to the conversation. but kick the can into someone else's camp. It also a difficult question because in a sense it's a void question in world where we reduce _everything_ to "economics" - all human affairs, structures and processes - to the point where it seems there's nothing left that lies outside the realm of economics. (Maybe that tells us "economics" has lost its power as a concept word and pursuit, if we have problems that seem to lie outside of it.) So when I hear someone say "It's not about 'The Economy'" what I'm really hearing isn't "it has nothing to do with economics" (because everything does), but "I don't think economists can understand and fix this". And that's a valid observation - that people who think as economists have a serious blind-spot and defecit of real power. [0] If there isn't already there should be a South Park episode where "The Economy" is kept in a glass box at the City Hall and Eric steals it to sell at school.